• Member Since 8th Oct, 2011
  • offline last seen Nov 7th, 2023

Nicknack


Former author and proofreader/editor/fanfic troubleshooter.

E
Source

Every weekend or so, I'm going to be writing a quick little story based on some suggestions provided over at Ponychan's /oat/ board. To avoid cluttering up my userpage with several short stories, I'm going to post them all as chapters of this story.

The tags / cover art on this story apply only to the most recent story I've added to the chapters. For posterity, all the stories' tags are as follows:

Generosity – Twilight Sparkle, Rarity. [Sad]
Ditsy Flies With a Bumblebee – Ditsy. [Slice of Life] And fuck the name "Derpy"

Chapters (3)
Comments ( 11 )
Wanderer D
Moderator

I'll be reading

An interesting idea. It's not to hard to imagine losing her magic would be devastating to Twilight.

I do feel like like the story needed a lot more detail about why her friends and family would disown her though. And honestly, I'm not sure what you could possibly do to get Fluttershy to give up on anypony.

There also seems to be someone missing - little short dude, purple and green scales, breathes fire, Twilight Sparkle is the center of his entire existence?

In my eyes, generosity is given for free. Rarity is not giving it for free, or for pity, or for feeling guilty, or for having a teacher for her daughter, or something else. In a way she is worse than Twilight, because she is destoying her element by acting. And the worst part is that she surely thinks she does something good ! :-(.

4205461 What do you mean, exactly? That Rarity defeats the purpose of generosity by forcing it on Twilight?

The words did not effect on her.

"Had no effect on her" or "did not affect her"

4213034
No, my problem is that she gains something from it. She is not giving it for free, she has Hintergedanken (ulterior motives). And I don’t mean her daughter. I believe she does it for feeling better herself.

Huh.

That certainly was short and (bitter)sweet. I would have liked to see this expanded out a little more so as to explore Twilight's past and recovery a little more. As it is now, it feels a bit... abrupt.

(As a side note, Gererosity would not happen to be autobiographical would it?)

Utterly adorable in every way- I really enjoyed this chapter!

The 'dorbs are strong with this one.
*ksssh-haaa*

Ditsy is written with all the grace of a sledgehammer. Which given the character should work, if you weren't such a sloppy hack.

4334586 Such brutal honesty. *dabs away a tear*

Login or register to comment