I'm working on a new story where the CMC get turned into Merponies! Do you guys have ideas for what should happen?

4456988 First question, who transform them and why? Are they ever going back?

4456988 ,you'll need a good villan, if the story is going to have one. I suggest you plan out the major characters first before the plot in detail.

4461035 Oh yeah, a good Villain can lift an otherwise bland story to greatness.
4456988 How and why are they turned into mer-Ponies?
Are they going to explore the Apple Dam again?

I kind of hope you don't leave them as fishes on dry land here.

As Mer-Ponies, which kind of a tail would they have+