Sunset Shimmer is happy and fullfilled. Her life is perfectly normal and okay. She is a human, dating another human, Twilight Sparkle, with plenty of human friends.

But sometimes she wonders of Equestria, a world that spat her out.

But sometimes she wonders of Equestria, a world that didn't need her.

But what if it did?

What if Equestria needed her, permanently? What if her wildest abandoned dreams could come true? What if she had to choose between abandoning the human world, or abandoning Equestria for good?

What if she had to choose between two Twilights?

This story is a sequel to Equestria Ninja Girls: Magic in Manhattan and Equestria Ninja Girls: The Birthday Bounty Bash.

The Rainbooms and the Turtles got a distress call from the Titans. It’s up to the Rainbooms, Turtles, April, Casey, and their familiar allies to find Jaime Reyes/Blue Beetle before something terrible happens to him.

Equestria Ninjas is created by Wildcard25

This story is edited and proofreaded by Red Tagg and Jebens1

Disclaimer: Neither Jeb, Red Tagg, or I own My Little Pony, Batman, Owl House or Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (2012)

Cover art created by yours truly