Happy Birthday Dear…Who?
Happy Birthday Dear...Who?
Another lonely school day, another lonely afternoon in my garden. Trudging away from the building, I followed the short path towards the alcove where I always held the Gardening Club. But this time, there are no other members here, now it’s nothing but me and all these flowers surrounding me. I know it might sound sad and all, but I’m used to it honestly, being invisible to everyone around me is just a natural thing for me.
I reach my garden, still looking beautiful since last week. Those new members really did a great job…I say as I see some potted flowers that weren’t in the right places. Guess those three forgot to finish when they left. I slowly got on my knees, opened my bag, and brought out the trowel I always bring with me. Rolling up my sleeves, I start working on fixing the plant. This’ll be no problem for me.
I’ve been working in gardens like this my entire life. Ever since I was young, this was how I spent all of my time, and never have I met anyone who shared the same interest as mine, not even my family. Even years later, I never convinced anyone to help me out, but at the very least, the silence is pretty nice for gardening. I can pretty much plant these without even trying. It allows me to think about other things.
It’ll be my birthday tomorrow, and just like last year…and the year before that…I’m not expecting anyone to wish me a Happy Birthday. Not like I haven’t gotten any from my family, teachers, and the guidance counselor I’ve been talking to in the past few weeks, but nobody else at school said anything about it. They’re just normal days to everyone, especially me. It’s not like I need other students to really care about some day like that. Then why does it feel so worse than all the other times?
“…” They picked out some pretty good flowers, really brings out the color of the garden. I’ll have to thank those guys whenever we meet up.
“I thought I’d find you sitting around here.”
Suddenly I hear a familiar, yet unexpecting voice, especially after what happened recently. Turning around, my thoughts were right, as I saw Sunset Shimmer right behind me. To say I was surprised was an understatement, I was downright speechless. “Uh…hi Sunset…guess you did find me.”
She approached me with her hands behind her back, a toothy grin plastered on that face of hers. A part of me was a bit suspicious; sure she’s now one of the nicest students in the school, but I’m still not sure why I’m shaking a bit. “Although, I honestly wasn’t expect you to be here by yourself. Don’t you have other members of the Gardening Club?”
I stood up wiping the dirt from my hands onto my jeans. I looked up to the slightly taller girl and used my hands to hide my cheeks. “They’re…not meeting with me today, I just like coming here from time to time. That’s it.”
I watch her glance around at my garden with a frown, I could tell just by looking that something’s off. “I’m starting to get the feeling people still don’t come around here,” she said. “Doesn’t it get lonely, all by yourself surrounded by nothing but plants?”
“I’m not lonely here, Sunset,” I slightly lied. “Like I said before, I have all these beautiful flowers to keep me company. I’m mean, it’s not like I’m still just some lonely girl without any real people to hang out with, unlike you.”
She gave me a leery look, “I…didn’t mean it like that.”
“Good! Because I’d rather be with something who has no chance of forgetting anything, than anyone in this school!” Immediately I realized what I blurted out, as Sunset started to back away from me, her face with a hint of fear. My heart started to drop as I remember how I felt in that parking lot when I took her memories. That face of fear and confusion she gave us wondering where she was, all made me regret ever digging that thing out.
I sighed, “I’m…sorry about that outburst Sunset. It…really does get pretty lonely out here by myself. Guess I never bothered to really express it to others.”
“That’s okay,” I suddenly hear her say, looking up to see her give me a small smile. “I didn’t gave you a good first impression. Actually, I didn’t gave you a good second impression either, so I can’t blame you if you still don’t like me for what happened last week.”
“O-of course I don’t h-hate you Sunset! I…I never b-…blamed you for what happened,” I stumbled on my words so much that I probably sounded like such a loser. If I still had that memory stone, this would be the part where I erase her memories and restart this whole conversation over. Now that it’s destroyed, I’m stuck in an embarrassing conversation with no way out.
