Nyx woke up the next morning and decided to review her evidence before continuing her investigation. She pulled out her notebook and all of her evidence and placed it in front of her.
"Hmm, whoever kidnapped mom used chloroform from Sleepy Head's store. She also had 4 cans of mane dye, 2 of which she used to disguise herself as Rainbow dash. while the other 2 cans were most likely used on her mane and tail after purchasing the chloroform. Whoever this was probably bought the mane dye from the mane shop."
Nyx packed up all her evidence and left the castle to go to the mane shop. As she was walking, she noticed a cloak lying on the street next to a toppled trash bin. Nyx walked over to the cloak and lifted it with her magic. "Hmm, maybe this belonged to the kidnapper. I should hold on to it." She said to herself, carrying the cloak on her back
Nyx approached the mane shop just as Rarity walked out, carrying a bottle of shampoo.
"Oh, hello Nyx. What are you doing here?"
"I'm investigating my mother's kidnapping. This is where I needed to go next."
"Twilight was kidnapped?!" Exclaimed Rarity, fainting.
"Heh, classic Rarity." Said Nyx. "Well, time to resume my investigation."
Nyx walked into the mane shop and up to the counter.
"Excuse me." Said Nyx, taking out her notebook. "I'm investigating my mother's kidnapping, and I need to ask you a few questions."
"Sure, I'll answer them." Replied the mare
Nyx levitated the cloak off her back, "Was there anypony here two days ago wearing this?"
The mare took the cloak and studied it. "Yes, there was one pony wearing this."
"Were you able to tell who it was?"
"No, unfortunately. The cloak made it too hard to see what the pony looked like."
"What did the pony buy while she was here?"
"She bought 4 cans of mane dye. I remember her sounding like she desperately needed them for something."
"What were the colors of each can that the pony bought?"
"One was light blue, a second was rainbow, a third was dark green, and the fourth was dark blue."
"Did the pony say their name at all while purchasing?"
"No, unfortunately. Is that all?"
"One more question. Was the pony a earth pony, unicorn or pegasus?"
"The pony was a unicorn for sure. She teleported out of my shop after purchasing the mane dye."
"Thank you for the information." Replied Nyx
"Although, I did remember her coat being a very light blue, just a little darker than Rainbow dash's coat."
Nyx wrote this down in her notebook before putting it away. "Thanks for that extra information, Miss." She said, leaving the mane shop.
"So, a light blue unicorn. I wonder who it could be." Said Nyx to herself
Nyx suddenly heard her friends' voices
"Hey, Nyx."
"Hi, Diamond. What's up?"
"Not much. Just on my way to The Hayburger. What about you?"
"I'm busy investigating my mother's kidnapping."
"Wait, Twilight was kidnapped. By who?"
"I don't know yet. But I'll hopefully know soon." Nyx then heard her stomach grumble, "Though I should probably get something to eat. Mind if I join you?"
"Not at all. Silver's busy today, and I have no idea what the bla-, I mean, CMCs are doing."
"Still having a little trouble not calling them what you used to call them?" Nyx said with a smirk
"Yes, I've been doing it for so long." Replied Diamond, before her stomach started grumbling too. "We should probably head to The Hayburger now."
"Good idea." Replied Nyx
It didn't take the pair long before they got to Hayburger, just about 5 minutes.
"Hey, Nyx and Diamond. I bet that you're both here for brunch." Said Pinkie, "Come on, I'll pay for you too."
"Thanks Pinkie. I'm just taking a break from investigating my mother's kidnapping."
"Ok." Said Pinkie. Then it hit her, "WHAT?! TWILIGHT WAS KIDNAPPED!?"
"Pinkie, calm down. I'm still investigating and I will find her." Replied Nyx
"Right, sorry." Said Pinkie, "So, what do you two want?"
"We'll have two filly's meals."
"Okay." Said Pinkie
Pinkie ordered the food, and the three of them talked while eating their brunch.
"So Pinkie, how's business at Sugarcube corner."
"It's been great. Business is booming this time of year."
"That's good. How many ponies buy treats everyday."
"Dozens. One of the ponies that bought a pack of cupcakes was a little strange. She was wearing a cloak over her body."
Nyx's eyes grew wide as she spit out some of her apple juice that came with her meal. She immediately wiped her mouth afterwards.
"Pinkie, did you just say that one of the ponies was wearing a cloak?"
"Yeah, I was. Why?"
"It wouldn't happen to be this cloak, would it?" Asked Nyx, showing Pinkie the cloak that she found earlier
Pinkie looked at the cloak for a couple seconds, then said, "Yeah, this is the cloak. Why is this important?"
"Pinkie, were you able to see who the pony was?"
"No, not really. I did a bit of what the pony was saying though."
Nyx pulled out her notebook, "What did you manage to hear the pony say?"
"I heard her say something about revenge on somepony for humiliating her, something about spray painting her mane and tail, and something about chloroform."
"Anything else?"
