What do you think? · 3:10am Oct 1st, 2015
In "the Last Roundup" our favorite background pony Derpy talks for the first time, but why did they decide to change it? I saw this episode before it was changed, and prefer that version over the new. What do you brony and pegasister's think?
Old Derpy
I have to disagree. Back then in the Last Round Up, the actress who did Derpy's voice thought that Derpy was a boy, and that's why her voice sounded that way, but in episode 100, Derpy was voiced by Tabitha St. Germain (I believe) and I loved her new voice soooo much
3434235
Either way, I still think it sounds like a girl The old version just sounds like a more goofy voice
3434253 Idk. I just know that I hadn't rally liked Derpy before I watched episode 100. I can understand that old fans and people who watched MLP since 2010 loved her, but for me, I never understood why was all the love she got, until episode 100. She and Dr.Whooves were the stars of that episode, and I really liked them
3434235 Another thing, in the new version they made it so that her eyes were normal, and not all messed up like in the old version, so why did they fix that when that's part of what makes Derpy, Derpy?
3434262 Noe, they didn't fix her eyes completely, just a little and they changed her voice, so that she would seem 'less disabled', that's what the writers said.
3434265 Watch the video closely, and her eyes are completely fixed in the newer version, and I'm guessing they fixed that because it made her look r******d I don't like to use the "r" word, because it's very offensive to someone like me with a disability
3434281 Oh, sorry.
3434297 You've never used that word against me, but it's okay That and I've watched the video multiple times, and noticed that her eyes are fixed in newer version
3434309 Yes, they did it for the reason I mentioned.
3434362 Another thing, if you look closely when Derpy pulls Rainbow into the hole with her, she has no wings OOPS! Animation error!
3434379 Oh, I guess you don't know that Derpy herself is an animation error, right? Back in episode 1 of Season 1, an animation error caused a certain gray Pegasus with bubbles Cutie Mark to have derped eyes, and since that day, she was known as Derpy Hooves! Don't believe me? Check out IMDb or any other source.
3434955 Yes, I did know that
3434978 Did you know about the 'New Derpy'? Well, since Derpy has had her episode, spotting her in the background has become a little easy and not interesting, so they made this mare in Canterlot Boutique episode...
3.bp.blogspot.com/-03MBBsFeVZY/VfRyHo9k_NI/AAAAAAACYRY/njPzRpS5X3A/s640/5.PNG
Why do I think she's the new Derpy? Because she appeared in one of the newspapers in the latest episode; Made in Manehatten.
I can only laugh now
3435003 I think they just threw that in as humor
3435093 Yeah, but who knows? The fans already began spotting her, so yeah, she's probably the new Easter Egg after Derpy.
3435097 I prefer old Derpy
3435110 To be honest, me too