• Published 28th Jul 2019
  • 3,608 Views, 312 Comments

Romantic Mischief - TheHardie-Boy

  • ...
20
 312
 3,608

Extra Credit (by Peni Parker)

“Hey, Jake,” Sandbar amiably said to me as I passed him in the hallway. “What’s up?”

“Hey, Sandbar,” I just as amiably said back. “I’m just heading to Twilight’s office. She said she wanted to see me about something.”

“Sounds good,” Sandbar replied as he walked away. “See ya around.”

“Later, Sandbar,” I said as I continued my journey towards Twilight’s office.

As I walked, I couldn’t help but wonder why it was Twilight wanted to see me. My mind began to race with about a million possible reasons for why the headmare had summoned me. Everything from simply wanting to see how I was doing to needing to tell me I was getting kicked out of school. Needless to say, I tried to keep my mind off of that last possibility. But for whatever reason, I wasn’t going to keep Twilight waiting. So I picked up my pace and hurried to the Headmare’s Office as fast as I could without running in the halls.

Once I made it to Twilight’s office, I took a deep, calming breath and knocked on the door.

“Yes?” I heard Twilight say from the other side.

“H-Hello?” I anxiously said as I opened the door enough to poke my head inside. “You wanted to see me, Headmare Twilight?”

“Ah, Jake. Yes, I did,” Twilight very formally answered. “Please, come in.”

As I opened the door more and entered the office, I noticed that Starlight Glimmer, the school’s guidance counselor, was there was well. She was standing off to Twilight’s right with a concerned look on her face, though I couldn’t tell why. I shot her a small smile, but she just looked away when I did. Something told me this wasn’t going to be a pleasant visit.

“Please, have a seat,” Twilight said to me, still sounding very formal, as she pointed to a chair located in front of her desk.

I couldn’t help but notice the look on Twilight’s face as I sat down. It was the same as Starlight’s: concerned. Yeah, this definitely wasn’t going to be a pleasant visit.

“Do you know why I asked to see you today, Jake?” Twilight asked me.

“N-No, ma’am,” I apprehensively answered. “I can’t say I do.”

“I asked you here because of something Starlight here brought to my attention,” Twilight explained.

The headmare then looked over at Starlight and gave her a small nod, as if telling her that that was her cue to speak.

“I was going over your file the other day, Jake,” Starlight started to say. “And I found something that was, well…concerning.”

“C-Concerning?” I bewilderingly asked.

“Yes, I’m afraid so,” Starlight solemnly affirmed. “There’s no easy way to say this, but…it seems as though your grades aren’t high enough in Rarity’s Generosity class for you to graduate this semester.”

“What?!” I shouted in disbelief, exerting every ounce of self-control I had not to leap up from my seat as I did so. “N-No, that can’t be right! I mean, I admit that my grades in Miss Rarity’s class aren’t the best, b-but this has to be some kind of mistake!”

“I thought that might be the case as well,” Starlight told me in a very calming fashion. “That’s why I brought it to Twilight’s attention. But unfortunately, it isn’t a mistake.”

I quickly turned my attention to Twilight, who was simply staring at me with a very demure expression.

“I double-checked everything, Jake,” she sympathetically spoke up. “But Starlight was right in her initial finding. Your grade in Generosity class is too low, and you won’t be able to graduate this semester.”

I could feel my heart quickly go from beating like a jackhammer to not beating at all. This wasn’t happening, it couldn’t be happening.

“Please,” I began to plead. “Please, I-I have to graduate this semester. If I don’t, my parents will kill me. There has to be something I can do to boost my grade up. Anything.”

“I’m sorry, Jake,” Twilight sincerely consoled. “Truly, I am. But at this point in the semester, there isn’t anything that can be done to get your Generosity grade up high enough. Even if you aced every remaining exam, it wouldn’t be enough.”

