Pinkie Pie: Pinkamena Diane Pie 1,626 members · 1,867 stories
Comments ( 5 )
  • Viewing 1 - 50 of 5

With an upcoming episode about the Pies, I got to thinking:

If Pinkie's granny is pink, and her mother is named Cloudy QUARTZ...

Could Granny Pie be named Rose Quartz Pie?

4798010
In Too Many Pinkie Pies she refers to "Nana Pinkie", though obviously she'd have two grandmothers.

(And it's possible that "Nana Pinkie" is actually a great-grandmother or a great-aunt or something.)

4798035 I got a hypothesis for Nana Pinkie! Older Pinkie Pie goes back in time to be Granny Pie or the other Nana(If there is another Nana)!

What about surprise thou?

...even thought my headcanon is that she s pinkie'-long-lost-evil-twin-sister considering she s the originql concept of pinkie by faust, but she was also the g1 pony faust was using as ref, which is why other people headcannon her being the gran-ma

4798035 In English, you can have Two grannies, one on each side of the family, while there is nothing against the next gen Grand granny as well.
4800338 Now there are Too many Pinkie Pie's again .. but there is a G3 Pinkie Pie who is actually a younger version of the Pinkie we see in G4.
On that note, she seems to be ageless and a filly in a Mare's body; rather than a dumbed down Mare.

  • Viewing 1 - 50 of 5