After a severe burn that scars his face and rids him of a wing, royal attorney Justice Scale is sent to Ponyville by order of Princess Celestia. Despite his anxiety of the situation, he goes there, and meets a strange group of ponies.

Little does he know, those ponies--and himself--are linked to the ancient Elements of Harmony. Which is fascinating in and of itself--but the added fact that his friends--and his alter, Coin Flip--are all villains!