Wow very good can you make it so that later on he stills holds hatred for the ponies so he just pretends to be kind so later he can stap them in the back
I'm not really a fan of this "Anon" storie's because I cant really make a connection with the protagonist. But I think it's a good story and I look for more in the future.
You now live in an alleyway, living off the trash. It wasn't so bad, you learned where had the best food and where to get a new box after a storm.
I would recommend with whole heartedness that the comma be replaced with a semi-colon: ---------> ;
You thanked whatever deity that decided to smile on you that day.
Now in terms of grammar it would make more sense to remove the 'that' however it is still acceptable for it's use. It's just compare the two sentences out loud, and see which one you prefer. I just go on what's correct in grammar terms, but you choose whatever you like.:twilight sheepish:
That and the constant giggling.
*Sigh* I was dreading this. This is what is known as a 'fragment' these are the most despicable things to ever happen to the english language and I loathe them. You see it's just a small piece of information on it's one with little context if read without any.
You could hear the sound of hooves scraping metal, and the sound of the lid opening and closing. That and the constant giggling that followed each time.
Now the orange is just a change I would make in order to be rid of this fragment.
The sounds of hooves in the alley causes you to stiffen.
Another grammatically correct term unfortunately. Merely change this to 'cause' that is all. If you say it out loud it still makes sense doesn't it? Don't fret, this is a common mistake, it happens to the best of us.
This is it. The life or death moment
I really hate fragments.Now I'd recumbent changing that full stop that separates 'This is it' and 'The life or death moment' to a colon. Like this: Hello! Simple change and removes fragment, everyone's happy.
You breath a sigh of relief and remove the cardboard camouflage
Simple spelling/grammer error. Change to 'breathe'
You don't know if your heart can take it if you let her release the flood gates.
Floodgates is one word! Who'd a thought! No one, that's who!
"Ok ok, I'm sorry. Just please don't cry." You feel yourself start tearing up.
Place a comma between these two, okay? Otherwise it is just a repeated word, not an actual piece of the sentence.
You two just sat there in the alley way, bawling your eyes out.
Alleyway is actually one word. Sorry.
Every inch of your being told you to run and hide. You hear shouting behind you.
Change to 'tells' otherwise it is not what occurred, it is an order, meaning you'd have to change 'your' to 'you're'
"But princess, what about the king and queen?" She starts to pet your head. It feel good to be comforted.
Um… I think you meant 'feels' Right?
She leans in a whispers in your ear.
Final error. Simply change to 'and'
I can honestly say I liked this… quite a lot.Not many fics have you in the POV of a child and it is very nice to see refreshing new POV for a change. I liked how quickly your character warms up to Celestia, very nice. I also eagerly await the next chapters. A definite 9/10 (Which it only gets because I prefer first or third person stories. So consider it a 10, okay?
i'm intrested in where you're going with this, so i'll fave it for now.
allthough we haven't read much of the story yet, i think this story could be much better without the sex tag; because not all romance stories need one.
I like the concept of the story, I think I've only seen one other like it and I'm interested to see where this one will go, its not a bad first chapter but I wouldn't say its a good one either. There are a few things that are holding this chapter back, at least for me.
Something I found out of place is the guards are ashamed of having friends and family where Anon lack's both of those, not that they almost killed and innocent 'creature'. It's also difficult to believe that Anon could survive more than 2 months living on the streets if the beatings and such occur, not to mention the lack of protein he would have access too.
Why does Luna speak in ye old English and everyone else in modern English? Strange that a filly would speak in something that can be considered another language,
Can you please clarify how old Celestia is? When Celestia said "W-Why are you s-so mean." it sounded like something an 8 to 10 year old would say, this is supported by the quote "this little filly", but when she said "Do you have any idea on how that makes me feel? Knowing ponies could be so heartless." I would place her more in her mid to late teens.
How would a homeless kid receive a letter about an offer to join a circus? If its the case where a pony hands him the letter what is the point of the letter in the first place if said pony can simply tell Anon about the offer.
How have the King and Queen not heard of Anon? One would think they would be informed of an unknown species in their capital city, and that's disregarding the fact magic seems to have no effect on him.
ThatFriendlyGuy has already pointed out all the spelling and grammatical errors I could see and some I didn't so I won't go through that.
As I said before not a bad chapter but not good either, until I see some improvement I'm going to hold off my like for the story. I hope this helps in some way or another and I hope I can put my like up there soon. Can't wait to read more. Sincerely, TheMagicalBrony
4408874 Alright. Let me answer some of your questions/concerns
Something I found out of place is the guards are ashamed of having friends and family where Anon lack's both of those,
My thinking is was along the lines of, if you knew someone who lost everything while you were able to still live happily, would you not feel bad. It isn't about them being ashamed for having family, just sad about the other person's loss.
