Rainbow Dash, being famous for her great story telling, passes down the old legend of the 11:59 death train to twilight and the gang, you know, just to spook 'em, but things get a little weird when she hears the dreadful groan of the Death Train's lonely whistle. Cheating death is what she has to do to now.*TickTock* Time is running out.

Derpy is a normal, quiet mare, but fate and something dark seems to have chosen her for imminent torture. The priest is dragged to court over a case of science against religion and is accused of negligent homicide, but he is the only one who knows the true story. Can he convince the jury of his innocence by telling the real story or will the truth be revealed by the prosecutor herself?