Ha, You screwed up DHX

I have proof that seasons 1-4 can't be one year. Party of One was Pinkie's Birthday. In a Friend Indeed she says her birthday isn't for another 75 days. Thus no possible way for 1-4 be 1 year. Tanks for the memories is simply in the wrong season.

Comments

[Admiral Q Ponyform]

yup. I figure Tanks is in season three because frankly except for one part Twilight could have been a unicorn for the entire time.

[Odd_Sarge]

Oh snap you're right.

Of course you're right you're Admiral Q.

[Fresnor]

Well back then they weren't really on the continuity binge that they are on now... Granted I do mentally rearrange some of the episodes to make more sense as well as add in an extra year or two.

[Admiral Q Ponyform]

3209178 I figure it has been roughly 3-4 years since the start of the show. We don't see all the friendship reports. Even the writers said that Winter Wrap Up and Fall Weather Friends were mixed up. which they fixed in Tanks.

there attempts to set continuity is messing it up.

[The Cynical Brony]

... Your point? Odd placement in a season doesn't make it a bad episode.

[Admiral Q Ponyform]

3210084 it's the implication that everything top this point happened in a year.

A better way for them to have done this was Rainbow recounting it.

this got downvoted. I suggested something that alows the episode where it is yet not mess with countinuity.

[The Infinity Doctor]

Or it could quite possibly be that their year is shorter, and the seasons are out of order. No one's explicitly stated that the seasonal changes are quite the same as ours is? That might explain it? I don't know. Good proof, though.

[Admiral Q Ponyform]

3431586 the best way to solve this DHX could of had it as a flash back as RD got ready for Tanks hibernation.