• Member Since 18th Aug, 2012
  • offline last seen March 31st

permeakra


More Blog Posts2

  • 498 weeks
    [no title]

    Common headcanon about changelings includes ability to sense emotions. This, actually, is an excellent justification for them being fundamentally better towards each other, than ponies (and humans and any other race), as they don't need to guess and account others feeling, they need to learn to ignore them. From perspective of such creatures ponies, being food source or not, are fundamentally

    Read More

    1 comments · 486 views
  • 562 weeks
    Some undeniable sad truths. I want someone write an AU fic changing them. Posted here as reminder

    1) Nightmare Moon had great potential that was dumped.
    2) Sunset shimmer was the only pony with guts to go against the system and her potential was dumped.
    3) Discord had great potential as ultimate Big Bad that was dumped
    4) Equestria is tyranny with good publicity.
    5) Changelings have great potential as everyday performers and probably two-thirds of performers are changelings

    Read More

    1 comments · 352 views
Oct
11th
2014

[no title] · 7:26am Oct 11th, 2014

Common headcanon about changelings includes ability to sense emotions. This, actually, is an excellent justification for them being fundamentally better towards each other, than ponies (and humans and any other race), as they don't need to guess and account others feeling, they need to learn to ignore them. From perspective of such creatures ponies, being food source or not, are fundamentally socially inferior and deserve pity and charity at best and mercy kill at most, depending on details of the culture. Given that, changelings taking over ponies could be good for ponies. Think about it: aristocrats (i.e. wealthy bigot as they mostly portrayed) gone, most management positions taken by people who knows if you like your government or not and so on. This opens entirely knew possible viewpoint to write changeling invasion.

In response to this post.

Attempts to justify the invasion using historical parallels are mostly bullshit. Both ponies and changelings are too different for this to work. Still, if we play the card, the most common real reason for invasion would be decision of leaders. It does not matter what masses think about it, once leaders set course, they will justify invasion and its form, be it Drang nach Osten, invasion of Iraq, or Black Ships. Anyway, the point is that culture and views of the invaders are secondary to decisions of their leaders. Once a decision is made, propaganda (be it truthful or not) can be used to manipulate masses, and people in general are quite easy to manipulate.

The reason for invastion from leaders' perspective falls into three categories: personal gain, gain of invading people, gain of people being invaded. I'm a cynic and honestly believe that two latter are very rare, but in case of changelings because of common headcanon it may be different.

Now, another possible justification for the invasion starts with changelings using absolutely alien ethical framework (insert appropriate framework here), either because they are completely different (hive mind and all, may result in assimilation plot) or live in very different environment (Badlands where survival of the many depends on absolute dedication of everyone, may result in totalitarian utilitarian). Writing alien mind is very difficult, so mostly this results in quite bad quality. Of course, effort counts and I would like to see a good fic with absolutely alien changeling, but writing one requires at least basic education in anthropology and really hard work in worldbuilding, and most writers are not ready for it, even if their other writings are good.

Report permeakra · 486 views ·
Comments ( 1 )

If Changelings can sense Pony emotions, that doesn't mean they care about the ponies (much like the psychic Festum in Fafnir anime). Propaganda idea is interesting.

Login or register to comment