A evil older then Luna or Celestia has returned and only one thing can stop it. With the help of a new friend with a dark past The Mane 6 go on a great quest that will test them and their friendship. It will take trust and willpower or all if Equestria will be lost to the darkness. Takes place between season 2 and 3
OH MY GOD, THE PACING!
Seriously, dude. The pacing's going along at supersonic speeds. Slow down a moment and tell the story as it's meant to be told.
~An Old Train Conductor
Hi... Pinkie or Discord?
I dunno, I've read a pretty wide variety of stuff.
I dunno, I've heard some pretty colorful stuff.
Well, that makes "Hearth's Warming Eve" completely pointless.
Sorry if this violates your "no flames" rule, but I'm going to be honest. There are a ton of technical errors you and your proofreaders are missing. Given that this is a legend, much like the Nightmare Moon legend in episode 1, I don't mind the pacing so much, but there are a ton of technical thins you need to fix.
Also, don't assume things about your readers. I've written stories that include slaughter, so it's safe to say your story isn't going to phase me with a little violence.
Dat punctuation.
'Tis bad.
-Winter Storm
~An Old Train Trooper
I understand that you don't want any harsh comments so I'll just go ahead and suggest something. Get rid of your proofreader. He is BEYOND terrible and I am appalled that someone with his limited knowledge of the English language can work up the nerve to put this together and called it proofread.
Holy hell this was beyond cheesy. I'm not trying to be rude but this needs an immediate redo. So much could have been put here but you never bother to EXPLAIN IT. Don't tell me what's happening with these cheesy one liners. SHOW ME......
Can you believe that this only took me about 8 minutes to throw together? This story is in desperate need of work.
There have been a lot of comments about this, but I agree: there needs to be a big change in the grammar and spelling. There are a lot of basic mistakes (you're/your, to/too, etc) that I seem to see a lot. Being somewhat of a grammar nazi, it kinda gets on my nerves. However! I really like the ideas you're putting out. Maybe slowing down a little and adding a few more romantic details could be better than it already is :)