• Member Since 28th Oct, 2012
  • offline last seen 50 minutes ago

Pineta


Particle Physics and Pony Fiction Experimentalist

More Blog Posts441

  • 3 weeks
    Eclipse 2024

    Best of luck to everyone chasing the solar eclipse tomorrow. I hope the weather behaves. If you are close to the line of totality, it is definitely worth making the effort to get there. I blogged about how awesome it was back in 2017 (see: Pre-Eclipse Post, Post-Eclipse

    Read More

    10 comments · 160 views
  • 11 weeks
    End of the Universe

    I am working to finish Infinite Imponability Drive as soon as I can. Unfortunately the last two weeks have been so crazy that it’s been hard to set aside more than a few hours to do any writing…

    Read More

    6 comments · 169 views
  • 14 weeks
    Imponable Update

    Work on Infinite Imponability Drive continues. I aim to get another chapter up by next weekend. Thank you to everyone who left comments. Sorry I have not been very responsive. I got sidetracked for the last two weeks preparing a talk for the ATOM society on Particle Detectors for the LHC and Beyond, which took rather more of my time than I

    Read More

    1 comments · 160 views
  • 15 weeks
    Imponable Interlude

    Everything is beautiful now that we have our first rainbow of the season.

    What is life? Is it nothing more than the endless search for a cutie mark? And what is a cutie mark but a constant reminder that we're all only one bugbear attack away from oblivion?

    Read More

    3 comments · 224 views
  • 17 weeks
    Quantum Decoherence

    Happy end-of-2023 everyone.

    I just posted a new story.

    EInfinite Imponability Drive
    In an infinitely improbable set of events, Twilight Sparkle, Sunny Starscout, and other ponies of all generations meet at the Restaurant at the end of the Universe.
    Pineta · 12k words  ·  50  0 · 882 views

    This is one of the craziest things that I have ever tried to write and is a consequence of me having rather more unstructured free time than usual for the last week.

    Read More

    2 comments · 158 views
Mar
14th
2015

Terry Pratchett and me · 11:44pm Mar 14th, 2015

What to blog about this week? For once there is no shortage of news tags. Last Sunday was International Women's Day—I did start writing another post on feminism, but put it to one side so I could finish my entry for the write-off. It is now the start of British Science Week, which surely calls for more ponies and science; and it's pi day, so we should have some mathematics from Pinkie. But all this is eclipsed—oh and there will be an eclipse next Friday, mustn't forget that—by the sad news of Terry Pratchett's final meeting with Death. Everything else will have to wait.

It's been quite moving reading all the comments on this site from Pratchett fans. He clearly was a huge inspiration for many of us. I hadn't thought too much about it before this week, but thinking it over, I believe he had more influence on me than I realized.

Sir Terry's books were reinterpreting fantasy in a modern (or post-modern) way. Discworld was a land of magic, wizards, trolls, dwarves, but one which had to deal with issues of labour relations, equal opportunities and such like. He thought rationally about decidedly irrational things, with hilarious results. He throws in all sorts of obscure literary references, some of which we miss, but that makes his books fun to reread as we spot new things each time. And it's all done with a brilliant sense of humour.

This is all the sort of thing which I do (in my own amateurish way). As do many fimfiction writers. We reinterpret My Little Pony, as Terry was redefining fantasy, taking it in directions which it was never designed to go, but in a way which respects the original, and remains true to its spirit.

All my stories use the pony world to parody some aspect of our own. I wasn't conscious of it at the time, but I created my version of an Equestrian newspaper industry in Breaking News and Weather, not unlike (for instance) how modern music is parodied in Soul Music, cinema in Moving Pictures, and so on. Would I have done it if I had never read any Pratchett? Quite possibly not. Of course he wasn't the only writer to do this sort of thing, but he is certainly the one who sticks in my mind.

And I have to say something on the Science of Discworld, because he got this so right. A lesser writer would have tried to produce a technobabble “theory” of magic in the fashion of the Standard Model of Particle Physics, as if it could all be explained by a different set of fundamental interactions. But that's not how magic works. Terry and his co-writers explain, “Dragons don't breath fire because they've got asbestos lungs—they breath fire because everyone knows that's what dragons do.” Discworld magic does not run on a set of rules like the laws of physics, it runs on narrative imperative—the power of story.

Which is not to say that you can't use such a world to say something about real world science, or economics, or whatever. That's what thought experiments are. The Science of Discworld is a really innovative work of science communication, as well as a fun read.

But I do wish he had written that book on the nuclear industry.

Report Pineta · 336 views · #terry pratchett
Comments ( 3 )
Majin Syeekoh
Moderator

Dragons don't breath fire because they've got asbestos lungs—they breath fire because everyone knows that's what dragons do.

This is an amazing line.

Everyone knows of the great god Om, because tortoises can fly.

Wierd rules. Its been proven that for the law of truely large numbers, the sort of rule where the sum of all numbers is -1/12, that million to one chances turn up 9 times out o 10, and that the impossibly remotest chance has to occur almost instantly.

I have a comic strip in a book called Welcome To Sellafield. It was drawn up in the 80s, but given the news thats turned up in the 30 years since, it looks like an operation manual. :pinkiecrazy:

As for what Terry would do next in an infinite desert? Well, apart from enjoy the Pink Pony Of Death party time?

xkcd505 meets Pinkie.

The best part about analyzing magic is that you can always be right, no matter how simple or how elaborate you make your explanation. But Terry Pratchett's narrativium model was perhaps the most elegant I've ever seen. He was a brilliant man, and he will be dearly missed.

Login or register to comment