Cookiemilk & the Alternative Universe
written by MelodyStories
Also LikedSimilarAuthor
- Ausbrony · 422k words · 597 50 · 12k views
- Slendy · 116k words · 258 15 · 7.2k views
- Ausbrony · 68k words · 1,903 74 · 41k views
- EquestrianTwist · 30k words · 48 0 · 2k views
- darkstone57 · 12k words · 68 2 · 3.6k views
- shirotora · 128k words · 1,101 56 · 18k views
- Ausbrony · 108k words · 1,181 28 · 19k views
- SugarPesticide · 20k words · 75 7 · 3.4k views
Join our SubscribeStar to remove these adverts!
Stats
Page generated in 0.07 seconds
Total duration
949 users online
231,807 hits today, 2,673,812 yesterday
FIMFiction
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Follow & Support Us
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
Oh no!
Please don’t cancel this story! We love Cookiemilk, and you!
whaaaaaaaaa
10746761
That’s not even remotely answering the question.
10746801
WHAT
10746761
Why would she punish others for a cookie allergy? That isn't anything that can be chosen and it isn't dangerous.
10746811
They want ponies to love cookies because it’s mean to hate them also the rule is cookies only
10746828
How is it “mean” to hate them?
10746831
Because it means they hate the cookie family
10746835
Seriously? That’s like saying if they hate muffins then they hate Derpy. Or if RD hated pies then she hates the Pie family, which obviously isn’t true.
Heck, going as far as to have everyone attempt kill characters who are even implied to not like your OC just shows how Mary Sue she really is.
10746842
Cookieheart is a good princess
10746852
A “good princess” wouldn’t harass other characters over a dislike/allergy over a certain food.
10746854
They all teased her and said they hate cookies
10746860
So? There are much better ways to react to that situation instead of throwing a petty tantrum like a 5 year old.
10746866
I don’t think you would be loved by a princess if you told them their favorite thing is bas
10746877
I don’t think a princess would be loved if this is how they act towards her subjects’ opinions.
10746828
That doesn't make any sense.
10746883
viva la revolución
10746883
Saying I hate cookies in a cookie kingdom is like going on a pony website and saying I hate ponies :o
10746884
That’s what we keep tellin’ her
10746890
And? It’s not a big deal.
10746895
yes it is
10746898
Prove it.
10746901
How?
10746904
You’re making my point.
10746905
Stop acting like a sidward
10746901
The story kinda proved it.
10746926
Exactly you’re not a sidward
10746926
Huh
10746431
That's not even compelling. What'd be the point of the entire story if at the end it all just gets, 'Magically fixed' in 10 seconds flat. The only way I ever see that as an actual plot would be if she has imprisoned or some other similar state, as if she were a free unicorn or rule, why wait for ponies to come to ask for help instead of just asking.
I very much doubt that the story is gonna be about the hardships the characters go through to reach this her.
1) G4 has already covered that, no point in having a plot that covers a lesson already taught. Multiple times.
2) The main character is trying to"change hearts and minds," in the G5 Synopsis, not find a pony and fix the world in the blink of an eye.
Fairly sure I could come up with more reasons if I tried, but I'm too lazy.
10746449
I don't even see what this old late 2019 video proves. Enlighten me if you would. Have you ever considered explaining your evidence? Because it would work a lot better if you answered the question, gave evidence, and explained the evidence. Oh, and restate that question at the start if you will. Most people call this format, RACE, to Restate questions, Answer, Citations, and explaining the evidence.
10746559
A fic in which is not an actual story. It's meant to troll the readers. In fact, a two-second google search on what a troll fic is gives this,
10746564
Well, throwing away Mary Sues, the number of fart jokes, the cringe- much I go on? Actually, perhaps if you're serious about this you should get beta readers or an editor. They'd do a better job explaining than I.
10746801
Well... It does make sense... In a way, if you reorganize the sentence from
to
Make more sense now. Kind of.
10746895
Well... It is a problem, as not everyone can just ignore such comments. For example, should someone come to fimfiction to say ponies suck and are shit for this or that reason, then that person is going to create conflict. I mean, generally being disrespectful and agonizing others, would do the same thing. But this is on a much large scale as it's insulting an entire fandom.
10746926
Well, one could say the story is biased, as it was made by an author with an opposing viewpoint. Thus, the story is made that fits within the author's point. Also, it's a fictional story.
Note
Why oh why is lack of evidence such a big trend here? It's been making it a pain to go trying to resolve as best I can most of the arguments.
10747339
Who are you and why did you comment at 4 AM
10747339
You are blind to the forest because of the trees. Invest in head protection.
10747351
I'm Pensive!
1 AM in my time zone... Yeah that's still late, isn't it?
10747352
I feel I need more than head protection
10747363
Alright.
10747366
I feel naked with just those...
10747367
Well, it's up to you if that's a good thing or a bad thing. I won't judge.
10747530
10748611
O.o.o
10749499
???