alchemist's punishment · 3:05am Apr 25th, 2016
Those who have been following my Living Nightmare story might remember how Luna punished the pony Alchemist. After a bit of thinking, i would like to know your opinion: Should i change it so he simply ended up in Tartarus?
And for those who haven't read it, here's chapter 27 of the story
Nah. It's possible to escape from Tartarus. It will be nigh on impossible from him to return to his native Equestria from a forest he is bound to in a parallel dimension without help. And any help that could get him out of there could get him out of Tartarus as well. And frankly from what I have seen he isn't worth the effort, expenses, or favors used to get him out of either.
Tldr: he's fine where he's at, no need to retcon it.
3894219 I agree
Leave him where he is.
It is possible that he would suffer down there for the rest of his life with no one to help him escape. Part of me says he could get a second chance and change for the better, but I highly doubt that would happen in the story.
I think it's up to you to make this decision, Autum.
i actually liked how Luna handled that.