Page generated in 0.039 seconds
Total duration
763 users online
788,618 hits today, 2,658,435 yesterday
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Fanfiction
Designed and coded by knighty & Xaquseg - © 2011-2024
Support us
SubStar
Chat!
Discord
Follow us
Twitter
MLP: Friendship is Magic® - © 2024 Hasbro Inc.®
Fimfiction is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Hasbro Inc.®
you should have the prophet have a kind heart and have celestia see why he is there leader
2789786 Ok, so one vote for pardon. Even if the reason you want it isn't canon whatsoever.
Oh, and his title is literally Prophet, so you don't need the 'the' but you do need a capital.
That bloodshed wrought in this chapter was truly awe-inspiring.
Ouch. And here I was thinking that this won't end as badly as the Red Wedding.
2790167 2790158 Silly ponies, of course it was going to be a massacre.
2790263 Well, ponies are rather ignorant and arrogant.
2790344 That is partially the fault of Celestia.
Ok, it's all Sunbutt's fault. Stalled the advancement of the ponies for 'peace' and in doing so gave them an undeserved smugness.
So what's your vote on Prophet's judgement, punish or pardon?
2790351 Punish Celestia, go easy on ponies IMO.
2790354 Your vote has been tallied. I'll update the A/N with the votes I count, while I work on the between chapter.
Can't wait to see which one people want more.
Although so few people are actually voting
Have celestia punished with death
normally I'd say pardon, but i know that would mess up the entire story and possibly ruin future chapters. As much as i would like to see Celestia forgiven, I'm going to have to say punish
2790466 Not at all. If you wanna vote pardon do so, it wouldn't overly affect any chapters cause I haven't written any.
The vote will have have an effect on the story after the next chapter though since that is where I plan on implementing said vote.
I'm decently confident in my own capability to write either choice.
I say punish hard. Have Luna and all of the Mane 6 watch Celestia gets whats coming to her.
She shall be Punished. Mostly because I want Luna to take a stronger role here.
2790425 Same thing here, death is the only way.
Yeah punish it is. And if I know what you'll be doing then it wont be pretty and I will regret it for some weird reason.
but keep up the good work
2790709 Regret my work?
It's like you know me too well when I get creative
2790712-_- Really really? *sigh* whatever...but ive seen you creative and lets just say that I have to good of an imagination to see what you have done
cdn.meme.li/instances/250x250/34988098.jpg
s17.postimg.org/a759qh50v/primitives.jpg
Punish because they did warn her and tolerated their BS
2790796 I was waiting for these to show up
2790800 Apparently everyone except for the one guy wants Celestia punished.
We shall see the entirety on Sunday, when I put out the next chapter and make the official call.
2790812 if your going to do more voting in the future just do two comments or more and say thumb up here for her getting punished or here for her to be pardon that way you don't have to hunt down the comments for the votes
2790825 I don't have much else to do except sit here and tally votes.
Besides, it's fun to see people actually comment on this story for once.
I've seen more people post their opinion alongside their votes, and that's what I want to hear.
2790903 Do you read the author notes and then the chapter, or was that just a really long after thought?
And yes, that is a 'between the lines' view I hold on Equestria. While Celestia does what she believes is best for her ponies, her actions have led to an extremely oligarchic/diarchic style of government that is also very reminiscent of a semi-permanent technological dark age.
She and Luna hold the official power, while the nobles hold the influence to enforce certain laws they want to see put through.
Punish!!!!
Punish her!
Punish. This since less bloodshed pleases me. Blood for the Blood God!
I think the Prophet should pardon Celestia, but annex the planet as a slave planet.
I believe the prophet would pardon her because he is a leader as well, and I'm sure he has protocols in place to protect his people, at least to a certain degree.
As for the "enslavement." Even though Celestia's actions could be excused, there still needs to be a punishment. The annexation and enslavement of all the people's of her planet could also cause drama within the planet. All other species would blame the ponies and their leaders for their predicament. It would be interesting to see a hated Equestria, perhaps one who not only suffers the Prophets wrath, but also the wrath of every other species on the planet.
2792712 why does everyone keep saying the Prophet?
His name is literally "Prophet", like some people would say Commander, General, or Sir in the military.
His rank is his title.
2792773
I agree with The Reaper pardon her (after "gentle" torture) and enslave the planet to that way you still keep the Aetherian way as a brutal race, we can have more pitiful and broken Celestia in the future and I like the idea of the really hated Equestria
2792712 2794971 Ok, the Planetary Enslavement combo meal is now available with Celestia's pardon.
2795032
Yay
man I did not see this coming. how about this: twilight sparkle absorbs the seed kills all aetherians revives blueblood and leads the ponies in the steps of a now retired hornless celestia... why cant there be that ending.... I don't get why people can't find the right way to end a uselessly violent story. what are generation calls horror would be consider childish snuff films by hitchcock and other earlier book and movie writers. if you end this story as a shitty celestia dies and the aetherians get off scotch free even though the seed had not only the capacity but also the will and capability to end his enslavement I will be disapointed . also-and this is for slasher writers in general(not that I consider this fiction a slash I don't i just think it doesn't have a definable ending with any meaning)- its in my opinion that this kind a fic should not be shared with others but this fic was meant for personal reflection and doesn't really have an ending that would be appealing to a reader. I know this is selfish but now I am going to say something mean now: the only thing worse then a predictable happy story is a predictable slash fic because unless you get off on death grim dark and destruction( and actual thing look it up) you have to ask your self "why am I reading a story that desecrates and destroys and twists an important idea to myself( I am biasedly assuming this wasn't meant as a slash) "and every body dies the end" kind of story
I guess what im trying to say is I am going to finish reading this but I am not expecting alot...
CAN WE PLEASE GET A FULL LORE AND EXPLANATION ON THE AETHERIONS?!?!?!?