This group is for anypony who thinks Sunset Shimmer deserves a second chance in Equestria or a chance at forgiveness and/or redemption. Whether you are a Sunset Shimmer fan or a sympathizer, or just like her in general, you are definitely welcome here.

Also, to any and all current members of this group, as well as all future ones, PLEASE DO NOT ADD A STORY TO THIS GROUP WITHOUT CONSULTING AN ADMIN FIRST.

Sister Groups:
Sunset Shimmer Appreciation Group

Comments ( 30 )
  • Viewing 11 - 30 of 30
Comment posted by Golden Fang Ryu Shenron deleted Jul 17th, 2022

At first, I didn't like Sunset Shimmer. Then the second EQG film came around and showed the world how you redeem a character on the moral AND meta level! Shimmer for life!


Besides, there's a certain saying called "Show, don't tell". If Sunset does or doesn't want to go back to Equestria, why is it so difficult for them to SHOW that in the series? We have to wait a whole year for each movie to come out, so telling someone she MIGHT do something is completely useless if it doesn't happen. It's been more than two years since the first Equestria Girls movie, and there hasn't been a single bit of licensed material that depicts Sunset coming back to Equestria for a visit. Not a movie, not an episode, not even a COMIC BOOK of Sunset Shimmer going back to Equestria AFTER her redemption has seen the light of day! So either SHOW us why she won't go back, or just put her in the damn show already!

403821 I'm not right in the head.

403817 I can't believe you just replied to a comment I posted over a year ago. -_-


So yeah, I'd be pretty crushed myself if I were to suddenly find out that she would never come back to Equestria. I mean the Breezies have to go back to their own world, but Sunset can't go back to hers? What kind of sense would that make?

Now that we're on the other side of movie 3 and she's found herself a place in the human world, here's a thought:

How would you feel about her being able to return to Equestria, but choosing not to, or returning to visit but not staying? Because the way things currently stand, I think those may be very real possibilities.

I'm the newest member!

I'm the 100th member. :yay:

371276 Yeah. And Hopefully she will go back where she belongs by the end of the next movie. Let's just hope Hasbro does not botch the ending for Sunset Shimmer in Rainbow Rocks.

Aw, shucks. :twilightblush:

But yeah, I'd say that I'm the most vocal person I know that is opposed to the idea of Sunset never returning to Equestria. It really pissed me off when Sunset didn't go back at the end of the first movie. But I'm a little more optimistic thanks to the recent news about Sunset Shimmer having a major role in Rainbow Rocks. At least we'll actually get payoff to her turning good at the end of the first movie.

370962 It's nice to know that someone agrees with me on that point. Especially when that someone is one of my favorite authors of all time on this site!:heart:

370926 Sunset Shimmer was the character that made me a fan of the show. If I'm a Brony, it's because of her. So yeah, I'd be pretty crushed myself if I were to suddenly find out that she would never come back to Equestria. I mean the Breezies have to go back to their own world, but Sunset can't go back to hers? What kind of sense would that make?

And I might check out your stories sometime. I can't guarantee I will, though I'll certainly consider it.

370923 Yeah, I can see her singing something like this. I think if it were a slower rhythm beat, and sounded a decent amount sadder, it would be perfect.

At the very least, by the end of Rainbow Rocks I hope she returns to Equestria with Twilight (Permanently this time) and seeks out and receives forgiveness from Princess Celestia.

By the way, have you by any chance read any of my stories? I have three up on both Fimfiction and Two of them are completed while the third one is still in progress but I am suffering from major writer's block right now which is preventing me from forming ideas as to how to progress with it. All three of them involve Sunset Shimmer (or will in the case of the third one.).

What about the song, though?

This song kinda reminds me of Sunset's situation at the end of the first movie. I can almost hear her singing something like this.

368820 Ah. Now that makes sense. Thanks for the clarification.

I admire your enthusiasm.:pinkiehappy::rainbowdetermined2::raritystarry::scootangel::twilightsmile::yay::heart:

368814 It's a reaction to the group's name!

368800 I do what? What is this supposed to be?:duck::unsuresweetie::applejackconfused:

368801 Well I can't argue with you there. Even that is mostly part of a fandom.:ajsmug:

But I digress. I like Lyra too. In fact I like all ponies. But Sunset Shimmer is one of my top favorites and I am sticking with that.

  • Viewing 11 - 30 of 30