“Um…I’m glad you came to see me, but…” I think my stomach’s about to burst. I must be making her so uncomfortable right now. I gotta get out of this before I start sweating up a storm.
“Well, it’s been great seeing you, but…oh man, would you look at the time! It’s starting to get late!”
“It’s…only 5 o’ clock.”
“Which means that it’s time to head off to bed! Early bird catches the worm they say.”
“But you’re not even done planting those pots behind you. You’re not just going to let them sit there, are you?
Darn it. Why am I such a slowpoke? I always waste so much time spacing out. Worst of all, I can’t think of a single good excuse to get out of this corner. Defeated, I took a deep breath. “Look Sunset, I really do appreciate you coming here to see me, but after everything that happened since last week, it’s a bit awkward to just act so casually, like nothing happened, right?”
I hoped she would understand everything I was rambling about, and leave. Better to have her not here before I do something stupid right in front of her. “Well, I guess you make a good point when you think about. A villain like you can never hang out with us good guys, especially one who erases memories.”
Well, that was easier than I thought. “That’s exactly right. I mean, I wouldn’t put it entirely that way, but…”
She continued. “And to think, I came all this way just to wish you Happy Birthday. That is today, right?”
My eyes shot open and my body tensed up. Did she just? “You know today’s my birthday!?”
She shrugged her shoulders, all nonchalantly like. “I mean, I did get pretty excited when I learned it was pretty close the other day, I even brought you something, but since we can’t be friends, I guess that means we should never see each other for the rest of our lives. I best be on my way then.”
She started to turn and leave. I knew it was too easy, but I was not expecting outright manipulation. She may not be the biggest meanie anymore, but she’s definitely taking advantage of those days. “Fine! I guess you win Sunset.”
Fortunately, she turned back around. Unfortunately, she started to speak with that stern voice.
“Wallflower. You’re obviously still upset about what happened last week, with the memory stone. Me and my friends forgave you, so you don’t need to act so distant like this anymore.”
“I know, but…it’s just….it’s hard for me to really put it to words. I’m not the best at conversation.”
Those eyes gave me that same scary stare she’s been giving me the entire day. I waited for her to say something back. Until she abruptly said, “Give me your arm.”
“W-What!” After that shock, it took me a good second to understand what she meant by that. And when I did, I immediately stepped back. “Are you going to read my memories?!”
Her eyes opened in surprise at what I said. “Well that’s a first, never had anyone but my friends call me out like that. But I am going to read your memories. It’ll make things easier for the both of us if you’re not comfortable talking to me. That is, if you don’t mind me looking.”
Despite the warm look she was giving me, I still hesitated to give her my hand. With her reassurance however, I took a deep breath. “Okay, but no looking into anything private!”
“Don’t worry about that, I learned to control how much and what I see. Just take a deep breath and let me take a peek.”
I sighed as I held out my arm for her. Without hesitation, she grabbed it with her right hand, and eyes flashed white. I didn’t get a good look when she searched my memories the first time, but now that I can see her, it’s such a surreal and freaky sight to look at. A couple seconds later she released her grip as her eyes went back to normal.
“Well…what did you see?” I asked, fully aware of what the answer was already.
She shook her head in reaction, her eyes glistening with resolve. “Enough to know that you’ve been punishing yourself by distancing yourself to even the members of your club. You were even planning on canceling the club were you?”
I didn’t have time to respond, too ashamed to really say anything to her. She kept talking for me. “You’ve even went as far as to make sure nobody knew about your birthday. I was lucky enough to look it up through the student records just in time, but you did a great job making sure no one learned that it was today. You can’t be invisible for the rest of your life!”
I couldn’t take this anymore. “Well maybe I should, Sunset! Maybe I should just keep blending in until even you guys forget I exist!” She was about to say something, but I was just so strung up that I had to keep going. “That night when you guys destroyed the memory stone, I spent that whole night thinking about how much I really erased, so many people’s memories I snuffed out because I was so insecure. I was so jealous that everyone loved you despite what you did, while no one even knew my name. But that’s still not an excuse for what I did.”
