From the story from Escape to Paradise comes an alternate storyline after his life splits in two. While he lives his human life after his pony death another part of him stays in Equestria as a unicorn and the same entry as before. With no memory of his past pegasus life, he starts over from the very beginning.

Hook as the young 19 year old finds it hard deal with his own kind about the very things they do to life and everyone and everything. He is suddenly dropped from the sky and lands in Twilights home and meets Rainbow Dash. The very thing he worries about the most is being found out he's not one of them and tries to flee from the over embracing ponies who saw him.