Equestria's enemies have returned and they became allies. But you challenged the leaders to a duel to determine Equestria's fate. However you're carrying an artifact that has the power to redeem a soul (Like the cross from Dante's Inferno the game) the downside it can only redeem one soul.

Who will you redeem and who will you slay?

Queen Umbra (Rule 63 Sombra)

Queen Chrysalis

If I to choose to redeem... Umbra.

As for Chrysalis...

Sorry changeling lovers

4165267 All HAIL THE GOOD QUEEN CHRYSALIS.

I LOVE YOU CHRYSALIS.

4165267 I'd choose Queen Chrysalis, I can't justify leaving a whole species leaderless and probably to their extinction, sorry Umbra, I'll try to make it quick and painless.

if i had a object like that i would probably destroy it,if the villains are allies already there should be no need for a duel except for fun.

also a duel doesn't always end in death, the victor decides the fate of the loser often.

4165267 Chrysalis. Why? Numbers. It's nice to be able to bum rush your enemies and win every time.

4165267 I would save Umbra and burn Chrysalis, eh.

4165481

4165492

4165267 Umbra

4165267
Redeem them both half way and tell them that if they want to be completely redeemed they'll have to work for it. Redemption doesn't really mean a lot if you can just snap your fingers and make it better; you need to earn it to be meaningful.

4165502 Pick one you pansy.

4165497

4165511

4165517

4165522 Socialist Canada, eh.

4165267
Not very heroic, but take a third option and kill both of them. They are threats. Said "full redemption" could probably be gone back upon.

4165533 I thought we were communists and a US state though.

Gotta go with Chrysalis. While Umbra might be a great battlemage, I've learned that putting all your eggs in one basket doesn't usually work out, so getting the ally with a whole army behind her would definitely be preferable. Even if she is horribly tactically incompetent...

4165267
No brainer.

Kill Umbra.

Try to pull Chrysalis out of that dark place...if not, then she dies too.

That's how it should be.

4165267