"Now that you mention it, the pony also said something about some kind of magic show. I don't know."
Nyx finished writing all the information down and put her notebook away. "Pinkie, you just gave me what I need to solve this case."
"No, problem Nyx." Replied Pinkie, "Mind telling us your theory on who you think it is based on the evidence you've collected?"
"Sure." Replied Nyx. "It started yesterday morning. I found a cloth with chloroform, a few of my mother's feathers, and green fur, all with a chloroform scent, in her bedroom. Then I found a bottle of chloroform, made by a new business-pony named Sleepy Head. I rushed over to his shop and asked him about the bottle. He told me that one of the ponies that bought chloroform the day before had a light blue coat and a rainbow mane and tail, along with mane dye. That led me to suspect Rainbow dash, until I proved her innocence. Then I asked Sleepy Head how many bottles of mane dye the pony had and what colors each one was. He told me the colors, which were blue, rainbow, green, and brown."
"Today, I found the cloak in a trash bin outside while I was heading towards the mane shop. When I got to the mane shop, I asked the pony working there about the mane dye and the cloak. She told me that a pony with a cloak had purchased the mane dye, and that the pony had a light-blue coat and was a unicorn. But it was your knowledge that helped me figure out who the kidnapper is."
"Who is it?" Asked Diamond tiara.
"Light-blue unicorn mare who runs a magic show and has a grudge on Twilight for humiliating her. I propose that the kidnapper of my mother is none other than Trixie Lulamoon."
Well, it's kinda obvious who we're talking about. However, there's a little error made, Trixie has a coat darker than Rainbow Dash's:
Trixie:
static.wikia.nocookie.net/heroes-and-villain/images/9/92/Trixie.png/revision/latest?cb=20190131193305
Rainbow:
i.pinimg.com/originals/d7/47/14/d74714095998f4d617b5a0d18f8f70bf.png
10542486
Oh, I thought that Rainbow had the darker coat
Oh boy. Here we go!
This is an awesome story, and great cliffhanger here!
10542493
Thx
Great chapter and great detective to nxy and can't wait to see the next chapter
10542507
I'll be releasing one or two tomorrow
Two?
I think I’m just realizing this, but isn’t announcing that to any and everypony be a bad idea?
10542514
Yeah
No
10542519
What two cans were used? I know rainbow is one of them.
10542528
The other was a slightly lighter blue
10542493
10542494
Wait, am I seeing two Players?!
10542533
Yep
D'AWWWWW! Nyx is just so cute in that getup
10542534
And we all met Player 6... A trio of Players, what a coincidence.
10542535
Thanks. SuperSamYoshi made it
What do you think about the story?
10542538
Yep
10542540
You three could make a collab... The Players' Collab.
10542541
Hmm, maybe
10542533
Yes indeed! You're the first to comment on this!
(If you're wondering, I had the username type first. Player 5 wasn't called that until about two days ago; I've been Player 4 since April, when I first came to this site.)
10542509
Thx for head up
10542543
But still... three completely different people calling themselves as "Player" is... just wow.
10542549
What do you think about it?
10542550
It is something, definitely. I never thought I'd cause a ripple effect with my choice of username.
10542553
And only with 24 followers! Imagine when you'll get 100 followers... They'll probably begin a cult named the Player's Kids.
LOL
10542552
Really great story it bring another side of nxy
10542562
Thx
10542539
Haven't gotten a chance to read it yet, but the concept is interesting so ill be keeping an eye on this
10542565
It’s not just one single story
It’s a series
10542556
That is true; it already happened at 24 followers! Looking into the future, I can only imagine...
You know what, that does sound like a good name, I think! If my followers ever were to make a fan group for me (and possibly the other Players, too), that could easily be their name!
10542567
I should talk with Player 6 about this
10542567
Heh. Glad I could help, mate. After all, you already helped me once.
10542566
I read the description. I look forward to seeing how this develops.
also, Nyx should TOTALLY get Rarity onbaord. after all Rarity has experience mystery solving.
10542573
Maybe I’ll have her be a one time partner
10542572
Yes! Thanks so much for engaging with me, and I'm happy that I found you!
10542576
Likewise, mate. If you ever want to help or need some, here I am.
Boops
10542587
What?
10542531
Ohh
I think they might be a little more concerned about Nyx investigating, shes only a filly after all.
10542622
A filly who is the incarnation of a really powerful villain
10542590
Its a boop
10542783
I still don’t understand what that means
10542832
Its a gentle nose poke
10542833
I know what a boop is, but what does it have to do with the chapter?
10542835
Nyx is adorably written and i wanted to boop her
10542836
Oh
10542836
Were you surprised when you found out who the kidnapper was?
Nyx Found out who ponynapped Twilight, Good for her, now she needs to find Twilight and save her
Ohh so this is pretty much somewhere around season 5 because you said something this is after Crusaders of the Lost Mark and Trixie is still upset with Twilight ok I guess
:0 le gasp! Starlight gonna be mad at Trixie