That pit from my stomach felt much lighter, but it was still just a bittersweet feeling. “I’ve never felt so ashamed in my entire life, you may not share my thoughts, but I just can’t help but think that I deserve to just stay hidden. You understand that, right?”
I wasn’t really paying much attention when I was talking, so imagine my surprise when I heard Sunset…chuckling. I turned to see that she actually was trying to hold it in, and failing. I couldn’t believe it, she wasn’t laughing at me, right?
“Hey,” She suddenly said, getting my attention, “you know, I can understand exactly how you’re feeling. I can also understand enough to know that you’re taking this way too seriously. What you’ve done may be unforgivable, but to be honest, turning into a power-hungry she-demon bent on interdimensional conquest is arguably worse. ”
I vividly remember how terrifying Sunset was in that demon form. I had nightmares for weeks. Still… “Well, I wouldn’t say it’s worse than erasing memories for the sake of quelling your own insecurities, but it’s pretty close. Um…where are we going with this?”
She gave me the same warm smile from earlier. “No matter what we’ve done in the past, nobody deserves to be forgotten. Even if you think you do, it won’t help anyone. You really don’t want to be forgotten do you?”
“NO!” I suddenly said, “I mean…not literally. Not even sure if that’s possible.”
“Then how about we move on from all that and try to make new, better memories. Besides…” She suddenly opened her backpack’s side pocket to reveal a box wrapped up in beautifully flashy paper, and along with a neat little bow. “I still need to wish you Happy Birthday!”
She handed me the small object which I wasted no time in accepting. The wrapper had an amazingly bright sunflower pattern and the bow itself was bright green with a vine-like patterns. I wanted to keep whatever it was inside so I wouldn’t have it all go to waste. Without another thought however, I quickly found myself opening the gift. And…
“Ten coupons for free milkshakes at Sugarcube Corner?”
I looked up to see Sunset rubbing the back of her head. “Yeah, I had no idea what you wanted, and I couldn’t just ask you directly, so I had Pinkie whip this up for me on the spot. I hope you still like it.”
I’m more of a fruit smoothie person, but I was so overwhelmed with so much joy, I couldn’t help but rush in and give Sunset the biggest hug I could muster. “It’s perfect Sunset! Thank you so much!”
I felt her arms wrap around me. “You’re welcome Wallflower.” She was so warm.
After a while, I let go of her, and besides the both of us clearly feeling a bit embarrassed, we were both feeling much better as well. I then heard her say, “You know, I told the girls about your birthday, and they were all talking about throwing you a party to celebrate. You should’ve seen Pinkie, she was absolutely ecstatic about throwing your first party just for you. Though I had to turn her down, I wasn’t sure if you were into something like that.”
“Well…yeah. A small little get together at Sugarcube Corner is good enough for me,” I said a bit reluctantly. Then another thought came to my mind. “But I wouldn’t mind if we went to the mall tomorrow and maybe…buy a new camera I could use for my Gardening Club.”
Sunset gave me a quick laugh. “Well, I think that could be arranged. How about we cash in these coupons first. I bet you’ll just love Pinkie’s Rainbow Supreme Shake. Probably the reason why she gave you all those coupons, but it’s not like you can complain, right?”
I looked back at the coupons, then back at the garden behind me, and back at Sunset with a smile. “Sure, but I still got a couple flowers left to plant. Can’t leave them behind in good conscience. Care to join?”
With a nod, we both started to get to work on the last few flowers, and at the end of the day, I never looked so forward to my birthday in years. For the first time, I have friends to celebrate it with, and now I can’t wait ‘til next year.
