• Published 28th Sep 2021
  • 697 Views, 116 Comments

You, Us, We, Now - PonyJoel



Ever wonder what has happened with the Sunset Shimmer that exists in the EQG Universe of Spike the Fairy?

  • ...
6
 116
 697
This story has been marked as having adult content. Please click below to confirm you are of legal age to view adult material in your country.

Confirm
Comments ( 24 )

"If we kill Sunset right now, there's no controlling the Changelings. They will have absolute freedom to kill anyone to take the land..," Sunset Shimmer sits down and holds her head.

How would killing her change them being in stasis? Wouldn't knocking her out do the same thing by the logic. Yeah, I don't get the logic behind the changelings control.

"You also need to take Twilight and Spike with you."

Ok since you brought Sunset to Equestria might as well replace Twilight and Spike. Sure, why not? I guess potential for the mane 5 to have a second chance with a spike, though it not being the same one kind of lessens it, but since the real one doesn't hold any harsh feelings against them it's fine.

Pinkie giggles at the idea of it. She's glad that the backup generations are going to be useful. "Thank you, Twilight," Pinkie grabs her friends and hugs them one last time. The final group hug she'll have with them. "I'm going to stay here to monitor how many hours Sunset stays unconscious. You need to get going, now."

Wouldn't a better solution be to take human sunset into Equestria and I don't know have discord freeze or suspend her into an endless sleep. Much simpler than keep an eye on her 24 7 and I guess keep knocking her out. What if she wakes up when Pinkie or whoever is asleep? Yeah not really the best solution.

All in all a darker fic that I managed to somewhat enjoyed. Nice to see no reset button, though things weren't explained as well as I would have liked, but I'll take what I can get. If nothing else this was a wild and interesting ride. I'm interested to see what's next.

I would love to see a continuation with Pinkie Pie. It would be awesome to see how the world of EQG changed and to see a conclusion. Keep up the good work!:pinkiehappy:

11017083
she's alive thats why. Maybe she had one last command 'if you sense my life ceasing. Go nuts" they have ties to her like a hivemind they can tell if shes dead. In short she has a literal deadman switch

11017121
Maybe. It just seems too convenient that they were all well most of them were in stasis and somehow her being knocked unconscious doesn't change that yet her dying will. Yeah, it could have been explained much better, but what can you do.

11017098
Same here Dragon-In-Black, same here.:moustache:☕

11017083

How would killing her change them being in stasis? Wouldn't knocking her out do the same thing by the logic. Yeah, I don't get the logic behind the changelings control.

Unconscious is temporary but the connection to the Changelings is there. They believe their savior needs rest. Death is permanent which would disconnect with their savior. Giving the Changelings absolute freedom and go untamed.

Wouldn't a better solution be to take human sunset into Equestria and I don't know have discord freeze or suspend her into an endless sleep. Much simpler than keep an eye on her 24 7 and I guess keep knocking her out. What if she wakes up when Pinkie or whoever is asleep? Yeah not really the best solution

The endless sleep or suspension would be too easy. The way I see it, there wouldn't be a suspense to follow through in a world that is now bleak. Also, it's thinking in the now while Pinkie, Sunset, Twilight, and Spike are sad with what transpired. If you were in their situation, would that idea come to you that easy? With the emotions running wild in your head? The trauma of watching someone you love die right before your eyes?

11017293

Unconscious is temporary but the connection to the Changelings is there. They believe their savior needs rest. Death is permanent which would disconnect with their savior. Giving the Changelings absolute freedom and go untamed.

So they can remove their stasis on their own without an outside force, if they lose Sunset's connection? Or losing the connection stops all effects of the former master? I guess I can buy the latter.

The endless sleep or suspension would be too easy. The way I see it, there wouldn't be a suspense to follow through in a world that is now bleak. Also, it's thinking in the now while Pinkie, Sunset, Twilight, and Spike are sad with what transpired. If you were in their situation, would that idea come to you that easy? With the emotions running wild in your head? The trauma of watching someone you love die right before your eyes?

Considering, they were going to have Discord try to reset everything and the narrative even has Pinkie think about him makes it harder to forgive them not thinking about that, but whatever. Them babysitting human Sunset will be needlessly complicated. They are going have to feed her and keep her alive and since they can't have her be awake, that just gives them a heavy load to deal with, especially on her own as of now. Yeah, Pinkie didn't make the right choice, since she also decided to have Twilight and Spike leave with Equestria Sunset instead of helping her. What if human Sunset wises up and pretends to be unconscious then sneaks attack her. A lot can go wrong and valid excuse or not, she made a huge mistake.

11017325

Considering, they were going to have Discord try to reset everything and the narrative even has Pinkie think about him makes it harder to forgive them not thinking about that, but whatever. Them babysitting human Sunset will be needlessly complicated. They are going have to feed her and keep her alive and since they can't have her be awake, that just gives them a heavy load to deal with, especially on her own as of now. Yeah, Pinkie didn't make the right choice, since she also decided to have Twilight and Spike leave with Equestria Sunset instead of helping her. What if human Sunset wises up and pretends to be unconscious then sneaks attack her. A lot can go wrong and valid excuse or not, she made a huge mistake.

Well, that's the risk. No other explanation is needed.

11017328
That's kind of the problem with having an op character like Discord who can literally bend reality to his whim and have him be an Ally. You have to find an excuse or reason to remove him or have him not do it in order to have stakes. It's not your fault it's mainly the canon show for doing that. While I am glad they ended up not getting him to reset everything, it does end up creating a plot hole, one I am fine with living with. What can you do?

Oh. My. God.

11017121
In other words, 'If I go down, everyone else goes down with me.' says Human Sunset

😞 Geez. As if an insane Princess Twilight wasn't enough.

Well…I can’t wait for the next chapter to come out now. I want to see everyponies reaction to what happened, and all the events that have happened afterwards? Especially with us having replacements for Twi and Spike. Not the OG’s, but still a nice touch to change them up and put both of them back into Equestria.

11018212
The following chapter will be in Spike the Fairy. However, I'm not there yet with other chapters coming before it syncs up.

11018218
Okay. See it when it does come out. Now I REALLY can’t wait. I’m curious how the rest of the characters will handle Sci-Twi and dog Spike replacing the psychotic Twilight and new and improved Spike in Earth Land. Now I want to skip work and wait until it’s posted with how peaked my curiosity is, but I won’t.

Last thing, Stay safe, and healthy. You and your family, and friends. :pinkiehappy:

I feel things are going to go pear shaped after this considering the reputation princess Twilight Sparkle has in Equis right now. Hopefully Discord can smooth things out when they make it to ponyville.🥺

11019563
We will see what happens.

While I enjoyed reading this, I still think that Sunset and the whole "identity theft" plot should've had its own story instead of being a part of Spike the Fairy

11032837
I think that this story works fine as a side-story

11041040
Enjoyed the story

Wow, that was really dark. O_O

11207708
That's the idea

Login or register to comment