Starlight and Trixie are going to the Grand Galloping Gala together, Starlight eager to have a romantic night with her marefriend. However, the night becomes anything but relaxing when rumors spread about Trixie having gone up to Blueblood's bedroom.
As the Ponyville jeweler is about to close up shop, she notices a very familiar mare, Trixie, walk through the doors, insisting on finding the most beautiful necklace for the most beautiful mare. And she seems uneasy. Oh, so very uneasy.
One evening Starlight Glimmer pays her best friend Trixie a visit with one burning question in mind, but the conversation that follows is far from what she was expecting.