Thoraxis's daughter, Skia, has been missing for over a year now, and he has fallen into a state of despair. Then a traveling theater, the Theatre Metamorphoses, arrives in Ponyville to perform, but he senses something familiar with its presence...
Just a few days before Hearth's Warming, an unnatural blizzard lays siege on Ponyville, bringing a strange character into town with it. Serendipity, Thoraxis and Petra's blind daughter, and her visiting friend, Charybdis, decide to investigate.
Thoraxis has become perfectly happy and content with his life in Ponyville, in the months following his "small" misadventure. His daughter, though, senses something missing, and sets him up on a blind date. With who just happens to be a wyvern.