Good Stuff

Yesss Update. When im driving home i totaly going to re-autoread this twice

That was wishful thinking, though. Even if that somehow worked, it would only take one slip-up to bring that house of lies toppling down around us. Not to mention, with Luna... lying was as good as impossible. Lying to the degree of pretending that we aren’t actually sisters? It would have taken a decade and she would have said something, whether by accident or due to feeling guilty.

To bad Starswirl has no timejump spell...

Twilight & Shining Armor... Neat.

born of 2 immortal gods i highly doubt summer and luna have genetic diseases for any child to enhairet, they are after all immortal and had never been sick in their lives

10921371
That might be the case, but the risk of incest comes from the shared genetic code, so to speak. But why worry so much when you have a stupidly designed ritual that could screw the favors of 50/50 of defects to whatever odds you actually want to have, huh? :P

Edit 2022, March 19th: I've since been corrected about the odds of defects. Don't belive the first source of information Google throws at you and always triple-check, folks.

10921326
Paradox. 'nough said.

10921355
Wrong pony there. At least, one of 'em.

So we have two thestrals (possibly alicorns with thestral characteristics) in the Royal family now. I theorise that with them being twins and all its Sam and Toby (or was it Tom I Cant remember) cos of all the clone business.

My question is.,How would Bluey react to this totally legitimate heir of the throne? There has to be some wacky hijinks involving him trying to either eliminate them or gain favour with them.

10922592

So we have two thestrals (possibly alicorns with thestral characteristics) in the Royal family now. I theorise that with them being twins and all its Sam and Toby (or was it Tom I Cant remember) cos of all the clone business.

I'm not going to confirm or deny anything here (it's Tobias not Tom, no rocks to be found here :P). Although, I do feel like pointing this out: Thestrals aren't the only ones that drink blood. I would go so far as to even say they got that trait from somewhere else.

I would go so far as to even say they got that trait from somewhere else.

That there is a conundrum. It's not somepony, someone or something but somewhere. I haven't seen anything in Eqeustria that has a bloodsucking trait other than the batponiesor or vamponies.

Many species and races haven't shown enough of their dietary activities to draw a conclusion so this could be a multiverse thing. So either the children are multiverse entities or vampires.

10922629

That there is a conundrum. It's not somepony, someone or something but somewhere. I haven't seen anything in Eqeustria that has a bloodsucking trait other than the batponiesor or vamponies.

Now... what does that imply about Summer, Tia, and Luna?

10922634
Now this brings up even more questions. So it's Remnant or Fringe related and I haven't seen enough of both to make a guess so someone take this info and help meh

10922657
I mean, you weren't wrong with the bat pony and vampony thing. I suppose I can spoiler that much since those two are pretty much the only ones that suck blood. *shrug*

Especially now of all times, damnit. I couldn’t be pregnant and bring a foal into the world when Platinum was just about to be released in a few short years. Not to mention that Luna and I are siblings, I can’t possibly be pregnant with her foal. We could and would never risk that, I know that. Definitely not me. Absolutely. Not. Me.

Wait… Twi…? Don’t tell me that miscarriage was actually… her…?

10923394
10923406
Haaahh... the emotional journey observed in those two comments is just... *wipes away tear*
I'm just going to leave this here:
10904187

10924001
meanie

Ahh.. the joys of unprotected sex

10923406
I recommend you to Re-read ch. 21.

10927486
Are you sure? I'm pretty sure I got it all.

“Oh, the poor mare, having to go through a miscarriage,” Liz commentated, letting out a sad gasp at what she read. “Poor Velvet, I feel for her.”

Velvet, as in Twilight Velvet, Twilight's mother.

Luna and I left a small mountain of bits on the property of House Star after I broke down crying in their backyard. I’m really sorry for what happened to poor Twilight Velvet. The mare would no doubt be too depressed to try again, so I wanted her to at least live the rest of her life in luxury.

And here is Summer's prediction of Velvet not trying again, thus at least wanting her to live in luxury. Admittedly this is Summer's prediction, a prediction she made after over a year of being away from her ponies. But with her being over a thousand years old, I'm sure that she'd know her ponies well enough to make an accurate prediction even after a year of absence...

...

Unless there was some external intervention...

10927567
But looking at this part from ch. 21.

An ancient spell, cast to save the life of a daughter, latched onto the two other, now broken, souls as well. Too bad the intended recipient could only grant a new home for two of them.

It doomed one soul to wander between realities, until... at one point...

That poor soul, too, started to feel a pull, granting it a new home of its own in a world so similar to the one that Tabetha’s and Tobias’ souls got pulled towards. What that soul did not know, though, was that it was thrown back in time due to the ‘timely’ departure of one meddling observer.

And even then, Shining was firstborn no?

