Should I completely rewrite 'Eternal Love'?

So, the title says it all, I am reading over my story 'Eternal Love' and I kind of find it a bit stale and repetitive. So I am wondering, should I completely rewrite it?
This of course, will be my 4th rewrite of it, but yeah... what do you, my readers, think?

Comments

[Dusty Sage]

Generally, I'm of the "give it a chance" school of thought, especially since early thumbs seem to be pointing upward. (I pulled one back for rewrite once, but it was terrible; I mean, nopony liked it at all.)

[Swift Quill]

Oh that was about the 3rd rewrite, this version is actually the 4th rewrite ^^