One month after a terrible case of heartbreak by someone she once held close to her, Twilight discovers one morning a love poem sticking out of her locker. Of course, due to her friends, the news breaks out, making it harder for them to pinpoint Twilight's secret admirer. Twilight suspects it involves an incident last month following the heartbreak.

Sunset, meanwhile, suspects Twilight's unquie behavious has something to do with Flash willing conversing with Canterlot High's own equivalent to the boogeyman.