Also LikedSimilarAuthor
- TheNewYorkBrony · 2.1k words · 100 2 · 2.9k views
- JustNewHere · 9.1k words · 75 3 · 2.7k views
- PanHead 537 · 13k words · 16 4 · 1k views
- Slateblu1 · 1.8k words · 28 3 · 2k views
- Lightning_Striker · 1.3k words · 36 6 · 1.7k views
- Peni Parker · 1.2k words · 64 3 · 3.7k views
Stats
Page generated in 0.283 seconds
Total duration
1,029 users online
2,295,864 hits today, 2,921,617 yesterday
FIMFiction
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Follow & Support Us
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
Love it ♥
Wallflower is a disgusting person
9063830
Any reasoning to back up that opinion, or are you just trying to stir up some drama?
9063864
Drama.
Okay, read this, and my heart broke. And then it melted. THIS SHOULD NOT BE PHYSICALLY POSSIBLE!
9063830
in my opinion i agree my favourite character has always been sunset.
9063864
and personally it's not wallflower that i hate its the movie in general its like a remake of anon-a-miss and have the memory scenes would literally be impossible without sunset i don't like wallflower for a simple reason she hurt my favourite character emotionally and physically at the end and almost did the same to the other girls. i may say i can't forgive her but i may just need her to grow on me same with sci-twi i don't like her because sunset went through hell and back trying to get people to forgive her after turning into the demon and sci-twi came in and turns into the demon while stealing everyone's magic through the movie and she is pretty much forgiven right away. and yeah she had sunset to help the other girls forgive her and i know sunset was a bully for 3 years before but all through rainbow rocks the girls are mean to her then the whole anon-a-miss fiasco comes up and turns the school upside down. then the whole sci-twi thing and stuff and i personally don't like sci-twi for that reason. and these are just my opinions.
9064165
Dude, you completely missed the fact that Sci-Twi was actually pressured into stealing everyone's magic by her fellow students and Principal at Crystal Prep (Who was pretty much blackmailing her anyways), and ended up regretting it instantly.
9063864
she violated the memories oof not only sunset's friend, but sunset herself, simply because she wasn't friends woth her
I know liberal college kids less entitled that her ass
9064267
Maybe so but she was the one who made the device and saw the magic for herself she chould have destroyed it and leave it at that. But she continued to steal it. AND she was only PRESSED to unleash the magic after the cinch saw the magic so yeah the whole demon wasn't completely her fault but she chould have destroyed the device after she saw the magic. So she still played a big role in it.
9064328
Ah, but did she know the consequences or even understand what she was stealing? Again, no.
Jesus! I just wanted to write a cute and nice story not start a war...and as for YOU THREE
9063830
9063864
9064165
You guys need to calm down and stop acting like children! ESPECIALLY YOU MJP! If that is your real name! I doubt it is
9064714
yeah sorry just stating my opinion i'll let it go i'm being petty
9064470
9064328
Actually Sunset and the bike race should have made it clear to Twilight how dangerous the magic was. She could have destroyed it after she ran off but didn't. Because she didn't destroy the locket when she had the opportunity she turned into a demon.
9064734
Pretty sure the author's pissed at us as it is for starting a war in his comment section of his cute little story. No need to drag it on further with debates that aren't related to the story at hand. Not the place for it anyways, as there are groups related to Equestria Girls and the like.
9064742
Thank you kindly!
9064742
yeah lets just end it with we both have our opinion and we will be keeping them to ourselves if its gonna start a fight
9064756
Believe me, I was getting just as annoyed with it as you were. I mean, not my story, but I'd understand how I'd feel if I saw people waging debates over something that ultimately doesn't matter story-wise and clutters up the comment section.
I like it
My apologies, Horizon.
9065195
You're forgiven kind stranger.
I like the premise but it was difficult to get through as I would lose track of who was speaking. Could use an edit. Still, nice idea of a story
9065443
Could you tell this was my first "first person" story on this site? I'm not used to written in that style, trying to get better at it.
