After a successful date, Capper begins to believe that there can be something wonderful between him and Luna. But just as things were starting to get better, his past started catching up to him.
The story of the giving spirit has become quite popular and is a stain upon the Heartwarming holiday. However, when belief is forgotten, and the Heartwarming spirit dies, a much darker ancient spirit will come. And he only comes will one gift.
What first started out as a simple dare turns into a hellish nightmare as these groups of students find out the hard way that some things should be left untouched.
On Nightmare Night, Discord, Spike and Big Mac take on the challenge to eat the hottest chip in the world. Will they be able to do it or die trying? Luna thinks they'll die trying.
When ponies are unable to wake up from their dreams, it's up to Capper and Luna to work together to figure out what's going on and how to wake them up before it is too late.