The Accusation Fic Collection 560 members · 394 stories
Fanon 3
Series Wide 13
Season 1 20
Season 2 ( 1 sub folders ) 128
Season 3 22
Season 4 31
Season 5 36
Season 6 36
Season 7 19
IDW Comics 37
Movie 9
Equestria Girls ( 1 sub folders ) 45
New Members ( 3 this week )
Purplefan9 ( 2 days ago )
SuperChaos ( 3 days ago )
Umbra Animo ( 6 days ago )
dragstormer ( 1 week ago )
Attack_on_Titan_Brony ( 1 week ago )
Flashfire Wolf ( 1 week ago )
A Drunk Soviet ( 2 weeks ago )
lokyy55 ( 2 weeks ago )
RustyWarhead ( 3 weeks ago )
fmriver ( 3 weeks ago )

This group is made to collect the various fanfics that call out characters for their actions they've done in the episodes. Every episode is included, from the very first episode to the very last. So long as a fanfic calls someone out for what they've done, it's in here. It was originally the ACW Call-Out until it begins to expand into the Accusation Fic Collection it's known today.

For most newcomers, the question comes to their heads of "why make this group?". That is a simple answer: catharsis. There's always an episode someone hates, whether it'd be the infamous Mare-Do-Well or Ponyville Confidential episodes or something that everyone else loves like A Canterlot Wedding. Most of the time, the reason why they are hated is because the episodes in question have their characters be mean spirited in a show that's supposed to be about friendship, love, and tolerance, or act counter to the morals given in the show. Worst of all, these episodes end without those very moments being questioned.

So, in response to these episodes, fanfic writers write up scenarios that happen during these episodes, whether they be after or in the middle of an episode with the sole intention of addressing the problem of the episode in question and ensuring the ponies learn their lesson. This can be done in many ways. The ponies could feel remorse for what they've done, the pony attacked in the episode could lash out, or, hell, some great evil comes up to punish the ponies in some way, shape, or form.

Whatever the reason, its hits a much needed catharsis for those who didn't like a particular episode that the show more often than not skimps out on. And that is the aim for this collection. Catharsis.

So now contributors could ponder "Well what goes here?" Well, any fanfic where a character is called out over stuff they did in the show. However, there are limitations.

For one, they have to be actions that they did in the show/comic. To give you an example, a fanfic where Pinkie Pie is called out over the events of Filli Vanilli would get accepted into this group, but not over the events of, say, Cupcakes. This group is made to focus on what happened in canon (and semi-canon if you count the IDW comics), not fanon.

Another thing, the focus of the fanfic has to be regarding the calling out. To give you an example, Post-Nuptials focuses entirely on ponies feeling guilty over their actions in A Canterlot Wedding. To contrast: Harmony Theory, while it opens up with Luna accusing Celestia of holding back, is not the main focus of the story. The reason for this is because this group's main focus is ponies getting called out.

And one final thing. It doesn't matter if the character being called out is a hero or a villain. Catharsis is made regardless.

The banner comes from a strip of Totally Lashed. In this case, #76.

Comments ( 34 )
  • Viewing 15 - 34 of 34

Tell me about it.

Regarding the current banner, I'm not sure if what was picked for Rarity really qualifies as accusation material. I don't even think "Sweet and Elite" warrants any accusation material.

I hear ya, this show is running down it's ideas for something that is a complete waste of time.
I really despised their behavior since Friends Forever #38 and this episode Royal Problem.

You know what I hated about A Royal Problem?

1. It claims Celestia and Luna learned nothing over the past 1000+ years and regularly bicker like idiots.
2. Starlight Glimmer's first instinct was "Cast Mind Swap no Jutsu on the two god-princesses because fuck free will and the agency of others and respect for others and anti-magic-abuse laws"
3. This did not land Glimmer in the dungeons.
4. It's just the cliche Freaky Friday stock plot. It's the Celestia and Luna episode we've been waiting for since season one, complete with evil-Celestia and... it's just a Freaky Friday stock plot. And Glimmer gets shilled constantly. Almost every single problem with Miller/Haber/Vogel's writing style is on display in this episode (At least it didn't have random OCs coming out of nowhere to state the episode's solution), and it couldn't have happened to a more anticipated and important-to-the-show episode.
5. It proved that when it comes to these nu-MLP writers, the best thing that can happen to a character... is to be forgotten completely, so these idiots won't get their hands on him/her. I don't even want to know what the inevitable Lightning Dust episode is going to be like.

Also I will do a short story on Cadance shouting at her aunts for their incredibly stupid argument after the events of ‘A Royal Problem’ as a side story.

But there will also be a story where Rainbow and Applejack are called out for insulting Twilight from the Saddles Row and Rec when suddenly years of abuse from her friends takes it’s toll, causing Twilight to snap at them after reading their comment about her in the article. Spike is also called out for being abusive jerk to her for the past seasons, and when Applejack knows that Spike was the one that told Twilight to use magic at Winter Wrap Up she WILL get extremely mad at him and calls him out for making fun of her when she was still trying to learn everything about Winter Wrap up the first time. And the others will get angry at Spike and Rainbow for teasing Twilight from the events of the time travel episode, which Rarity will have pleasure of yelling at them and smack them across their face with the newspaper.

Spike, Applejack and Rainbow Dash all must think of a way to make amends for what they did and hopefully their friendship can be restored all the while being shunned by Twilight’s friends and family.

Comment posted by Decepti-Cobra93 deleted Sep 1st, 2017

Can I add a Anon-a-Miss story in which Sunset Shimmer is called out as a cyber bully and accused of being Anon-a-Miss to this group?

Newbie Dash: The Wonderbolts are pro bullying and have no concept of honor or professionalism.

