Aug
14th
2021
Fanfiction · 1:10am Aug 14th, 2021
Need your opinions on this. It’s clear the idea of Soldier of Three Armies wasn’t suited for a crossover. In fact, making it a crossover with MLP made it worse in my opinion.
That being said, should I make a Fanfiction story with the same premise? No MLP, still have an Imperial faction led by Thrawn scheming against Palpatine, a stronger Rebel Alliance, Imperial Civil War, no Valkorion, and no Yuuzhan Vong/Grysks.
Let me know what you think. I was thinking the story starts with SCAR Squad and a scientific team under Thrawn’s command discovering Darth Malgus’ body frozen in carbonite and he ends up being the Darth Vader for Thrawn.
Id read this, so i say go for it. Where would you post it?
The crossover was what appealed to me, so not sure I'd be as interested if it didn't have it.
5568486
Fanfiction.net
5568489
Sorry to hear, but the idea was never meant to be a crossover. I wrote it because I thought it was possible, but the more I wrote, the more I realized I’m diverging from the original idea. Valkorion was never suppose to be there. The Songsteel sword with Darth Vectivus and Traya weren’t suppose to be there. Outside forces weren’t suppose to be involved. The Citadel wasn’t suppose to happen.
Really I’m betraying myself by straying from my vision, so I decided when I have time, I need to get back on track.
you have an interesting take and the SW universe and Twilight looking at it. please doin't abandoned it. maybe refocus on what the core story is.
I'd still read it. But the crossover with Twilight and Spike was nice. You could keep the Twilight and Spike banished idea, just make it so they magically left a normal Equestria. One that has no idea of/or Is even in the same reality as that of the story. Either way I'll read it as I enjoy your works, and was most disheartened by the cancellation of it and PBM,WIM.
I do like this story. It is fun to read as well as enthralling. I like alternate universe stories with different takes on the characters personalities.
I really enjoyed the story but mostly for the Imperial content. I would love to see this continued whether it be restarted and retried on Fanfiction.com or more of the current story added.
Possible for the Reedit of the story or new version.
Please keep Twilight and Spike in the story
Sounds good though Im iffy on the Darth Malgus bit it feels like it would undermine the ‘normal people telling the force to screw off” impression the original had
So did you already start remaking this? If so what's it called so I can find it and read it.
5655709
https://m.fanfiction.net/s/13952588/1/Star-Wars-Divided-Empire