• Member Since 24th Mar, 2012
  • offline last seen Oct 23rd, 2023

Jacob Applehoof


Hello everypony,this is your friendly every day earth pony. I run a general store outside of Ponyville's orchards,and ill happily help any pony in need

T

Octavia has always been prim and proper, but one left out detail on a note leads the mare on an adventure into the depths of romance. (Note, some references will be made to my current work Trixie's Redemption, so reading the first few chapters of that story will help you understand a few references).

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 34 )

before you spam the comment box...i shall continue this story soon...but for now, i shall work on more Trixie's Redemption :trixieshiftright::trollestia:

I congratulate you sir! I can't wait for more.

I'm not really a big fan of TrixDash, (more of a TwiDash), but it fits quite well. The Rarity and Fluttershy mix works as well, I have learned that from A Bluebirds Song.
I have found some small mistakes, but I will keep my mouth shut about them as I am much worst in my story.
Two mustaches now, three more when it's done :twilightsmile:
:moustache: :moustache:

I also give you one of these:
images.4chan.org/mlp/src/1337903752727.jpg

644657

Your mustaches are appreciated, and I rebuttal with a review of your comment. It was well formatted, and well written, so I shall give you two Twilight's and a trollestia :twilightsheepish::twilightblush::trollestia:

If I was the one to call the shots and give people the schemes to write about, I would give them these choices:
images.4chan.org/mlp/src/1337925615960.jpg

How the best way to phrase this...

This isn't my slice of Pie.

644776

fair enough, but i never made you read it, and dont plan on changing my writing style as long as many enjoy my work :rainbowkiss:

TrixDash EWWW(LEST LIKED SHIP OF MINE) But this is a really good story!

644999 haha, both characters go through a maturing process in my other story, Trixie's Redemption...if you liked this story...read that one, the shipping makes more sence that way :rainbowlaugh::trixieshiftleft:

Well I can say I enjoyed this story very much and I will check out your other story as well,:rainbowdetermined2:

I also give you a Scootaloo
:scootangel:
For luck.

645501no thanks, im not hungry :rainbowlaugh:

644915
Hey at least I gave your work a shot before I tried to judge it.
And it isn't your style per se as I liked some of your other works.

Best way to describe it is I wanted Apple Pie and I got was lemon meringue pie.

646334 k...but my rebuttle is that even if you didnt want merrange, it was good merrange. it should be judged on how good of a merange it is. No one goes to a pie judging contest and marks it down for being "not my kind of thing"...just my kind of thing. I judge a story on how good it is in the genra is put under. A clopfic wont be graded next to a normal story :rainbowderp:

I must say, that was really quite good!
A few mistakes here and there, but nothing terribly noticeable, so I won't point them out. :twilightsmile:
But one thing:
WHY DID YOU SMASH VINYL'S GOGGLES?! WHY?!:raritycry:

*ahem* Anyway, very good show, I look forward to the next update!

--TwilitLightning

651505

Haha, cuz she had to hulk smash something,..and a glowstick would have gotten everywhere :rainbowwild::trollestia:

Jeez, I am having way too many awesome stories to follow. I should start prioritizing. This story shall be a spot #2..........

keep up the good work!!!! Following and waiting for an update!!

This is the best kind of shipping, Tavi-Scratch. I probably should be finishing my story, but this awesomeness keeps distracting me

676439

Daw, your sweet. If your in the mood, check out my other story, Trixie's Redemption. I update it twice a week...so it will be updating alot quicker than this one. Love the comment and your support...you rock, woo hoo.

:rainbowkiss::trixieshiftleft::trollestia::facehoof:

678278
I shall do that, and I thank you for making awesome stories.
I suppose I should give some constructive criticism, I would suggest that you proofread your stories for grammar before you submit them. Bam I helped. Now get writing. :twilightsmile:

681116

I am lazy though. Doing this as just a hobby nets me no cash, so expect two updates a week on this story...once a month on side projects. :rainbowwild:

681574
Haha! Well constant updates are good enough for me! My own story is taking forrrrrevveeerrrr to finish. I probably should step up on that. I shall stop bothering you now :twilightsmile:

681574

So I went looking for your other story, and damned if I can find the thing. :ajbemused: According to your profile, it doesn't exist.

690794 ...sir...please check the box that is marked "view mature" at the top panel...or something. Oh, mouse over your profile...it will be the bottom option :twilightsmile:

817326

Checked that box when I set up my account. :rainbowhuh: I have no problems seeing other mature stories, just this one.

819954

:eeyup: That worked. Thanks!

I want her to her me at my best
Spelling mistake for Vinyl?
Other than that, great fic!:yay:

1097056

fixed...thanks...I'm also casually playing games...found here,

1299686 you like it? By all means spread the word if you wish for more...this is the least popular of my stories, and I'll need ever mouth I can find...that sentence went someplace horrid :twilightblush:

OK....So...Celestia is a bit outta character. When has she ever really demanded something?
Why would she demand something like this?
Why would she be willing to rip apart lovers for something this small?
Why would Rarity, the best known romanticist, rip them apart only feeling a bit ashamed?
I'm pretty sure usually, upon seeing a scene like she had ripped Octavia from, she would have felt really bad and tried to not go through with what she did.
Why did Twilight, who got them together in the first place, allow this. She never spoke up, she never talked to her after the show.

It's like you introduce someone, give them a small part, and then throw them to the side to look pretty.

So yeah. That's why I'm giving this a thumbs down. Good day and good luck in future endeavors.

2038729 as far as Celestia, she was never told that Octavia would be against the offer, only Rarity relayed the information. And as much as Rarity tries to set them up, her own dreams for fame were more powerful, and she decided glory would outweigh love. Twilight...well, she wasn't there. She was only a small role because she only needed a small role. If you remember, they were at Vinyl's house when Rarity took Octavia, and Twilight and Vinyl never had a deep relationship to which trust could be given. Besides that, I don't think Vinyl would have gone to see Twilight because it would admit defeat, and she is known for her stubbornness. Think about that...

2039036

Twilight...well, she wasn't there.

both unicorns. She quickly identified them as Twilight and Rarity

Unless you thought I meant Vinyls show or her house then yes, she wasn't there. But however she was at the act. She tried setting Octavia up many times and must by then had heard something about it. With how far ahead she was thinking with the two when she first thought they would work I would think her hope would have been brought back up by them living together. Still It surprises me that someone who got Octavia so many gigs and "Dates" wouldn't even speak to her after something as big as playing for the princess. Maybe a question or something. "How's it going?" "How ya been since everything you owned went down in a fiery blaze?" Ya know? Something.


as much as Rarity tries to set them up, her own dreams for fame were more powerful

Rarity is the element of Generosity. Yet she "selfishly" went through such a thing for her own goals.


I hope this will not somehow devolve into an argument. I simply wished to put out my points to explain why I voted the story the way I did so that you would understand. I know that around this site far too many people simple vote down and leave without explaining why.

Ok ok ok. u did not just say that was ur least popular story. That was the best story I have ever read and I honestly just made an account in this website just so I could comment back to that because what u just said was a lie. Please make more this story soon. :)

Login or register to comment