Top Bolt: Spitfire never LOOKS at ponies before considering them to join or not, and even refuses to actually WORK.

Wonderbolts Academy: Spitfire almost got 5 civilians killed and yells at RD for not babying her after she kept yelling at her for not killing herself. I don't mind her being a drill sergeant but if she thinks that being reckless and dangerous is a good trait (even if it's until this episode) then she's the most dangerous kind of idiot.

Rarity Investigates: This one random guy says to fire RD? Okay. Dumb cluck.

Rainbow Falls: Spitfire and Fleetfoot left a man behind and made the worst apology about it ever.


And now we have the Season 6 finale, but is it really the worst of the worst?

Is it just me, or is who ever made this new banner by any chance a fan of Kamen Rider Double?

@Psyga315: Hey, uh... it's great that you gave credit to how you made the group's banner (can't believe I didn't notice the credit sooner), but... you might wanna fix the link to where you gave credit because that web site is now inactive. You can look through my blogs and find the comic again to get the new link to it if you like.

Which is why this comic dub exists.

So, in a way, I feel sad for Celestia...

Attention everypony, please do not ignore this. I am a little busy with college work so I won't be making new chapters as quickly as I hoped. But to those of you who are reading my fanfic and find it entertaining, could you leave comments telling me what you think of the story so far. Tell me what you think of the events that transpire in the chapters. Receiving comments is one of the biggest reasons why I started this. I tried to put my fanfic on deviantart but no one ever gave me any comments for it, so I took it off the deviantart account. I'm hoping the same doesn't happen to me here.


RD already knows this material or at least should. In Sweet And Elite it reveals that everything Rarity knows about the wonderbolts she learned from RD and now they're saying that Rarity knows more than RD does. This episode should have had Scootaloo in RD's place, Cheerilee in The Wonderbolts' place, and RD in Twilight's place. They keep trying to make RD worst pony and it's getting rather annoying.

Actually, that's a great idea!! Ellington, YOU'RE A GENIUS!!! :twilightsmile: Rainbow can teach Scootaloo!! Scootaloo dreams of Flying with Her Sister/Idol... and It needs to be a Tough Slice-of-Life and it'll show that you can still try your best and not thoroughly succeed...
Hope This Rewrite Episode will be like The Simpsons Season 2, Episode 1 "Bart Gets an F" from that was Talked from Nostalgia Critic:
This Episode is a True Gem....

399623 RD already knows this material or at least should. In Sweet And Elite it reveals that everything Rarity knows about the wonderbolts she learned from RD and now they're saying that Rarity knows more than RD does. This episode should have had Scootaloo in RD's place, Cheerilee in The Wonderbolts' place, and RD in Twilight's place. They keep trying to make RD worst pony and it's getting rather annoying.

I should also say that the episode was literally saying 'It's okay to be a disruptive punk at school and to not pay attention and if you fail because of it it's the teacher's fault' and thus was justifying bad behavior. Plus having Pinkie rap is like having another character dress like a member of the KKK. The episode tries to say that RD needs to learn her way but really RD didn't care, which is as out of character as Beast Boy eating meat.

I'm surprised that not more people dislike this awful episode. In Legend Of Korra, Korra was dealing with a matter she wasn't familiar with and RD was dealing with her thing; in the Weekenders Lor was seeking her friends ad while RD was being forced against her will by Twilight (BTW Twilight had no right to forced RD like that, Twilight was being a jerk); in The Wild Thornberrys Debbie knew little about history and needed to learn. So yeah Amy Keating Rogers completely missed the point of this plot type.


You know, the more Black Kyurem thinks about how awful the wedding rehearsal was and what everyone did to Twilight being unjust, Black Kyurem just can't shake the bitter feeling and bad taste in his mouth from it. :twilightangry2:

They should have invited "The Bride" From Kill Bill


Testing Testing 1 2 3: RD was behaving like a 6 year old. And with an attitude like that why would the Wonderbolts let her in. Plus Rainbow should know more about the history of the Wonderbolts than Rarity, Rarity knowing more than RD is like a casual MLP viewer knowing more than a hipster brony about the history of MLP (not impossible but unlikely).

- Yeah, I'm with you on this one, This Episode could've done a similar resemblance to "Bart Gets an F", Pinkie Pie Telling Her about the History of the Wonderbolts... "Nations of the World: Animaniacs Style", then later Fluttershy, Applejack, Rarity, and Applejack came in to do their method, and when Rainbow's Friends are arguing about which method is better, Rainbow would've snapped and said something like this: Okay, okay! Why are we dancing around the obvious? I know it, you know it. I am dumb, okay? Dumb as a post! Think I’m happy about it?, then (Based from the Expierences of Homeschooling from Kids and Parents) Rainbow both studies for the wonderbolts and gets distracted for things with help from Celestia and Luna and The Mane Six without Pressuring her, and did she succeed? actually no, we see that she actually failed (Sad Shocking Moment, isn't it?), and in my opinion, This is the Saddest BUCKING Thing I'll See in the Fanfic or Show... Rainbow completely breaks down and believes herself to be a total failure when she gets an F on the test despite genuinely trying to study hard for it... This will be the Perfect Episode for this, Some People Had a Hard Time or Weren't Good Students in School Growing up... I want it be both a Tribute and Shout-out to The Simpsons.

Comment posted by Komodo Dragoon deleted Jun 23rd, 2015
Comment posted by FoxfanMLP22 deleted Jun 24th, 2015

I recently started an alternate ending about Boast Busters. I know that this episode has a lot of alternate endings already, however, I believe that I have taken an original approach to this, by inserting the collateral damage that SHOULD have happened when that Ursa Minor went into Ponyville.

  • Viewing 15 - 34 of 34