It's also difficult to believe that Anon could survive more than 2 months living on the streets if the beatings and such occur, not to mention the lack of protein he would have access too.
There are a lot of kids that live on the street... more than we are care to talk about. Yet, they still get along and adapt.
Why does Luna speak in ye old English and everyone else in modern English?
I just threw it in for giggles.
Can you please clarify how old Celestia is?
She is one year older than Anon and Luna is one year younger.
How would a homeless kid receive a letter about an offer to join a circus? If its the case where a pony hands him the letter what is the point of the letter in the first place if said pony can simply tell Anon about the offer.
I got nothin' besides preference of communication.
How have the King and Queen not heard of Anon? One would think they would be informed of an unknown species in their capital city, and that's disregarding the fact magic seems to have no effect on him.
That is up to the reader. I have not thought that deep in the story to be honest.
As I said before not a bad chapter but not good either, until I see some improvement I'm going to hold off my like for the story. I hope this helps in some way or another and I hope I can put my like up there soon. Can't wait to read more.
I hope I will be able to get you to press that green thumb. Thanks.
I understand him being afraid now, because he is young and has had awful experiences. But I do hope you don't overdo the amount he fears the ponies. As he gets older, fear would turn more and more into hatred. And a teenage or adult human that is immune to magic can be a very violent and very powerful fighter in the pony world. I do like the fact that he started here young not many fics I know of follow that concept. And I do think you characterized Celestia correctly, can't say for Luna because I haven't seen enough of her. Overall a nice fic so far, I look forward to more!
Ummm...Alright, yeah, I'll bite. This looks generally good, if not a bit frustrating but a story's credit is based on how much it makes you feel, right? Anyway, ya got my attention. Let's do this.
4408883 You'd be surprised. Or, if you'd stop to think about it, you wouldn't be surprised. What passes for a "proper home" has changed throughout history, and we once lived off of the land well enough.
I like this.
hope the next chapter comes out soon.
oohhhh that was nice....fav'd and I'll be waiting for more.
Wow very good can you make it so that later on he stills holds hatred for the ponies so he just pretends to be kind so later he can stap them in the back
Well, I'm glad to see it here!
I'm not really a fan of this "Anon" storie's because I cant really make a connection with the protagonist. But I think it's a good story and I look for more in the future.
I have not seen this kind of concept yet.... I want to see where this goes!
I would recommend with whole heartedness that the comma be replaced with a semi-colon: ---------> ;
Now in terms of grammar it would make more sense to remove the 'that' however it is still acceptable for it's use. It's just compare the two sentences out loud, and see which one you prefer. I just go on what's correct in grammar terms, but you choose whatever you like.:twilight sheepish:
*Sigh* I was dreading this. This is what is known as a 'fragment' these are the most despicable things to ever happen to the english language and I loathe them. You see it's just a small piece of information on it's one with little context if read without any.
Now the orange is just a change I would make in order to be rid of this fragment.
Another grammatically correct term unfortunately. Merely change this to 'cause' that is all. If you say it out loud it still makes sense doesn't it? Don't fret, this is a common mistake, it happens to the best of us.
I really hate fragments.Now I'd recumbent changing that full stop that separates 'This is it' and 'The life or death moment' to a colon. Like this: Hello! Simple change and removes fragment, everyone's happy.
Simple spelling/grammer error. Change to 'breathe'
Floodgates is one word! Who'd a thought! No one, that's who!
Place a comma between these two, okay? Otherwise it is just a repeated word, not an actual piece of the sentence.
Alleyway is actually one word. Sorry.
Change to 'tells' otherwise it is not what occurred, it is an order, meaning you'd have to change 'your' to 'you're'
Um… I think you meant 'feels' Right?
Final error. Simply change to 'and'
I can honestly say I liked this… quite a lot.Not many fics have you in the POV of a child and it is very nice to see refreshing new POV for a change. I liked how quickly your character warms up to Celestia, very nice. I also eagerly await the next chapters. A definite 9/10 (Which it only gets because I prefer first or third person stories. So consider it a 10, okay?
Could of been more creative with the name of the human
Otherwise this seems interesting
Just when I thought I saw every variant of a HIE...
Please, do go on.