10927584
Well, while that does make a lot of sense, as cryptic as it is, (Curse you Feynna for actually confusing me! I shalt have vengeance. Vengences I say with a hint ponies! And it will be cute ponies I say!), I wouldn't take it as defined evidence.

Actually, I suspect Summer's twins are actually Tabetha and Tobia. In that case, your evidence could be dismissed because if we look at the provided paragraph:

An ancient spell, cast to save the life of a daughter(Suspectedly Twilight), latched onto the two other(Tabetha and Tobias), now broken, souls as well. Too bad the intended recipient(Unknown) could only grant a new home for two of them.

In such a case, if the new home for Tabetha and Tobias is indeed Summer's womb, that would imply the intended recipient of the spell was Summer(?) Which would not make sense as the spell was cast to save Twilight, thus a flaw in your logic.

Evidence backing this theory up would be that Tabetha and Tobias are suspected to be alicorns, and the fact that they fulfilled the requirement of needing to be reborn enforces the fact that the recipient, was in fact Summer, which again wouldn't make sense of the spell was cast to save Twilight.

As a side thought, it's possible that the intended recipient was meaning the mare that would give birth to Twilight. If so, then the likely intended recipient would've been Twilight Velvet, but if that's the case, it leaves the mystery of who truly are the souls within Summer's womb

(Actually, if the intended recipient was indeed actually supposed to be Summer, that suggest that it was not being drunk and messing up the spell that caused the pregnancy, but actually a third party external factor that may or may not have cast the spell whilst the two were having drunk sex. But I find this unlikely as it's heavily suggested that it was them messing up the spell that caused Summer's pregnancy.)

It's likely that her soul was probably tossed off into another world to be saved later in the story- SHIT. Did I just prove that Twi, is in fact, alive? Wait, no, that's the answer doesn't cover up who the intended recipient is(?) I think? Fuck, I just disproved myself, didn't I?

Ahem, as I've said, curse you Feynna, for make an exquisitely well down story capable of tricking me such! I shall have revenge for confusing me down this rabbit hole of confusion! My vengeance shall be... Well, actually it can't be swift since I said I'd have it someday... If this was your goal, congratulations, you have successfully tricked me to confuse myself, Feynna. I will have vengeance(if I ever come up with something)!

Also, thanks again for giving yet another show to binge on. RWBY, now Fringe? Oh boy, any more and I'll get my trusty newspaper to swat you with for overloading me with good shows to watch.

10927607

An ancient spell, cast to save the life of a daughter(Suspectedly Twilight), latched onto the two other(Tabetha and Tobias), now broken, souls as well. Too bad the intended recipient(Summer) could only grant a new home for two of them.

I have no idea how you could get that confused about it. Why do I even write the totally dumb smut scene if that isn’t the conclusion you come to automatically? :P
Aside from that, the miscarriage was there to make you guys jump to conclusions (as some of you have already proven :P). No, it isn’t Shining Armor and neither is it Twilight Sparkle. You will see soon enough who Tabby and “Toby” are going to be. For that matter, “Sam” will also make an appearance, just... not in this story.

10927997
I think too much

10934929
Thanks!
Took me some time until I was happy with the end result for that one, but it was well worth it. To be honest, it was kinda obvious in hindsight what would happen after every little instance of Platinum falling further and further into her hatred for Tia, Luna, and Summer. Maybe not quite the possession part, but definitely the 'she is going to do something stupendously bad' thing.

Sunset and Twilight as Sisters is new... Guess you killed of Shining so noone even try Ship him with Cadance, Twilight or Sunset? Still... A waste. He would be perfect vs Sombra or Tirek. Become a hero giving his life for one of the Mane six or someone else...

11161852
Say... how many times have you read this story already? I know for at least once...

11161869
8 times, why?

11162352
Just wondering about that comment. Also, eight times, wow. Just... wow.

10921396
Do you know that this isn't how genetics works? Where did you get these 50/50 in the first place?

11184618
Right, forgot that one has to reply within the chapter for the whole notification thing to work correctly. Anyway, yes, I am aware I am grossly simplicating things and probably getting things wrong, but I'm not a biology major and neither do I care enough to go into a topic that's as controcersial as this one because I'm not nearly interested enough to know how badly one has to be a screw up to end up producing offspring with your sibling. As far as I know, severe genetic defects have a chance of about-ish fourty percent with incest involved (I rounded that one up because, eh... close enough *shrug*), though you're free to correct me on that one and the thing with the main risk of incest being the shared genetic code.

Also, I did see a study in regards to this once, can't tell which one and I might have not read the article thoroughly enough. Then, theres also the whole 'less genetic variety' thing that goes hand in hand with the shared genetic code of being siblings, but as I said, I'm not a biology major, nor a genetics expert and whatever else you could think of. I write stuff with ponies that's not appropriate for children.