Good to see a well-written story about Wallflower. For being one of, if not the best of the EQG movies so far, especially plot-wise and concerning the motives of the antagonist, Wallflower hasn't gotten very much attention on the site. It's a shame because her personality seems to be one of the most relatable of all the characters and one of the most in-depth. But then again, maybe that's why it hasn't gotten much attention; something so relatable to many may not be as interesting to alot of people.
But your story is good overall and I liked how you dived into Wallflower's insecurities even after making amends with Sunset and how you portrayed their interactions. Hopefully you'll consider doing more stories in the future, maybe?
9083784
This is the best comment I've gotten so far.
I'm honestly glad you've enjoyed this story so much, along with your thoughts on Wallflower who I also like a lot. I think she needs more attention, here's hoping she comes back.
Really with all the negative junk throughout this comment section, your's is the best out of all of this mess. Thanks a lot, and I'll see if I could do another story like this.
This is a beautiful little story! I felt SOOOOO bad 4 Wallflower when we saw her backstory. The poor girl was ignored since freshman year. U really did her justice. Amazing work!
9151014
Thanks for reading! I’m glad you like it!
9152945
You're welcome.
Okay, got some thoughts on this.
First off, the Forgotten Friendship special was a serious gut-punch for me. Sunset was put through the emotional wringer while she, her friends and the students and staff at CHS were subjected to mind rape simply because of another girl's insecurities and petty jealousies. As sympathetic as Wallflower Blush was - and trust me, I sympathized with her - she still faced next to no repercussions for the damage she did. And while what she did regarding the special was reversed, there's no guarantee that all of the damage was undone.
That being said, I liked this story. Wallflower feeling guilt for her actions, and feeling as though she deserves to be forgotten after what she did? That's realistic. Sunset trying her best to pull her out of that hole and reassure her that no one deserves to be forgotten? Totally consistent with Sunset's character. You were clearly going for a sweet story here, and that's what this was, a sweet story. Well done.
9220274
Thank you so much for your comment! Glad you really liked it and thought it was realistic. That's always something I try to do with these kinds of stories.
9220274
You can make similar arguments for Sunset and Starlight post-Fall Formal and post-Season 5 finale, respectively. But as it turns out, they both got a lot of character development as they journeyed towards becoming better people. So while Wallflower is a minor character who is likely to never show up again, if she were a main character, she'd likely receive similar treatment. It's important to remember that redemption wasn't in the crater nor was it in the wasteland timeline. It was in the journey afterwards.
9430992
Starlight, perhaps, but Sunset? She faced scorn, fear and distrust from the rest of the student body at CHS leading up to the Battle of the Bands, and even those closest to her (the Rainbooms) were awkward with her at times. The fact that she weathered that storm as well as she did speaks volumes. Plus, she did have do at least some of the work rebuilding that front entrance.
Neither Starlight nor Wallflower saw any clear punishment for their actions. Starlight's damage to the time stream might've been undone, but she saw no repercussions for everything surrounding her anti-cutie mark cult. Similarly, Wallflower's immediate crime - erasing memories of Sunset being a good guy and then erasing all of Sunset's memories of Canterlot High - was undone, but there was still a lot of smaller memories that she admitted to wiping away that can likely never be restored, and that ignores her locking Sunset and Trixie in the yearbook office (which I'm pretty sure counts as criminal confinement). Them being redeemed isn't the issue - them not seeing any visible repercussions for their crimes is.
9431281
We may not have seen the repercussions from others on Starlight, but we certainly saw a lot of self-imposed repercussions. Those should not be underestimated and may in fact be the most important.
9431291
Perhaps, though there are more than a few that would disagree. And I've had the mixed blessing of having been raised by one of them.
9431281
when the memory stone was destroyed and Sunset's memories were restored, who is to say that all the memories held inside were not restored as well? Though it is never stated, they were all inside the stone, so when it broke, it would make sense for ALL memories within to go back to their owners. Maybe that's just me.
9626475
Nuh-uh. It was stated straight-up in the special that whatever memories were taken by the Memory Stone would be lost forever after three days.