Okay, if your wondering how the League will grade your story then here you go:

The Categories above will be divided into three Major areas that each member of the League will grade upon.

Grammar/Spelling/Syntax
-Organization
-Clarity
-Tone
-Word Choice

Plot
-Consistency
-Redundancy
-Clear Theme
-Developed Plot
-Flow and logic

Characterization
-Properly Developed Characters
-Consistency

Types of Review

1. Grammar, Punctuation, Format and Word Usage
- English Grammar:
Tenses
Sentence Structure

- Punctuation:
Punctuation

- Format:
Paragraph Spacing
Paragraph Indentation
Use/abuse of Author’s Notes

- Word Usage:
Spelling Mistakes
Use/Abuse of Words
Being Unclear

2. Plot
- Plot:
Loopholes
Excessive Deviation from Canon
Tone and Atmosphere
Presentation (e.g. “show, don’t tell”)

- Meta-Plot:
Clichés
Fan-hated story devices

3.Characters
- Characters:
Excessive Deviation from Canon
Inconsistent Characterization
Mary Sue/Gary Stu

- Character Dialogue:
Consistency
Excessive Deviation from Canon
Word Usage

(Three is probably best, since it’s guaranteed that one person will be unavailable at any given time)

Format of Review

(To be made in comments of story)

***

[Author]’s review request [date] – [Type of review]

A. Quick summary

B. Details
(Ideally, segment your review using the sub-categories above)

C. Tips for improvement

D. Score

~The Writers League [Name]

***

(I don't think a word limit is necessary)