• Member Since 24th Jul, 2012
  • offline last seen Last Friday

coandco


Inconceivable!

More Blog Posts10

  • 479 weeks
    AT LAST, SIR TERRY, WE MUST WALK TOGETHER.

    Terrible news today. Terry Pratchett, luminary (and incredibly prolific) writer, has died today at age 66.

    2 comments · 462 views
  • 489 weeks
    An interesting article/series on writing

    Hello all!
    I just came across this, and thought it had some really insightful explanations of the sort of thing I look for in fics:
    http://yudkowsky.tumblr.com/writing/level1intelligent

    (referring to a scene from the second Hobbit movie where Thorin behaves in a particularly stupid way)

    Read More

    1 comments · 420 views
  • 524 weeks
    My new thing: acappella song covers

    So. I realize I haven't posted here in over a year, but here's a new thing I'm starting:

    Read More

    0 comments · 366 views
  • 580 weeks
    Non-MLP fanfiction reviews

    Despite the fact that I've been reviewing MLP fanfiction exclusively for the past couple of months, FiMFiction doesn't hold a lock on good stories. With that in mind, here are a few reviews of standout fanfiction from other communities. As always, I abstain from assigning numerical ratings because I try to review only the really exceptional fics -- there's enough dross that I don't feel the

    Read More

    5 comments · 611 views
  • 580 weeks
    Reviews, Part 6

    All right, I've accumulated a few more exceptional fics, so here's a full review:

    The Powers of Harmony (ongoing)

    Read More

    0 comments · 401 views
Dec
31st
2014

An interesting article/series on writing · 8:12pm Dec 31st, 2014

Hello all!
I just came across this, and thought it had some really insightful explanations of the sort of thing I look for in fics:
http://yudkowsky.tumblr.com/writing/level1intelligent

(referring to a scene from the second Hobbit movie where Thorin behaves in a particularly stupid way)

We could say that these strange creatures lack a certain sort of awareness. The scriptwriter wants us to be yelling at movie!Thorin, “No! You fool! Don’t do that!” but it does not occur to the scriptwriter that Thorin might yell this at himself, that Thorin might detect his own idiocy the way we see it plain upon the screen. Movie-Thorin has no little voice in his own head to yell these things at him, the way that you or I are the little voices in our own heads. We could call movie-Thorin a Hollywood Zombie, or H-Zombie for short.

Specifically, I love characters who, even if they're not necessarily explicitly genre savvy, at least behave like they're acting like people rather than hollow shells who do whatever is convenient for the plot. Shoutout to Hoopy McGee here, as he's the author that best exemplifies this trait, to me -- I was consistently impressed by the way all of the characters in his stories (even the villains) acted in reasonable fashions from their own perspectives. I'd highly recommend Project: Sunflower for that reason.

If you found the "Level 1 intelligent characters" article interesting, you might like the rest of the series:
http://yudkowsky.tumblr.com/writing/

coandco

Report coandco · 420 views ·
Comments ( 1 )

Shoutout to Hoopy McGee here

D'aww, thanks :twilightsmile:

I see that sometimes in movies/TV/books, and it really drives me crazy. I mean, granted, sometimes people will do something silly/stupid by impulse, but after the impulse runs out there's usually that moment of "Oh, crap... what did I just do?" They don't usually just keep on going.

Login or register to comment