Which pony would you like to give a pet?

As in petting them with your hand.

A perfect example. By irisarco on derpibooru. Link: https://derpibooru.org/images/2639768?q=artist%3Airisarco

Comments

[sunsetshimmer_13]

SUNSET

I PET SUNSET
derpicdn.net/img/2019/10/30/2183070/medium.gif

[Bendy]

5538853
Sure. I'd pet her too.

While I love to pet Princess Celestia, I have a strong feeling I would want to give Rainbow Dash a pet first.

[Who you think I am]

Fluttershy, she's just so adorable and sweet. But a close second would be Twilight.

[Bendy]

5538856
Personally, I would love to pet Twilight Sparkle over Fluttershy. I love to see that cute nerdy pony being happy.

At least at first. I would of course pet Fluttershy too.

[rikusorasephiroth]

Derpy.

[Fluttermedic115]

Fluttershy!

[hidden_pony]

EVERY.
SINGLE.
ONE.
OF.
THEM.

It's my headcannon that pony physiology is highly conductive of high frequency petting. So pet them often, pet them all! Seriously, I would wake up every morning in whatever town or city I would be at and give (consensual) petting to everypony. Then I would move to the next place, and repeat the process, ad eternum.

[TheDiscontent]

Princess Luna for sure! I'd love to find out what her mane feels like.

[Herald of Opera]

I dunno. They're sapient, so who would have enough sense of decorum to make it not weird? Maybe Princess Celestia, before she stepped down?

[Hiroblade]

Oh there are so many to pick but it would be Celestia. If not her it would be Moondancer

[MetalGenocide]

5538890
The only correct answer.

[Corey]

derpicdn.net/img/view/2020/7/6/2392555.gif

[Eating Pancakes]

Fluttershy, I think she'd enjoy it the most

[Samuel-Neocros]

Rainbow Dash

[Bendy]

5538867
And feed her a muffin at the same time?

5538881
She's pretty cute. But I'd pet Rainbow Dash first.

5538890
That sounds like a good idea for a story. A human's one-man mission to pet everypony.

5538903
I too would love to know that.

5538927
Oh, don't ruin the fun. I'm pretty sure they would love being petted.

5539011
I would love to feel what Celestia's mane would be like. As for Moondancer, she looks like she needs a good petting.

5539040
I'm starting to think so too.

5539060
Applejack, she be mighty cute getting a pet. With her southern accent.

5539088
You may need to earn her friendship first before petting her.

5539166
Right on. I think I would pet her first before everypony else.

[rikusorasephiroth]

5539213
Exactly!

Luna would get petting, hugs and everything else.

[Spike7845]

gotta pet theem all!

[Huk]

Shining Armor because stallions need love too :

"Hey, stop scratching me! I'm not g-geee--!"

*scratching behind the ear with a smug grin* "... so, you want me to stop?"

"N-no... *blush* But no word to Cadance about this!"

If Cadance would walk in on us, it would be fun to listen to Shining trying to explain it

[Bendy]

5539508
She would demand pets too as punishment for him. XD

[Huk]

5539511

And I would be like:

"NO! No pets for you, Princess !"

That would end up well, I'm sure

[moviemaster8510]

Strangely Applejack. Nice soft fur against a firm, muscly body.

[Bendy]

5539707
She would feel nice. Hearing her southern voice would also be pretty sweet.

5539516
If she's canon version (canon-like anyway) she mostly be upset with you. However, if she's out of character fan fiction version, you are in for hell.

[Huk]

5539786

Well, if she were normal Cadance, the moment she tried to break me with her sad or angry stare, I would perform this:

drive.google.com/uc?export=view&id=1d9L3RoNQZw0HenlCdybuA70hG12OZwHG

She would stand no chance

But... if she were 'Cadanatrix'... it could get ugly (or not - depending on how you look at it ).