The Reviews Are In

Comments

[Heavy Weapons Guy]

I like Rose. Screw the haters

[BaeroRemedy]

5754708
Let me be clear, I love that people hate her. I think it's great. She's so supremely wrong on so many things and she's killed so many ponies both directly and indirectly. The fact that people hate her is great. Honestly you're kinda supposed to, as long as you understand why she's awful

[Jman14102]

I'm incredibly amused that two of these "reviews" are from none other than me lol.

Rose fits squarely into the Villain Protagonist role of the story. If this story were from anyone else's perspective the entire time, it wouldn't work. But because we get to see Rose's rapid descent, and because it's in a setting where things are already so dire, we can still like her and hope she survives. Maybe.

Truth be told, her dying at the end would be too good for her.

[BaeroRemedy]

5754713
cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/803137706213113857/1173470954182164540/image.png?ex=656412fd&is=65519dfd&hm=7d87a73993bad0a7e34c5ea995d4ea416dc53c9c30f784d9516e142bb0bdd197&

That one's going on the fridge.

[DarthBall]

She’s a cute pone, and I almost wish I could see how she would work as a character in a story where there aren’t murderous unicorns trying to wear her intestines like a scarf.

It could even be called “And hell took a siesta” or something, just as long as we see her dealing with things even more terrifying then genocide like taxes, office politics, and crippling depression.

P.S. I’m totally going to steal that title name if you don’t use it.

[Bright Roast]

Rose is a good pone.

[Elitrino]

Gotta say, she's a pretty pone. And her stubbornness and drive to live is admirable. I still don't very much like her

[Acadians6545]

Oh hey there's my comment!!! I stand by what I said.

[M4Sharman]

Poor horse. I just want to give her a hug, and maybe an assault rifle to deal with any mutated Unicorn threats.

[mm3100]

I like Rose, even after everything. She was obviously traumatized and lost her mind. Who wouldn't after your literal god tried to eat you multiple times, and then Gods family tries to do the same. She was tragic character, still feel sad for Fizzlepop.