It's Nightmare Night and Discord's first since he was reformed. He's been looking forward to it for months and even put together a neat costume to go with it. Until Celestia sends him a message saying he's not allowed to go.
Down in Ponyville, the ponies are preparing for a night that will never be forgotten- but nothing could have prepared them for this.
Spike's an alicorn, Twilight's a dragon, Rainbow Dash is her favourite daring adventurer, Rarity's a vampire, Pinkie Pie and Applejack are changelings, Fluttershy's dead and Sombra and Chrysalis have returned. And I'm not referring to costumes!
What is going on here?!
Edit: ANNYNF was featured on July 24/07/2014! Thank you for this surprise feature :D !
Chapters (6)
oh this is gonna be fun >:D
Dude you had me at having discord and nightmare night in the same sentence
2233790
I think that's what got most people :P
Just wondering, are their attitudes/behaviors going to change as well as appearance?
I
discord! 
2234737
You'll have to wait and see.
All I'll say is who they play and who they really are will have a huge affect on... everything.
Muahahahahahahahaha!!
Yes, <3 Discord
shit just got real
What are you talking about? Celestia trying to kill alicorn spike is hilarious
What are you talking about? Celestia trying to kill alicorn spike is hilarious
WEll i dont see why you cant have both serious and funny..
2304383
I suppose you are right there ;)
Maybe more comedy can come from Luna still being her playful, scary self, despite being convinced she's Sombra? And Fluttershy being a ghost has comedy written all over it. Anyway, I'm assuming you don't already have the story planned out, which is pretty stupid of me. That said, I really like this.
2342912
no that's fine, really, most of the story is planned out but comments like these always influence it ;)
and yes. ghost shy will be.... 'interesting'. lol
When are you going to update the story? This is awesome!
2343384
When are you going to update I really want to see more of this story.
YAY AN UPDATE
Wonderfully written as always with brilliant detail on each pony and how they react to becoming the things that they dressed as.
Keep on writing and I cannot wait to see more of your work
Your forever loyal fan
Knight-Bishop
Run. Whenever you save the world, ALWAYS make sure there's a good bit of running.
So much chaos...
encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRLas2e5AJSJAn16tlbH1Ogokd_tFOCP8olzaK7fg982vuYpGQA
WAIT FLUTTERS IS DEAD?!?!?!!?!?!?!?!??!?!!??!!
4228148 Well, yeah. She was dressed as a ghost, right. I am sure Discord wont let anything bad happen to her. Well, aside from the being dead thing.
That said, Discord must have put some sort of safeguards in place. Right?
She didn't go as a dead pony. She went as a ghost. Check the last sentence before the scene changes.
Geez, it's like Xanadu all over again, isn't it?
4231535 ok phew got me scare there for a second I thought she was dead dead like the undead ok phew
THIS IS AWESOME I LOVE IT
The first chapter looks like a hilarious start, and you got the character's personalities exactly right. Well done!
4745002
Thank you! I hope you continue to enjoy the story :)
This would be good advice for Twilight.
(the series, not the pony)
By the way, great job on the chapter!
Was this inspired by the MLP Loops Halloween special? Very similar concept.
Cliffhanger! Can't wait for the next chapter.
Wow. Back after a year? Does this mean it's for real not dead?
4745268
For now, yes, this is returning :)
4745143
No I've never actually heard of that before?
4745277
MLP Time Loops had a chapter where everypony became their costume.
4745366
Oh okay, I'll have to check it out some time :)
Just going of the description by Fluttershy being dead do u mean like zombie dead, Incpector gadget dead, or dead dead because if she is dead dead
I..I..I mi.mi..might cry
4745442
You'll just have to wait and see, wont you? ;)
What's this story again? I didn't even remember it's existence it's been so long you updated! :P
Amazing fic, I can't wait for the next update
img.4plebs.org/boards/tg/image/1365/35/1365355257181.jpg
4745479 But what if I do a bad job at waiting what if people make fun of me 4 waiting, o wait people already make fun of me.... ok I will wait with excitment
Holy Cannoli Power Pony!!!
I've never read something like this before!
And I thought that Star Swirl the Bearded encountering Weeping Angels was cool.
Anyway, I can't wait for the next chapter!
Also, congratulations on being the first writer to peak my interest!
So, it's not really magic?
YEAH, YOU TELL HER DISCORD! FREEDOM!
4746039 yep people made fun of my for my story so I quit and people stopped trying to SEW ME!!!!!!
4745069
Unless it's from the Crystal Empire of course
go discord
Buffy did it... then the Simpsons.. but it wasn't caused by a chaos spirit, this should be interesting!
let the Chaos begin!
Muhahahahahahahahahahahah!
So wait if I was there I'd turn into Mary Poppins!
Yes!