Alright, music people, here's how it's going to work: I have the final four listed below for you all to vote on. List them chronologically from most favorite to least favorite; your most favorite will get 4 points and so on (if you only want to list one or two, that's fine also). Most points after a certain amount of time (undecided as of now) becomes the icon.

Now, the main issue here is that only a couple people have really been taking part in these threads (or at least, so far as I have seen), so for all I know, 3 or 4 people could vote and they decide what happens for the other 600 (100 or so are probably inactive BUT STILL). So if that does end up happening, I'll make the decision myself. And for the sake of that, I will not vote until I am sure that the votes from the group will be counted.

Now, the selections!

1: Sent in by Dark Avenger

Beginning your music career by Dreatos

2: Sent in by Nic-Fit

I'm going to assume there is no credits needed.

3: Sent in by Lady Froey

GUITAR by ponyKillerX

4: Sent in by Lady Froey

Puttin' on a set Tonight by Starlight-81

Stuck between 3 and 4, but I rather go with 3.

3 gets my vote.

4046851 definitely the third one!

Ok here's my list.

3,2,4,1

1 because it's adorable

>3
Dat detail.

Yeah, going for 3 here.

EDIT:

Also, instead of writing a new comment, edit the comment you already have.

3, 4, 1, 2.

There you go, my most favorite to the least. Can I go home now?

4046851 1, 3 or 4. Maybe 3 would make a better upper banner.

1, 3, 4, 2

4046851
I like the first one.

4046851 3

4046856 4046874 4047155 4047643 4047650 4047849 4048070 4048803
Guys, feel free to make a list of favorite to least favorite. Kind of like what 4047709 did. (If you only want to vote for one or two, feel free to say that, too.)
Also, instead of writing a new comment, edit the comment you already have. Less clutter, less confusion. Thank you!

I'm going to vote 4, 1, 3, 2.

My vote, 2.
Less is more, and it is pleasant to look at.

3 :3

1 or 4.

4050716
Is there one you have preference over? It's hard to count a vote when the vote is a choice between two options.
You can say "this is my first vote, this is my second one" if you want. If that helps at all.

4052836 That's exactly what I meant.

Personally I'd prefer number 4

1

4052856
OH.
'kay.

1