Button Mash makes an apology cake for Sweetie Belle.
[Sex] tag probably not needed but I don't feel like arguing.
Chapters (1)
- Member Since 5th Dec, 2018
- offline last seen 2 hours ago
SockPuppet
I like writing about the worst day of a character's life; it lets us see the mettle inside. (Pronouns: RB/20 )
SockPuppet
Joined 5th Dec, 2018 ·
Offline
Also LikedSimilarAuthor
- SockPuppet · 1.3k words · 60 7 · 875 views
- SockPuppet · 1k words · 69 11 · 1.4k views
- SockPuppet · 1.1k words · 39 8 · 851 views
- Mockingbirb · 3.6k words · 30 1 · 635 views
- SockPuppet · 1.3k words · 118 11 · 1.4k views
- Samey90 · 12k words · 105 4 · 1.3k views
- Forcalor · 1000 words · 26 0 · 524 views
Featured In10
Cutie Mark Crusaders4,489 stories ·1,747 members
Comedy4,737 stories ·1,292 members
Rarity3,855 stories ·2,002 members
Sweetie Belle2,661 stories ·1,640 members
- Rarity & Sweetie Belle432 stories ·252 members
- Rumble315 stories ·204 members
Sweetie Belle is the best pony476 stories ·195 members
Button Mash824 stories ·1,382 members
Join our SubscribeStar to remove these adverts!
Join our SubscribeStar to remove these adverts!
Stats
Page generated in 0.038 seconds
Total duration
1,087 users online
1,682,801 hits today, 1,996,409 yesterday
FIMFiction
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Follow & Support Us
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
can u get... pregante?
Good joke
Sweetie Mash is the one and only true paring, and I will fight to the death over this
i.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/mobile/000/028/925/Screen_Shot_2019-03-15_at_11.01.54_AM.jpg
Poor Button never got "The Talk". All he knew was that he bumped into Sweetie Bell at the market, and next thing he hears is she's pregnant.
11500153
RIP him. 🪦
Although I was thinking she only made Button use a condom, not Rumble.
Oof size: big.
I agree, the sex tag wasn't needed. Acknowledging the existence of pregnancy doesn't rate it.
Wonder who came first: Scoots or Sweetie Belle?
How is fole formed? How filly get pragnent?
11500119
Wait, is she.... gregnante?!
There are a variety of viable Crusader ships. I'm largely indifferent to them, but I greatly appreciate the contrast between Sweetie's suitors here. Fun little story. Thank you for it.
Sweetie got prengt.
HOW 2 GOT BABBY PWNY
Well, good news, Button. You don't have to worry about child support.
A wedding is just a bunch of people nth-wheeling, and you can't change my mind.
11500795
You're not wrong.
Haev my upvot, u carzy Sock!
11500314
There's a ponified version!
11500130
I mostly agree, but ButtonXSilver Spoon is okay.
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/214622/seven-minutes-in-heaven
While I have nothing inheritly against Sweetie/Rumble, the fact that you chose to use it in a netorare story is a MAJOR turnoff for me. This was a cute little story until you added that unpleasant and unwelcome twist at the end. Made worse by the fact that Rumble just had to rub Button's nose in the fact that the mare he was clearly close to and worrying over had apparently been cheating on him.
Yes, this was a very unpleasant story for me. Sorry.
11500935
'k.
11500935 I wholeheartedly agree. Seeing Button trying to steal Sweetie (obviously not seeing the fact that she was already really close to Rumble) by claiming her foal as his is a major problem. Obviously it was a big mistake on Sweetie and Rumble's part to include him as a comet in their relationship if he couldn't understand that was all he would ever be.
11500915
This is... acceptable.
11500935
I'm glad I'm not the only one with an issue here. I'm sure people will downvote me thinking I'm a SweetieMash shipper, but honestly this story just doesn't work.
11500946
Crap like this doesn't help.
Okay. First off like the first person I quoted said. I have nothing against who you want to ship with who. Sweetie can get with Spike, Rumble, Applebloom. Who cares, long as the story is good.
The problem is, this story basically can be summed up in one simple way: "I (The author) hate the SweetieMash ship, RumbleBelle is the way to go. Fuck you all."
At least that's most certainly how it's coming across. I'm not sure why people are saying "Good joke" to this, because there really isn't one.
Let's break this down shall we? First off, what is the relationship between Button and Sweetie in this story? We have no damn idea. It's IMPLIED that they are a couple. Given Button is talking about having foals someday. If they are NOT in a relationship. Why was he let in at all? Did they date and break up? I feel that would have come up. The only reason none of this is touched upon is because it'd ruin the 'Twist' which frankly I just find to be bad storytelling. It's only written/shown in this way to fool us the readers, and makes no actual sense in the context of the world.
"Did you apply for any job-jobs?" Play testing videogames IS a job job. Hey Sweetie, go say that to an actual play tester. Ask them if they ever tried to get a "job-job" See how well that goes.
Oh but of course the 'joke' is that Button plays videogames so he's a man-child (Stallion-foal?) And thinks he'll just get to play videogames for a living!
I'm assuming that's the idea at any rate. We don't get enough of this Button's personality to get that much of a bead on him. We don't even know what he's been doing up to this point. Of course the implication is that since Sweetie is an adult and a teacher and adult Button can't even spell correctly, he's an idiot, but again that only happens because the only point of this story is to shit on their ship.
