Page generated in 0.026 seconds
Total duration
1,011 users online
1,601,969 hits today, 2,280,440 yesterday
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
You offer one of the greatest choices available in a story like this Wolokai.
Should one go with Redemption and forgive the one who has committed great atrocities in the name of the great good? Or should you pass the judgement they so rightfully deserve for all that they have done.
Personally, I vote redemption first. I believe that usually a second should be offered first, unless the crime/situation is quite heinous in nature.
Also, listening to "Men of Harlech" made your battle seem all the more epic.
Redemption. But besides that, I love this story.
905365 umm what Celestia did was quite heinous to compare what she did in the real world terms she found a great person with a great future and forced her to snort bath salts and become a zombie (well that's what i believe caused those people to turn into cupcakes pinkie but replace bath salts with whatever the cause is if its proven different the concept still applies)
AND DEATH TO CELESTIA SHE DESERVES DEATH FOR DOING THE ABOVE SEVERAL TIMES OVER AND CAUSING IT TO HAPPEN TO TENS OF THOUSANDS OF OTHERS DEATH
or turn her into whatever variant twilight is and have her purge as a redemption she still dies but she redeems herself
the funny thing about my comment is if i was twilight i would spare her and say "you're not getting the easy way out"
I personally choose redemption
Redemption would be nice, but the dark path is always a interesting take. Are you gonna release them both at the same time?
redemption
I'm going to be blunt. If it was the criminal's head alone that was on the chopping block, I'd say swing away. In this case, however, innocent lives are at stake. Therefore, I vote redemption.
Revenge. Celestia deserves this. Don't you see. She's begging to be punished, to be absolved from her sins. And the only way for her hooves to be clean is with blood. Her blood. The blood of those who have sinned.
The thoughts yearn for revenge but the gut says redemption. Should all suffer for the pain of one? Celestia will perish, of that there is no doubt but under fair trial of law. If we kill just for the sake of our feelings, does that make us any better than the monsters we so claim to hate?
Personally i would kill Celestia then i would kill Trixie and purge all of the ravage and gift royalty upon Luna...
Celestia deserves to burn for what shes done...
Trixie wants to bring upon a new world of infection and death... and i would want to save Equestria so she must die...
and giving the empire to Luna because she a princess because i personally wouldn't give a fuck about ruling and if she does want to save Equestria well i say let her do just that...
my two cents have been spent
I would love to see Celestia get what she deseves for all the sin she has comited her death would solve one problem but with her death comes the end of Equestria and I dont think Twilight could handle what she did to inosent ponys after the battle is over. Also it is not like if she forgave Celestia that she would be prinses again most likely she would be sent back to prison or maybe be infected with the virus per her request to be her ponisment.
I go with redemption after all is said and done I dont think she could live with herself.
Someone needs to draw Big Mac in his D-Pony Armor.
Nothing but glory could rise out of that.
I vote redemption first. Celestia is suffering more by living then she ever will by being killed.
I dare to bet that both choices and with the death of both Twilight and Trixie xD
Redemption.
Twilight must remember: The true mark of wisdom is not using power to subjugate the weak, but using it to protect the weak, not for one's own sake, but for the sake of righteousness.
And revenge is easy, redemption is hard.
That, and While I love dark stories, I hate dark endings. Remember, this is My Little Pony. The end doesn't have to be sunshine and rainbows, but at least end on a positive.
Simple, I want both. Or rather, I want the third option. Which is to kill trixie, kill celestia, cure everyone but herself ( because she can't) and then leave.
Can we haz both endings? Assuming they are endings. I'm sure revenge would be an ending, but redemption sounds like it's keep going. If we can't have both, then I choose redemption.
Redemption is my vote.
I vote for redemption, not that I want celestia saved but hopefully in celestia's redemption twilight is redeemed and I want to see her happy with big mac
Redemption
Redemption because I enjoy a happier ending to a story
Funny thing just happened. I flipped a coin, heads for redemption, tails for revenge.
And it landed upright...
...
...
...
So both please, though I'm personally leaning towards redemption.
GOD DAM IT! If this was any other story I could predict the obvious outcome, Redemption. HOWEVER! Twilight is now a god dam infected, and is already fucking up Canterlot, she could very will kill everyone dear god.
this is such awesomeness!
Redemption or Revenge, a classical question.... Always Redemption. Always. You have power, and thus it lies to you to make the choice. Kill, or show mercy. It is your responsibility, as a sentient being, to show mercy to those in need, aid who you can, and defend those who cannot defend themselves. Even if it results in your own death, at the end.
This was released on my birthday. BEST GIFT EVER! THOUGH THAT DAMN CLIFFHANGER! :)
To all of you who would choose redemption I ask. Does such a thing as redemption exist? I say nay. There is no redemption, there should be no forgiveness for what Celestia has wrought. One can forgive a person their words, one can forgive a person their honest mistakes, but one can never forgive the deliberate taking of innocent life. Celestia has done far worse than merely take life she has corrupted and twisted it.
If Celestia gets redemption, she'll have her actions on her mind for the rest of her life. Which in some degree, is worse than death. There is no redeeming someone who has made something like this go on, I say Revenge. I think it is what Celestia wants after all.
