Page generated in 0.025 seconds
Total duration
845 users online
1,198,805 hits today, 2,130,388 yesterday
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
Alright, so my initial guess was off. Poison, using the plants that Pinkie nearly sniffed (I forget a name or description at the moment.) seems to be the Cause of Death. Octavia or Maud seem to be the best guesses as to who the culprit is, and I'm sticking with my theory that Trixie is the Mastermind after going insane and starting to worship Twilight, which puts her out of the suspect list due to the Cause of Death. If she's copying Twilight, she'd probably be using a gun to kill, preferably the same one.
The only thing bothering me is how Rainbow ingested the poison in the first place. It had a delayed effect, so it could've been ingested earlier, but it's not as watertight as I'd like.
Fluttershy?!
I'm gonna say its trixie
my guess is Rainbow dash poisoned herself and went to the spot soarin died then drank the poison commiting suicide
Fluttershy did it either as a form of mercy to Rainbow Dash, or at Rainbow Dash's behest. Supporting theory to this is that the Natural Remedies book was the same one that Fluttershy was reading in the library of Chapter 6, and she was one of the only people to handle Rainbow Dash's food. Now, it is quite obvious that Rainbow Dash was poisoned, and working off the assumption that it was the deadly nightshade that poisoned her, rainbow dash could have either ingested it in food, since it was stated that Rarity and Fluttershy left the food out for Rainbow Dash, or the tray or food simply needed to be coated in the nightshade. Research into nightshade shows that ingestion is one method, but nightshade is extremely potent and can easily be fatal if introduced to the bloodstream, and Rainbow Dash had a number of cuts and scrapes on her hooves from attacking her window, and she would have then used the hooves to handle the tainted food, either to eat it or otherwise.
Further suspicion is cast on Fluttershy's presence in the alchemy room and her brewing of an unknown mixture, which in this chapter, is now taken off the burner and disposed of. Fluttershy would have a more than passing knowledge of deadly nightshade, as she says in Chapter 6 when questioned about reading the book found beneath Soaring's bed, that it was already out and that she already knew of cures. Nightshade is not only a poison but also has many medicinal purposes to treat symptoms of disease and stomach problems. It also is used as a form of eye drop to give the eyes a more seductive appearance--this could lead credence to Rarity knowing how to identify the nightshade.
Finally, why did Fluttershy pace the entire length of the throne room in such a manner. Sure, she could have been saddened and distraught, but it could also have been to obscure any results, knowing how Rarity's spell works.
Theory is Fluttershy poisoned Rainbow Dash with or without the pegasus's consent, and then summoned her to the throne room and informed Rainbow Dash of her impending demise so that she could do whatever she required to make peace with her life. Taking off, Rainbow flew from the room, through the window,causing her feather to catch on the broken stained glass, and made her way to the spot where she died. The one fact is, Rainbow willingly went to that spot, since Octavia couldn't have moved her body there being an earth pony (at least, not without being noticed;) Fluttershy is too weak a flyer to carry it.
A thing that adds additional credence is that Rainbow may have stumbled across the Remedy book left out from Chapter 6, read it, asked Fluttershy to help her, and hid it in her own room.
Or, I could be wrong.
I may be taking this way too seriously, I think. . .
I'm either going to say Maud or Fluttershy. I know Maud does her research from time to time but doesn't Fluttershy know more about medicinal stuff more than anybody out of them right now? Bah, then there is Octavia but she's been running between the library and the orrey. Ugh, I know 100% that I'm going to regret this but I'm going to say that I think it's Fluttershy.
My instincts point to Fluttershy. I believe that she poisoned Dash at her request. The "personal things" that Dash brought up had to do with how much Fluttershy owed her. Possibly also promising Fluttershy a way out, or saying that it was technically suicide so Fluttershy wouldn't be punished. Rainbow Dash brought Fluttershy the necessary ingredients and had her brew up the poison. That slip with PH2 on it was describing the acidity of the poison and Fluttershy most likely used it to be sure that the poison was ready. She put it in the tea for Dash to drink, and she then flew out the window to lay in the spot that Soarin' had died in.
If I had to guess, Rainbow Dash.....comitted suicide, evident from her disdain of Celestia and Luna before dying from .... vomiting from the poison that either herself or Fluttershy created? Right in the spot where Soarin had died.
Fluttershy said 'personal things' that she didn't want to talk about just like how Aoi Asahina and Sakura in Dangan Ronpa .That Hina is the only one who ended up knowing that Sakura comitted suicide to prevent anymore murder then she tried to mislead her own friends during the investigation. It's pretty obvious that Fluttershy the one who knew that Rainbow Dash will try to commit suicide after talking about those 'personal things' because Fluttershy refused to speak about it.
I think Rainbow Dash goes toward the library for book regarding how to mix poisons since she obviously had no interest for any other books outside of Daring Do then goes up toward the infirmary to get the ingredients before going to the alchemy lab where she mixed the poisons. Added the fact that there's that book about Natural Remedies and Medicinal Plants inside 'Soarin's Room'. Rainbow Dash didn't know anything about chemistry or plants for that matter so she needed those books.
I think Rainbow comitted suicide because she's flipped, meaning just lose all will to live while telling Fluttershy, her closest friend since Flight School about her plans. In the end, Fluttershy could read Rainbow's intention. Maybe Rainbow Dash did it so Fluttershy alone could escape?
Or maybe Fluttershy created those poisons under Rainbow Dash request? My theory of suicide still stands, thought
Fluttershy's the killer, Trixie is the mastermind.