Yes she was being foolish, but he still shouldn't do that. I don't think he will again until the possible forum deletiion scare is over and we'll have to be more lenient anyway, but for now, should we punish him? I think he's a contributor. I can simply remove that status from him. I'm perhaps a bit past due for something more serious anyway.

6128109
Sure, I'd be fine with him getting demoted for that.

6128109
I say just demote him and be done with it.

6128109

Give him the warning and demotion. There's no need to extrapolate this.

6128109
Well, he is from 4Chan so the fact that he said that is to be expected but yeah, that's a valid reason for demotion.