After one of the worst days of her life Carrot Top is asked by a dreadfully ill Rainbow Dash to help Fluttershy. Feeling sorry for the mare, the Element of Generosity agrees to help Fluttershy with getting the animals homes cleaned out. What could go wrong? Kidnapping, randsom, evil illusionists, and multiple musical numbers aside. Set in the Lunaverse, one of the more interesting alternate universes out there.
Groups
-
26w, 2dThe Lunaverse
Comments ( 31 )
Hmm. I would advise putting in some page breaks at certain points. You know, ***s, or ---s. Like for example:
Fluttershy looked even more concerned at the note of visual hallucinations associated with vertigo. (What? She had to know this stuff if she's going to be taking care of animals.) “You know what, why don't we go inside where it's nice and safe and clean out the fish tanks well away from Mommy Badger?” she sugested with a smile, glad that this way there would be no further problems.---
^^^^
Like this. It eases scene trasitions.
“And so how did she fall into the badger den that time?” Dr. Caduceus asked.
Otherwise it got a little confusing trying to keep track of the scene changes. Also there's a few spelling mistakes, not a lot, but enough that the othewise good writing made them stand out.
"randsom" in the description is not a good start. Can't comment on the rest since i only read Lunaverse stories once they're complete.
Emailed a list of spelling errors, I like doing it that way better than posting in notes. I agree with RDD on the scene translation marks, but I think the "And so how did she fall into the badger den that time?" line is a classic.
Hm...Only real complaint I have is that you need a proof reader. Badly. Otherwise, not a bad start. Though this story better be as ridiculous as that description promises.
What could go wrong? Kidnapping, randsom, evil illusionists, and multiple musical numbers aside.
You're making some big promises. Don't let me down. ![]()
So far, I have to agree with Spammy. You really need someone to look this story over. Other than that, the very idea is funny, and you did a good job capturing the evilness of badgers. Accursed little thinks and their false cuteness...
Lots of telling. Not much showing. Really needed to dialog out the scenes and let them develop more naturally and this story instantly jumps up rather substantially in quality. A few spelling and grammar errors as well. Overall, was OK, but really could use some work.
More proof reading would be good, but I'm really enjoying this story! I like that little scene of how dysfunctional the Farmers' Union is. Continuing the theme of Carrot Top being overworked and not very good at saying "no" to ponies is great. She really is a very helpful pony.
I do feel there should be more showing and less telling but you have a great deal of skill with scenery descriptions, some spelling/grammer wouldn't hurt but besides that... Let the good times role!
Loved CTs little "worse" rant especially the green mane and... parents line ![]()
a good demonstration of CTs generosity with the badger.
I think quite a few of these paragraphs couple be broken into two.
Poor CT couldn't even start her meal without being asked for a favour.
She wasn’t looking at Carrot Top so much as in her general direction, and it was getting more general by the minute.
Loved this part!.
Dash is really sick then, guess that also explain why we likely won't see much of her this fic.
Fun fact about mother badgers: they have been known to fight off grizzly bears when their young are threatened.
![]()
I think Fluttershy's vocabulary could have used a small amount of tweaking but only a little.
Loved the chicken hunt and CTs... steady decline into hunter mode ![]()
CTs mirror scene allows me this reference!
and the title allows me this: "All it takes is one rotten day to send a perfectly normal mare into madness!" if this were a t.v series there's be a JokerTop meme.
Loved the windowpane and Trixie/window jokes at the end.
Have to agree about the proofreader. Lots of typos. But still entertaining. Carrot Top makes a beautiful woobie, doesn't she?
I'm aware I need help. I tried getting a prereader but it all kinda fell through and after a week I went "Buck it!" and went ahead anyway. Editing suggestions are welcome.
>>1636182 Thank you, I'm very proud of that line myself.
>>1636263 Badgers are vicious, so I do enjoy showing how scary nature is. And don't worry, the first musical number is next chapter.
>>1636353 One of the ideas I want to address in this story is when it's OK to say no and why you need to sometimes. A bit of a complex subject.
>>1636509 I based it off that actually. Watched it three times before deciding to tone it down a bit and writing the scene.
Proofreader, yes. Good to read you're aware of that, at least. *Nods* And... I'll be wincing a lot, won't I. *Hugs Carrot Top*
>>1683849 Probably. I haven't gotten to the corrections yet, too bussy hosting Thanksgiving. Still, I think I'm doing a bang up job for a dyslexic. And yes, if this is making you wince, there shall be much wincing.
>>1637484 I have not yet started to really make her suffer. Don't worry, everyone suffers in my stories.
I'll admit, I'm a fan of slapstick humor. I grew up watching the Three Stooges and MXC. But this just seems mean-spirited. I think the badger hole was overused, honestly. I get that badgers are vicious, but you need some variety or it gets bland. Also, somepony besides CT should be involved.
Also, Carrot Top didn't have the heart to evict a mother badger? Yet in the next scene she notes they have a tendency to fight off bears? Seems she should be a bit more nervous than compassionate.
I understand that you're working on the edits, but if you need a proofreader, I'm willing to do it.
Poor Carrot Top! Did she offend the God of Slapstick or something?
She's so nice too and then suddenly BADGERS!!! That one in her field should at least be more grateful! ![]()
Also slight nit picking:
“Well Representative, are you happy with the job I did?”Windowpane and Trixie see each other enough to be on first name basis so you can simple have him call her Trixie.
"The day I go to the Gala with him is the day I marry Corona." she thought, bemused by the stupid image of Corona dressed up as a blushing bride while Trixie wore her...usual Gala get up. But then the image passed and she was bored again.
That's it! Celestia just really, really needs to get laid.
Oh, wait, it's Trixie, so never mind.
Edit: Speaking of which, it's kind of weird reading Trixie go on about liking stallions, since I'm so used to the idea that this version of her doesn't like anybody romantically, and is very adamant about that. Other than that, funny chapter and I liked the song at the end. It's just a shame that CT was too upset with the world in general at the time to actually give Trixie a chance to re-work the spell.
I think she assumes she's into stallions 'cause she doesn't realize asexual is a thing.
>>2081655 You got it. Happens all the time IRL, or else they assume they're homosexual because they aren't attracted to the oposite sex "like they should be". For a lot of us, asexuality existing is a giant "Oooohhh" moment. It was for me anyway. I knew I wasn't gay, and figured I just hadn't met a girl that caught my interest.
Trixie's rambling could use a few commas, but this chapter is much better than the first, grammaticalally speaking.
I guess everyone has a berserk button, and after having badgers press hers all day, Trixie's screw-up was the metaphorical straw that broke the camel's back.
>>2090349 That's the idea, although comas aren't strictly necessary in a grammatical sense; the ramblings are already run on and fused sentences.
>>2089611 Thank you. My own nonponyfied work. I call it For Number One (Generosity's Lament). If the title isn't a clue to something that happens later on, I don't know what is.
Oh no. Make way for Carrot Jerk! She really does push herself too hard for her own good, sometimes. I feel for her.
Wait, Carrot Top! I moustache you a question!
I know, I know, but somepony had to say it.
wow, discord isn't even needed in this continuity; just a random series of unfortunate events







223