CLIFFHANGERS!!! ...Excuse me, I need to go flip a table.
revenge...i like my stories long, sad, violent and conclusive. i truly love the way you write and the stories you create. i look forward to more from you.
Let her live, she has already begged Twilight to end her, so letting her live would be like Revenge and Redemption all in one
Also I want Big Mac and Twilight to be happy together in the end, they deserve it
907765
This... This is beautiful. Exactly what I was trying to say. Revenge is easy. All you have to do is give in to your base instincts. Redemption, however, is hard. You must prove your with and overcome that which has tried to drag us back down to the slime pits we crawled from.
Damn cliffhangers. There everywhere now.
It's already past but I would personally have seen that Trixie is obviously not here for the princesses. She's there for personal reasons Twilight can't trust but doesn't know what they are yet (and twilight KNOWS this) so her fate would be a missing horn at the least as having two all powerful carriers could jeopardize Twilight's plans. As for punishment, Twilight is missing the point of it. Punishment is not meant to repay their past misdeeds rather than to make sure they don't do it again. The notion of revenge is a petty and illogical excuse that emotionally plagues us. The trick is to not give into revenge while still ensuring that they won't do horrible things like that any more. Yes, killing them all would accomplish this but think of the effects. Will that punish anyone else? They depend on the alicorns to eternally rise the sun and moon, thus killing Luna would punish the entire world. Celestia is already hornless and useless in that respect, and letting her live is a risk even though she truly seems sorry. HOWEVER, letting her live would also serve as a reminder for Luna (and Celestia) to try and stay on a morally acceptable path and her thousands of years of knowledge may prove useful in some later date. Killing Celestia would be a small mercy but would only guarantee that Celestia will never try this again (not Luna) and in a few thousand years, the memories of this may fade in Luna's mind, especially with her power being possibly unmatched. As for the guard, kill him or redeem him, he seems sincere and will probably never do something like this again.
Assualt on Canterlot: cease attack and cure afflicted.
Trixie: Dehorning and/or forceful cure.
Celestia: Kept alive as a small mercy to Luna and a reminder of what happens when morals are traded for power. (Affliction has a decent chance of carrier status being obtianed, deemed HIGHLY unrecommended and should be avoided.)
Luna: Kept alive for necessary celestial movements and leadership. Perhaps a nick to the tip of her horn to lessen her power slightly and serve as yet another reminder. (DO NOT AFFLICT)
Shadow: Angry threat and life. Maybe affliction. Still on the fence as to the affliction. Probably no.
Twilight: Would make for a good guardian force over Equestria and Affliction could take the place of the death/life imprisonment penalty. But it is mostly up to her whether she can emotionally handle being in Equestria. Not sure how to handle the Macintosh predicament right now. Need to see if any better options can be explored before just declaring that lost because Twilight really might need him for some emotional stability and morality support. Also... mac might not take her back.
The level of intensity and emotion that you created in the moments before the battle were unlike anything I have ever read. You are truly an amazing writer, capable of profound imagery and able to capture the imagination of such a mentally stubborn brony as I. Kudos to you sir :3
...Redemption.
He reared up on his back hooves and took in a deep breath, unleashing his magically booming voice across all of Canterlot "Colts and mares of The Lunar Guard! I stand before you now not only as a Captain, not only as a soldier...but as a citizen, and free colt of Equestria! Today...is a day that shall forever be written down, not as the day where we rolled over to our enemy and gave them our lives, NOT as the day where we found despair in the face of adversity, NOT, as the day where Equestria would bow its head and face its death as a coward! Today is a day, that will remembered as the day that in the face of impossible odds, impossible chances, and impending defeat...we...The Lunar Guard of the Glorious Lunar Republic, rose, united, and battled against the hordes of monsters that would seek to slaughter our fillies, our children, our way of life!" He paused as The Lunar Guard let forth a unified roar, stamping their hooves in approval.
"TODAY!" Shadow roared "Let us fight, brick by brick, inch by inch! Let our cannons shake the world with their mighty roars! Let our blades strike true, and our bullets fly straight! If they want to take our beloved city, they will do so over our dead corpses! I SAY, LET THEM COME! Let them all come! They say that these monsters are the true scourge of all life!? That they cannot be stopped!? Well I say let's put them to the test!!!! WHAT SAY YOU!"
Shadow's chest swelled with pride as The Lunar Guard stamped their hooves in a unified beat and shouted over and over again: "Glory! Glory! Glory! Glory!!!!"
That fucking asshole can go die for all i care! He´s the fucking reason this virus got into this world, that there had been hundred thousand of innocent deaths and that his own soldiers are dieing meaningless deaths yet he has the gall to sprout such words!
looked like it get Ponyville's town
I found a error of grammar....
Anyone wanna play inFAMOUS?
if I were twilight I would kill celly and twixie and purge and If I survived I would blame trixie for using mind control
i know its late so I will just say this mylittlefacewhen.com/media/f/img/mlfw8357-mlp_cliffhanger.jpg
ALSO I KNOW WHERE YOU GOT YOUR SEIGE SCENE FROM