Good stuff! I want more.
hmm I like this But id like it if you added some more detail to the surroundings and emotions.
i'm intrested in where you're going with this, so i'll fave it for now.
allthough we haven't read much of the story yet, i think this story could be much better without the sex tag; because not all romance stories need one.
4408455 anonXtia '_' i bet
4407858 I will take a look at that when I get the chance. Thank you
that....was ......awesome
*Grabs shotgun* "OKAY YOU HEARTLESS PONY BASTARDS TIME TO DIE!" Also fav.
I like the concept of the story, I think I've only seen one other like it and I'm interested to see where this one will go, its not a bad first chapter but I wouldn't say its a good one either. There are a few things that are holding this chapter back, at least for me.
Something I found out of place is the guards are ashamed of having friends and family where Anon lack's both of those, not that they almost killed and innocent 'creature'. It's also difficult to believe that Anon could survive more than 2 months living on the streets if the beatings and such occur, not to mention the lack of protein he would have access too.
Why does Luna speak in ye old English and everyone else in modern English? Strange that a filly would speak in something that can be considered another language,
Can you please clarify how old Celestia is? When Celestia said "W-Why are you s-so mean." it sounded like something an 8 to 10 year old would say, this is supported by the quote "this little filly", but when she said "Do you have any idea on how that makes me feel? Knowing ponies could be so heartless." I would place her more in her mid to late teens.
How would a homeless kid receive a letter about an offer to join a circus? If its the case where a pony hands him the letter what is the point of the letter in the first place if said pony can simply tell Anon about the offer.
How have the King and Queen not heard of Anon? One would think they would be informed of an unknown species in their capital city, and that's disregarding the fact magic seems to have no effect on him.
ThatFriendlyGuy has already pointed out all the spelling and grammatical errors I could see and some I didn't so I won't go through that.
As I said before not a bad chapter but not good either, until I see some improvement I'm going to hold off my like for the story. I hope this helps in some way or another and I hope I can put my like up there soon. Can't wait to read more.
Sincerely,
TheMagicalBrony
This poor kid is only 10 years old! I hope he finds an adequate home soon or he isn't going to last very long on his own!
I enjoyed reading this. I urge you to continue this story, my friend.
4408874 Alright. Let me answer some of your questions/concerns
My thinking is was along the lines of, if you knew someone who lost everything while you were able to still live happily, would you not feel bad. It isn't about them being ashamed for having family, just sad about the other person's loss.
There are a lot of kids that live on the street... more than we are care to talk about. Yet, they still get along and adapt.
I just threw it in for giggles.
She is one year older than Anon and Luna is one year younger.
I got nothin' besides preference of communication.
That is up to the reader. I have not thought that deep in the story to be honest.
I hope I will be able to get you to press that green thumb. Thanks.
Please. Please, continue this!
Also,
Umm, Solaris is actually a common name for Rule 63 Celestia. Just Saiyan.
americanfootballinternational.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/IT.jpg
This kid's an idiot
4409389 You posted on my story. I feel so honored!
4409393
It's a good premise, I haven't seen one like it in a while.
But, despite being scared, this kid is a bloody muppet. And it befuddles me as to why he didn't even say so much as "Hello".
Hmm, I'll be waiting for an update. I rarely judge on the first chapter, so here's hoping it captures my interest
I understand him being afraid now, because he is young and has had awful experiences. But I do hope you don't overdo the amount he fears the ponies. As he gets older, fear would turn more and more into hatred. And a teenage or adult human that is immune to magic can be a very violent and very powerful fighter in the pony world.
I do like the fact that he started here young not many fics I know of follow that concept. And I do think you characterized Celestia correctly, can't say for Luna because I haven't seen enough of her.
Overall a nice fic so far, I look forward to more!
This is great, i am really enjoying the story. Keep it up!
So...this is set in the past, right?
No chance of Anon somehow surviving 1000 years unless discord gets involved then, huh?
4410664 or he can be a nice memory of the past? :)
Ummm...Alright, yeah, I'll bite.
This looks generally good, if not a bit frustrating but a story's credit is based on how much it makes you feel, right?
Anyway, ya got my attention.
Let's do this.
ARRGH DAMMIT ONE CHANCE ONE FLIPPIN CHANCE
God damn racist ponies
I'm still sad for Anon, but...
i.ytimg.com/vi/4_gB-4uNa7U/hqdefault.jpg
i1.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/facebook/000/540/811/e45.png
"Hey Anon, do you like mmm bananas?"
4408883
You'd be surprised. Or, if you'd stop to think about it, you wouldn't be surprised. What passes for a "proper home" has changed throughout history, and we once lived off of the land well enough.