My Little Reviews & Feedback 387 members · 576 stories

My Little Reviews and Feedback

Welcome! We’re a group dedicated to providing reviews and feedback (duh) to authors on this site! Looking for an in-depth critique of your story? We’re exactly the group for you!

If you’re new to this group, check out the rules for requesting reviews (Requesting Reviews) and each reviewer’s preferences (Who Reads What?). These two threads will give you all the information you need to get a review from a member of our team!

If you’re looking to join up on our reviewer team, great! Send a message to Azure Drache — he’ll give you further instructions from there. We’re always happy to have new members, so don’t hesitate to join us! :twilightsmile:
Also you can read the thread with all details about it

Comments ( 65 )
  • Viewing 46 - 65 of 65

Well, Flora gave me a great review, but I always love second opinions. May as well stick it in another folder.

Well Jnß has left the team of reviewers. So no worry about them anymore.

Yes, his tone got a bit concerning so he decided it would be good to leave. And the rest of the team likes me to point out, let em quote:

We do not condone the usage of a disparaging style of writing reviews

I'm personally sorry to you and anyone who have felt unfairly critiqued by him or that he has critiqued someone unfairly. As someone who has worked with this team during the first golden age when this place started growing. I wish that within the future this feeling doesn't happen again with other members of team.

I'm not going to lie, I do find the recent review by jnzsblzs to be a bit concerning. :fluttershysad:

Hello I'm new here... well, I mean I just join this group I been on fim fiction for a while like since 2016... Wonder if I have what it takes to be a reviewer since it seems they need more...

Thanks for your praise, and your welcome:twilightsmile:

Can I just say thank GOD there is still one review site on fimfiction that is actually currently active? The single other one I've found, PaulAsaran's, is booked up (no pun intended) for literally a year.

You do us all a great service.

Well, this place has grown quite a lot.

How do I get my own reviewer folder?

I'd pick it up myself, but my queue is pretty full at the moment. Best of luck!

Yes, due to his lack of reviews, I removed all stories from his income folder. Sorry your story was one of them, the general folder should be fine, the limit there is 12 weeks till it gets moved.

I had it Schatten's folder, which might be why it got moved. I chose him because the story seemed right up his alley from what I know of his preferences. If he's unavailable I might leave it in the general folder though. The story's name is 20 Years Later.


It can also happen that the reviewer who picked it left or that it was moved to rejected during the folder cleaning that happens now and then. The main folder has a 12 weeks limit till a story moves to expires soon and then get rejected or deleted.

Also I move stories to rejected if a reviewer did not pick it from his personal folder for a longer time when he is already stuffed with work. Like I did with Schatten lately.

Though you can of course resubmit it, and if you tell me which story it is and who you want to review it I can see how things going in that matter and tell you if it will work out or if you better pick someone else.

I can't say for certain, but stories get removed if you add them to more than one reviewer's folder at a time. Did you submit it to a certain reviewer's folder or the general folder?

Hey there,
While I appreciate you guys don't want to review some things, I would like to briefly ask why my story, 20 years later, got rejected? Just so I know what I should and shouldn't put here in the future, since I thought it was fine. Thanks.

I insert my story in the 'Put your story here for someone considering it for a Review' folder, but in case if you review it, let me remind you that it's a very incomplete story.

Just saw your post here :rainbowlaugh: This frontpage sadly gives noone a notification about posts, so they are only found by happenstances:derpytongue2:

Greetings and salutations.
Just found out about this group and it sounds interesting.
I think I'll try putting one of my short stories here in the general review folder.

  • Viewing 46 - 65 of 65
Join our Patreon to remove these adverts!