Where did Rumble even come from? Does he have a key to Rarity's shop for some reason? Does Sweetie just live there now? Also he's not going to have his chef job for very long given it's implied he just came from it. Except Sweetie was trying to go teach her class at a school, suggesting this takes place IN THE MORNING. So what? Did Rumble show up to his job for a fucking hour and then leave?
That leads to the biggest problem. If Button and Sweetie were in any sort of relationship or sleeping together that Button thought he got her "preganant" Then that flat out means she cheated on him. She lead him on, cheated on him with Rumble, and decided the best way to break the news to him was to just have Rumble flat out say he was marrying her after he knocked her up.
Don't worry Rumble. Soon as Spike shows any interest she'll go off and cheat on you with him.
Yeah hate to break it to people but this makes Sweetie and Rumble in this story to be FUCKING ASSHOLES.
I would have preferred if you just said: "Hey I hate all of you who don't like the Rumble/Sweetie Belle ship" and saved me some time.
But seriously if Button had nothing to do with Sweetie's pregnancy, why was he let in? Does Rarity not know? How does she not know? Was she in on it to fuck with Button? Why?
11501129
'K.
11501129
Cool.
11501129
11500935
i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/000/637/470/1cc.gif
Yeah I had a feeling that'd be the reaction. Look, you're a good writer. I just hate that it was used for this.
But yes, I'm annoyed. I'm annoyed because all that effort was put into something like this, but all anyone is going to do is go: "Oh he just didn't like this ship" or something.
When in reality I just want more thought put into the story. You can still have this story as is and fix the issues. Sweetie could have said something like: "Why are you even here Button?" Have her and Button talk a bit more. Make it clear that they've been broken up. I get the point is that it's to lead us on that Button/Sweetie are a thing, but it's done sloppy. Sweetie could have made a comment like: "Button we haven't... nevermind" Indicating they haven't even slept together.
I'm pissed because when you stop and look at it. The world doesn't work with the context we're given and it baffles and infuriates me that no one else seems to care.
"Dude it's just a joke" Story only works so far. That's like saying: "Dude it's just a kids show" if I pointed out an issue with something that happened in the MLPFIM the show. That shouldn't be an excuse.
11501129
There are people in the fandom who have hateboner towards SweetieMash because of its popularity or simply because it exists. It's easier to "shit on" popular ships. Same with Flashlight or Fluttercord. People don't have this problem with Rumble/Sweetie because it's not really that popular so there's no need for that. Or maybe it's directed only at Button Mash because let's be honest... he is a butt monkey kind of character quite often. Buttonbuse is a thing after all.
Had the same question too when I first read that. It was a twist, hence this story doesn't even have a 'Rumble' tag to begin with.
11501274
The funny thing is, I don't have a problem with people not liking the Sweetie/Mash ship to begin with, and while it was annoying to think I was going to get a funny story when I read this, I'm not against it being a, to put it bluntly, "Troll fic" on the ship.
What I'm angry about is that it does it in a lazy way that shows Sweetie and Rumble as assholes and no one is calling them out for it.
As the fic stands right now, I could easily write an epilogue to this story that would not only rip Sweetie and Rumble apart, make them look like entitled stupid beings, but also make Button Mash the most mature and well prepared pony in this story. No problem.
And what's irritating is it's rather easy to fix. For example:
We can change that to:
This would not only aid in the fact that Sweetie is annoyed that Button is there, as she clearly is in the next few paragraphs, but it plants a seed that exposes the truth without giving it away. Most readers are still going to believe Button and Sweetie are an item. I imagine they'd imagine she doesn't want him to see her like this, or is still annoyed with him for "knocking her up" (Even though that didn't happen, we're supposed to believe it did at this point in the story.) It's also a much more realistic reaction to him being there if the idea is to establish that Rumble and Sweetie are a thing and Button is just being an idiot.
Finish that up with an alteration of this line:
To:
THIS establishes that Button and her might have been an item or gone on a date before, but Sweetie had long since moved past him and I guess his 'foalish' ways as the story clearly wants us to see him as a loser. This still does that but makes it very clear that he's the problem. Button needs to grow up.
The story right now doesn't do this. It paints Sweetie and Rumble as I've said before. "Fucking assholes" and that's where the bad taste comes into my mouth.
Is there any chance this could be connected to Scootaloo Gets a Twilight Lecture?
11502559
I hadn't thought about that, but I suppose it's
possiblenot impossible.11502665
It's certainly a thing to think about. Scoots never did prevent her own mistake on-screen, so this story could theoretically be a sequel that has Rumble learn a thing or two.
He better get a decent job in 10 months!
Rumble???
I would think that would be on the level of winning the Powerball jackpot, especially after the CMC Day Camp event...
Does this mean Rumble's Cutie Mark is a bad drawing of a penis?
You made me cry with that piece of shit ending, asshole. Button deserves better! I hope you dig straight down in Minecraft.
Updooted and faved.
Ever thought of using this concept in your stories?
11507910
I have a really good RumBelle romance story idea, but it's as yet only about 30% of the story -- I have the opening and the ending, but not the steps in the middle that lead from opening to closing.
11507911
Cool
files.catbox.moe/ynh9q7.gif
Scootaloo x Rumble is the OTP.
11506546
That's my favorite book series!!!
(To prove it I know the dragon in your profile picture is Glory)
OMG!! You like wings of fire??
11521146
As a scaly, not only do I love it, but I got another friend obsessed with it.
11506546
Ever since 1.17, digging down isn't really a big deal.
How does she know who the father is?