I felt like I was going to cry. How could I’ve let this happen? How could I’ve slipped so much in Generosity class? I didn’t have an answer, but at this point it didn’t really matter, did it? I was going to get kicked out of school with one semester to go. I was a dead man when I got home. Game over, man, game over.

“Hang on a moment, Twilight,” Starlight suddenly chimed in. “There might be something Jake can do to up his Generosity grade enough.”

Hearing Starlight say that brought a light of hope back into my eyes. For Twilight though, it just gave her a look of confusion.

“And what’s that Starlight?” the headmare inquired.

“Could you excuse us for a moment, Jake?” Starlight asked just before she used her magic to create a soundproof bubble around herself and Twilight.

Starlight’s bubble was transparent, so while I couldn’t hear what she and Twilight were talking about, I could still see them talking. At first, I tried reading their lips, but quickly gave up when I realized that I can’t read lips. Everything seemed fine for a while, but then all of a sudden, Twilight’s face lit up in surprise at something Starlight had said. She then looked over at me, which caused me to shift my gaze so that it didn’t appear I was watching them. By the time I felt it was all right to look back at the two mares, Starlight got rid of the bubble.

“My apologize for that, Jake,” Twilight said, sounding a tad flustered. “Thank you for waiting.”

“N-No problem,” I said.

“Now, just to be clear,” Twilight then said. “You’re willing to do anything to pass Generosity class, correct?”

There was something about the way Twilight had said the word ‘anything’ that was a tad off-putting. However, at this point I really was desperate enough to do anything to pass.

“That’s right,” I adamantly confirmed. “Anything.”

“That’s good,” Starlight sensuously said as her horn light up, and I heard the sound of the office door locking. “Because Twilight and I have thought of a very…special way you can boost your grade.”

“Oh yes, a very special way indeed,” Twilight just as sensuously concurred.

It was at this point that I noticed both Twilight and Starlight staring at me with lidded eyes.

“A-And what way i-is that?” I nervously asked.

“Oh, just a way that will show us how generous you really are,” Twilight answered as she made her way around the desk.

“And how badly you want to graduate,” Starlight added as she made her way around the desk from the other side.

“I…I still don’t t-think I understand,” I said just as both mares were practically on top of me, even though I was about ninety nine percent sure I did.

“That’s okay,” Starlight voluptuously whispered into my ear as she started to rub my chest. “You’ll understand soon.”

Very soon,” Twilight whispered into my other ear as she started rubbing my leg.

“Eep,” was all I could manage to say.


About an hour and a half later, I was lying on the floor of the Headmare’s Office under a blanket, that Twilight had made magically appear, with Twilight snuggled up on my left and Starlight snuggled up on my right. While both Twilight and Starlight hadn’t felt the need for a blanket, I’d asked for one because I was starting to get a little cold without any of my clothes on.

Anyway, we were all snuggled together and basking in the afterglow of our lovemaking when I’d decided to say something.

“That was a lot of fun,” I said.

“Yeah, it really was,” Twilight agreed. “I’m glad you suggested we try some roleplaying, Starlight.”

“I’m just glad you guys agreed to it,” Starlight replied. “When I got the idea for trying the ‘I really need to pass this class’ fantasy, I wasn’t sure how you’d both feel about it.”

“I admit I had my doubts at first,” I confessed. “But I really started getting into it. I even started to think I was actually a student here.”

Both Starlight and Twilight laughed as they snuggled in closer to me.

“You really are a generous guy, Jake,” Twilight lovingly complimented me.

“Yeah, you’d pass Rarity’s class with flying colors,” Starlight earnestly added.

“Thanks, girls,” I affectionately said as I wrapped my arms around my marefriends and gave each of them a small kiss on the forehead.

The three of us just continued to lay there on the floor until Ocellus knocked on the door a few minutes later, and both Twilight and Starlight made me hide in a closet until she left. But even as I stood there, naked in the closet, I regretted nothing.

Author's Note:

While I don't usually accept submissions beyond season 7, I made an exception for Peni since she's a close friend. But from here on out, please keep all submissions within season 7