• Member Since 3rd Dec, 2013
  • offline last seen March 12th

Awesomo3000


Film buff. Cartoon lover. Superhero enthusiast. MLP fan. Transformers devotee. Impressionist. Actor. Singer. Deadpan snarker. S'all good.

E
Source

After Adagio Dazzle's acclaimed villainous performance, three ponies have turned up at the Almighty Author of Life's door to audition for the next fearsome new villain roles. Initially excited to show off their stuff and become worthy successors, they turn displeased at the announcement of His Almightiness setting a new rule:

Any villains who are evil because being evil is fun are no longer allowed. From now on, all villains must have tragic backstories of being rejected and be reformed by the Mane Six in the end.

Vector belongs to DashieSparkle

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 26 )

I'm happy to see that these characters are aware of how awful they are as characters. Also Adagio your slipping, We got Cozy and she's pretty awesome.

Also Aria is best Sairat

Comment posted by TheApexSovereign deleted Oct 11th, 2018
Comment posted by zzzzzz deleted Oct 11th, 2018

9224306
Yeah I have to agree.

That ending got me. I did not expect that, and I applaud you for it. :rainbowlaugh:

More seriously though, in a weird way, this story puts some voice to how I actually feel now about the characters of Starlight, Stygian and Tempest: potentially good, even great, concepts wasted by the repetition of this "I'm sad and full of pain, and that's why I do these things!" You CAN have a villain with a tragic backstory, don't get me wrong, but you have to actually put in some real good effort to make them sympathetic instead of pathetic, and make their tragedy come across as effective instead of "woe is me."

"I have to have a point to make one." Starlight muttered under her breath before He continued.

Well said, Starlight. And that's a sentence I didn't anticipate writing when I got on the computer today XD

"For the love of Celestia..." Fizzlepop muttered, just barely resisting to urge to tear her mane out. "So let me get this straight... I get rejected by some kids once , don't even bother trying to make new friends or even see a doctor about my unstable magic, immediately turn to villainy and agree to team up with a tyrant to betray my kind and subjugate my home on the off-chance he'll maybe fix my horn?"

And this is what I've been saying all along about Fizzlepop/Tempest. I have no sympathy for a pony who turns her back on her entire kind, and goes to shack up with a mad slaver, to put her own people in cages and chains, all because he might, maybe fix her broken horn? :facehoof: Tragic villain of the year right there...

Comment posted by DAMN HAMSTER deleted Oct 11th, 2018

9224360
Thanks, mate. My personal favourite gag to write was the Storm King being a janitor.

9224454
That was a really good joke, too.

Poor Larry. XD

Ri2

I was going to ask where the Storm King fit in, since he doesn't get reformed...and then you introduce Larry. Wonderful.

This was actually pretty great. Though, what's up with these deleted comments? That's not a good sign.

9224328
Are you... using Bible quotations in a fanfic comment section?

9225068
Insults, bullying and insecure crybabies who can't handle me saying that their waifus aren't as perfect as they like to think.

9225083
I did, but surely you can understand why that would get you some incredulous responses?

9225092
yeah I understand. I just think is funny in some twisted way to make someone have to look up what im trying to tell them

9225090
You can report those, you know.

9225099
...That's not exactly twisted, but okay.

9224489
Either that or Fizzlepop starting to explain how she got her broken horn and scar before the Author interrupts her.

9225178
That was a really good joke too. Especially all the noodle implements involved.

Fizzle should probably be grateful. An Ursa Minor-inflicted scar is significantly less embarrassing than whatever happened there... :rainbowlaugh:

Silly ponies. Didn't you know that redemption is nothing more than a magic wand that you can wave over characters and instantly cure them of all guilt, culpability and consequence? It's not like it's a deep and meaningful process requiring remorse, repentance, soul-searching and, above all, change. All it requires is a switch to be flipped and *Bing* instant good guy. Heck, you don't even have to act any different - keep doing selfish, mean or just plain monstrous things to your heart's content, and it won't matter. After all, you're redeemed and that means you can't do anything wrong. Besides, it doesn't matter because, as we all know, having a sympathetic backstory automatically absolves you of any guilt for your despicable actions.

...

...

So, unrelated, I liked this story.

i did not like

Comment posted by Splashtraveler47 deleted Apr 7th, 2021

This was very funny, and brilliantly lampoons the atrocious writing the villains had in later years (not to mention the chronic underuse of the Pillars).

I was a little surprised DT wasn't in there, but nontheless a good story.

"But it's okay because the cosmic beings will believe you have a point." His Almightiness responded proudly. "Writing tip Number 5238: 'Villains with a point are always great.'"

Not wrong

"W-Wait, what?" She spluttered. "But I-I nearly destroyed time itself! I don't have to suffer consequences for my actions or go through a redemption arc? Y'know, earn everypony's trust back like that Sunset Shimmer girl did?"

I honestly still think both of them being forgiven is BS.

"So I don't try talking to them about how I'm feeling?" Stygian asked, now completely against this assigned role. "My very first instinct is to go behind their backs and steal from them before I even become a villain?"

Honestly, after meeting starswirl I don’t blame him for not talking to them first.

"But if you have to rely on supplementary material in order for a story element to make more sense or a villain's motivations to be more fleshed-out, doesn't that make the story or villain poorly-written because the writer couldn't be bothered to explain it? I mean, supplementary material is supposed to provide additional information, not complete an incomplete tale."

Is that true? I’m not a writer so I’m not sure.

"And because of your out-of-control magic, your friends don't want to play with you anymore which causes you to grow bitter, abandon the idea of friendship and run away. And you eventually team up with the Storm King to conquer Canterlot and the Princesses so he'll use their magic to give you your horn back."

I wish they explained that more.

Login or register to comment