• Member Since 15th Feb, 2012
  • offline last seen Last Wednesday

Noratcat


E

Little Apple Bloom has been feeling neglected and unappreciated at home as of late. Yet one day she discovers a door leading to a fantastic world. And while all seems perfect, she soon finds it hides a terrifying secret, one that could cost her dearly. MLP FIM adaption of the film Coraline.

Chapters (11)
Comments ( 23 )

Good solid start except from grammar mistakes, but a good start none the less.:twilightsmile::raritywink:

5318980 sigh. Of course there are grammar mistakes. Well at least people seem to like it. That's what matters most.

5319164 Still I look forward to seeing more, I like where it's going.:twilightsmile::raritywink: If you need someone to bounce ideas of off, I be happy o help.

5319365 Well this story is already done. I just have been uploading it bit by bit

5319485 I see, well maybe next time.:twilightsmile:

This just gets better and better.:twilightsmile:

(Note, before reading)

OMC I love Coraline...

I can't believe someone would have done something like this

Before even reading any of it I give it 5 :yay:s

Comment posted by Brony Pacific 4023 deleted Feb 20th, 2015

Please disregard my last comment, this reminds me of the poem La Belle Dame sans Merci. A very interesting tale.

Option B... Zecora believe her, she could very well, send a message to Princess Celestia and the fury of the sun could destroy the monster


Why is that no one think in option B?

Maybe because it's too easy and then is not funny or there is no story

Damnit, I was going to do a Coraline spoof with scootaloo!

5685691 You could still do it.

5687092 Really? That's pretty cool of you, thanks!

5687092 It occurred to me that my comment about not wanting to rip you off may come off as sarcastic, but I just wanted to say that I was being genuine. Also, thanks for not caring if i did my own coraline crossover.

Keep it up. It getting good.

This is actually quite good. Coraline is a hard fandom to find a good fic for. And Apple Bloom makes the most sense to fill the role of Coraline.

8538411
Thank you. To be honest this is the only one of my fanfictions to make it onto the recommended list on tv tropes.

9126445
Thank you! I'm glad this story is getting recognized.

"Come to my parlor, leave your world behind."

Said the spider to the fly.

"NO WAY!" Apple Bloom forcefully pushed the box away. "Y'all aren't putting buttons in my eyes!"

Thank you for being sensible!

Almost perfect but missing a detail, the eyes. The drawer opened, revealing a selection of buttons, some big, some small, various colors, but he went for a traditional color, black of course.

Quick correction: She instead of He

Apple Bloom let out pout. Her sister had been grumpy ever since the weather mishap, especially when she got caught in the rain, coming inside soaking wet to the bone. That or the combination of working in such conditions could make anyone cranky.

It should be "Apple Bloom pouted" or "Apple Bloom pouted in response" or something along those lines. Or even "Apple Bloom let out a pout."

“That tears it!” the little filly declared, storming out of the house. As the door slammed behind her, the sound awoke a certain mare.

I don't think I've heard of "That tears it!" before but I believe it would be better as "That does it!" or "That's it!".

honestly though, Apple Bloom loved her family, but sometimes she felt a tad out of place. Well, very little moments. However it was times such as these where she truly felt out of place. They were all apple farmers. It showed upon their cutie marks, something all adult ponies had. Applejack had three red apples, Big Mac had an apple half and Granny Smith had an apple pie. Where as Apple Bloom? Well as a certain pair of school bullies would say, she was a blank flank. She had tried to find her talent in apple's as her family, but that didn't turn out so well. In fact the first day she mostly just terrified the customer's with her overeagerness.

Quite a few here, "honestly" should be capitalized, and I think "Well very little moments" would be better phrased as "Well, very few moments." Also, "Where as Apple Bloom?" would be better along the lines of "Where was Apple Bloom's?" since I think that was a typo :twilightblush: . "customer's" should just be "customers" without the apostrophe since that would indicate that you're talking about something a customer owns.

Apple Bloom’s fell down in disappointment.

I think you meant "Apple Bloom's ears fell down in disappointment."

Apple Bloom shot the ca a dirty look before following Rarity upward.

It's always the typos that get ya, "cat" instead of "ca".

Rarity called. I’ve brought one of your friends to see you.”

Forgot an apostrophe here.

“Hey Sweetie, Ah heard you weren’t feeling well so Ah wanted.”

Not really a typo or anything but just a quick suggestion, with quotes where the character stops mid sentence I recommend either using "wanted-" to indicate a sudden pause or "wanted..." to indicate the character drifting off.

It brought a small grin to her face.

Another small suggestion, often times the word grin can be associated with a large toothy smile so it can fell awkward to see "small grin". There isn't necessarily anything wrong with it, it's more so personal preference than anything.

“Dyeah dye think it was da-da.” Sweetie Belle’s face began to spasm in a twitch.

Again, same the previous one with the sudden pause, it also helps the reader understand what the character is doing especially since this character's dialogue is a bit hard to read due to the fact that she's sick. I was honestly confused with the sentence until I reread it.

Apple bloom let out a yelp as her face was sprayed with……well…..it didn’t need to be said.

Personally, I find that "..." is always the best amount to use when it comes to ellipses, but again this is more so a preference.

“Scootaloo what happened?” Apple Bloom said after her initial “hello”, but didn’t bother asking “Ya wanna hang out?”.

This relates to something I prefer and you don't have to listen to this bit, but with longer sentences the characters wanted to say but didn't end up saying I find it best to use ' instead of ". This is more so something that just looks better to me but isn't a huge issue.

About now, home seemed more fun, and it probably would be dinner soon.

For some reason this sentence felt awkward to me? Not sure how to put it, I would probably word it "Right about now, home seemed a lot more fun, and it would probably be dinner time soon."

Of course being as young as he was, and the species barrier, it would rather difficult.

"It would be rather difficult", just a missing word, happens all the time. :twilightsmile:

Just editing and proofreading it since I haven't seen any comments about it yet, if it's alright with you I can proofread the rest of it as well! I am enjoying the story so far since the characters feel pretty in line with the show, I just think it needs some editing is all. Besides, it's hard to find a lot of MLP Caroline stories so I'm excited to see where this one goes! If you would rather I not touch the story then just ignore this comment or ask me and I can delete it. I don't mind either really! I know this story is old and this might go ignored but since I saw no similar comments relating to typos or grammar, I figured I could be the first!

10966606
You can if you want, but this story is old and my writing has improved since then.

10966606
Correction to my earlier comment, I just noticed you did mention this story was old. Like I said you can read this story and comment on it if you want. I've just kind of been focusing more heavily on my current stuff.

Login or register to comment