Merry May's life has always been dull and repetitive, she's stuck doing work she hates. Her only joy is in the stars, but even they can't fix her. So when Star Hunter, a stallion willing to help and love her, comes along, she finds it hard to resist.

Connor and Sweetie Belle have been doing some quality time together: helping with homework, walking to school, playing, talking, comforting after a personal dispute. After a while, Sweetie Belle begins to crush on the colt. She wants more than anything for him to be her coltfriend, but what will hold her back? The Cutie Mark Crusaders, Connor's obliviousness, or the fact that Connor is already dating Fluttershy? Dun-dun-DUNNNNNNN!