Fallen Ideal · 5:12pm Mar 16th, 2019
For those who don't look at Equestria Daily very often, this may have flown under your radar. Let's fix that:
I especially appreciate comic and show Moondancer interacting. Space is warped, time is bendable, and ponies are adorable.
....................Amazing, just, amazing. 'Nuff said.
I thought Sunset was a bit funky, but it was fun overall.
I love Celestia here. She's my favorite character. She tries so hard to be good... she needs a hug.
The animation is gorgeous and the characters look great when they don't look...off. But the story is...eh. It takes obvious cues from the comic but fails to do in 10 minutes what the issue did in 8 pages.
shoot, I need to watch that :B
Thank you for making me aware of this amazing piece.
5028923
Nah, I get that they're telling 2 different stories. I just noticed that the animation still took some cues from the comic so thought a comparison wasn't uncalled for.
The animation's only real problem is that it doesn't convey the time period and passage of time well. There's no clear transition between if a scene is taking place in the past or present, and it doesn't give a sense of how long Sunset's "fall" was.
5028830
At least the short tried. The comic jumps tones in a second plays Celestia like an idiot, plays Sunset like a one-dimensional thug with no emotional depth. And it switches from wacky hijinks to 'Sunset's evil' via montage, and even if in-universe more time passes, the time in the above short is spent much more wisely.
That's not even going into the beautiful composition of the shots and incredible line reading from the actors.