A sickening crunch, followed by a strange slurping sound pierced the darkness. Twilight Sparkle had locked herself in the closet to hide from the beast, but her friends weren't so lucky. She recalled what had happened, how a simple Nightmare Night celebration had turned into a nightmare.
First there was Rarity, she took a step outside to get some fresh air, only she never came back. Somepony finally went after her, but all they found was a small pool of blood and part of the fabric from her costume. Rainbow Dash volunteered to look for her while the police were called.
She was the next victim. There was a knock at the door an hour later,She was standing there with a blank expression on her face. Then her wings fell off. She couldn't speak, her throat had been torn out. She was dead, just standing there. The killer had propped up her body.
Panic had set in, everypony fled the scene, running out the back door, the killer had placed a trap there. Applejack couldn't duck in time, the blade cutting her head clean off. Her hat falling to the ground in the most dramatic way.
Then the killer stepped inside the building, a mask covering its face, gender indeterminate, but it was fast.
Fluttershy was halfway through screaming when her heart was torn from her chest. She slumped to the ground, blood poring from the hole.
Pinkie Pie was having a breakdown. She was crying in a corner, muttering Celestia knows what, Her eyes shrunk when she noticed the killer's shadow fall over her. It grabbed her and broke her neck, then while she was gasping for breath in her final moments, it finished her off with a sledgehammer.
Twilight hid in the closet, waiting for her imminent demise. She couldn't focus enough to teleport away, she was done for.
Gummy continued to feast on the corpse of his former master, putting his newly grown in teeth to work.
This explains why gummy must not have teeth
Completely opposite of what FOE said. Gummy lived for a couple centuries, but never got teeth.
3425031
I don't get it. Is it because he would turn into a sledgehammer wielding maniac?
3425226 never read FOE, too long of a story with too many spinoffs for me, maybe some time when i have WAY to much time on my hand and nothing to do
3425430
Don't read the spinoffs. Only read the one written by kkat. It's on here. And it's one of the best pieces of literature I've ever seen, including non-pony lit.
3425474 see, that right there helps a ton because I didn't even know the original author
3425483
Yeah, she just posted it here maybe 2 months ago.