• Member Since 17th Oct, 2015
  • offline last seen Jul 25th, 2018

HedgehogofRed1999


I'm a 18 year old, GSCE student from England, not an actually brony, though is very fun to see the stories that people come up with. Brohoof.

T

Sonic had never really been able to let go of his past and as such kept it hidden from his friends, this has now come back to destroy his trust with them and when Sonic is whisked away to another world, alongside some 'special help' he is able to let go of his past for a while... but the demons and evils that this world holds with his new friends in this world prove that no that matter where he goes, secrets create problems and with his new friends who want to teach him the magic of friendship that sentiment is made all too true by their past as well.

Chapters (27)
Comments ( 18 )

Hey, look, a stereotypically sh:fluttershyouch:tty Sonic fanfiction!

Hehe, well can't please everyone, why is it undesirable to you? Please explain, I truly want to know how i have offended you or this is in your distaste.

How long have you read my story, or did you just skip to the end, I honestly like to know because your story states lesson of lie, which is the last chapter, please respond.

7267517 Dude just ignore the haters. Don't pay them any attention or get discouraged.

7267385 Hello Madam/ Sir, how is story distasteful to you, what you do to improve it or make it better in your eyes, and secondly have you read the whole story or have you just read the end, please let me know, I am not trying to antagonize you, genuinely wish to know because I saw something to the side of your name besides the like and dislike buttons that states 'Lesson of Life' which is my final chapter, please respond with haste, I really wish to be criticized for my work though fairly, please explain your reasons for disliking my story

7270004 Well...

It's a tragically comedic romantic crossover adventure with gore in an alternate universe.

The more tags you have, the higher the likelihood that you have no idea what you're actually writing and are just putting on all tags possible.

The grammar in the description is, while not the worst, somehow incredibly clunky, making reading it a chore. I can only presume that the story is like this too. If it isn't, fix the description's grammar.

And that's not even getting into the subject matter. "Alternate Universe" is often used to mess up canon to the extreme, and what I see doesn't make me hopeful.

Also, everyone and their grandmother has heard of these types of things. Nothing but warnings and prophecies of despair and stuff.

You threw me for a loop with the first chapter.:applejackconfused: Can't wait to see where the story goes

7270060

I have checked out your profile and you have the same issue on Forbidden Love,which is a; Dark Adventure, which is random, romantic and Sad, hm, not trying it seem as though you are hypocritical, just trying to find evidence to support your claim with the mindset of following in your example, which not all of your stories have this problem, it's just specifically 'Forbidden Love'.

Also, this story most of the tags i placed on the story, it is tragic and causes many of the characters much heartbreak, for reasons apparent in the Sonic comics and specifically for the main six, because they left their dimension for 5 or 2 years I'm still unclear on that after season 6. Additionally this all does take place in alternative universes and dimensions, specifically speaking, this takes place for the Sonic characters in a universe where Silver is logically canonized, additionally I fused aspects of Fleetway, Archie comics and the games into one stories, alongside a bit of Sonic Underground... this was my attempt to rationalize the stories of Sonic that all took place in different universes and combine them into one.

Additionally most Fanfiction, for better or for worse specifically doesn't focus on Chronological timings or specific events that occur... 'My little Dashie' , 'Rainbow Factory' and even 'Lullaby for a princess are all not specifically canonized, though do those get a pass simply because they state alternative universe? Most of your stories aren't canonized, M.A Larson never canonized your stories so wouldn't that also be screwing with canon?

Just some food for thought, though you make some convincing arguments thank you for responding with speed.
Yours Sincerely- HedgehogofRed1999

7270297

If i'm being honest I'm not the best at writing cohesively, having one event happen and then the next, though thanks for checking out my story.

Comment posted by Sakinah Mlpfan deleted Jun 11th, 2016

7270298 On Forbidden love: I didn't write that. The basic plot was written by one of my friends here. I just edited it to make the grammar tolerable, and gave advice and stuff. Maybe if you actually looked before making assumptions, you'd be more credible.

Oh, wait. I haven't read this story. Double standards, yay! I'll read a chapter or two after I've picked apart your argument.

Really, reading one of my semi-stories (I write, friend conceives) and then attacking it is not the way to refute my arguments. That's being combative, and it makes you look like an enormous idiot.

I attacked your story. Fine, I'm not going to deny that. The logical thing to do is defend it, but instead, you attacked one of my stories (as far as you knew) without refuting my points.

That's enough ranting about that.

I didn't make the tags for Forbidden Love. You're pinning something I didn't do on me.

And, about your tagging of this story (which I see you've fixed somewhat) the tragedy isn't a problem. It's the comedy tag that is. People misuse the hell out of the comedy tag and I have no idea why. Comedy stories are supposed to be there specifically to make people laugh. This story, clearly, is not meant to do that.

Also, about this universe... You're basically outright saying it;s a clusterf:yay:k. Instead of taking the perfectly fine universes you had on display, you rolled them all together and wadded them with duct tape. But I'm not stopping you; Hell, I don't even know whether it's that bad, you just aren't presenting it favorably.

Also, "fanfiction doesn't focus on specific events"?

:rainbowlaugh: You must not spend much time here; When controversial episodes come out, there are explosions of fanfic after fanfic. Take "Newbie Dash". There were a whole cartload of various fanfics about all sorts of events within the episode. Or the Ember episode, a whole lot of fics came out based on this one specific character event thing.

Also, using Rainbow Factory as an example to prove your point? There are dozens of better fics you could use. The only reason Rainbow Factory took off in the first place was because it was new and interesting. Now, the only thing protecting it from a wave of scorn is nostalgia, because it's just not a good fanfic. The plot is contrived ant the characterisation of Rainbow Dash? Out the window. Rainbow Factory messes up canon to the extreme as well, I've never heard of Lullaby for a Princess, and, as far as I can see, My Little Dashie is only connected to the MLP universe by a name. Either way, the examples you brought up are just as much of a mess as your fic.

Just because your story hasn't been canonized doesn't mean it can't have the same feel as the canon universe, and lock well with it. My stories (I'll admit it) intentionally screw with canon for a comedic effect, but you have no such excuse.

I'm enjoying this debate. Sorry I responded late, I had to go to bed.

7272222
So you didn't write it but you took credit? Otherwise it wouldn't be under your name, how do you expect someone to react when seeing this fanfic under your name?

How am I supposed to know you did the specifics, there is no indication of that anywhere, regardless if you were one who was keen on grammar etc, I said 'most' of fanfiction doesn't focus on chronological events, true many do focus on a specific episode etc, but i guess what I mean is that they don't base them off the show or even go 100% with the chronological order.

Like 'Rainbow Factory', I think it's called 'Allgrezza'/ the one with Octavia and Vinyl, sorry couldn't think of it at the time or 'fallout:equestria, those don't follow a timeline and yet are some of the best fanfiction around.

Also Read the actual story before saying my fic is a mess, maybe you could find something you like, but just like your accusing me of doing, you're also making assumptions on my work, maybe if you read it and pointed out legitimate flaws with the work rather than this debate on the description and tags " you'd be a bit more credible".????

7272497 The reason I put the fic in my fabs bookshelf was because I edited it and I want it to be more well recieved, for my friend. End of story. Stop attacking Forbidden Love and start refuting my points on your story.

Stop bringing up other fics and start refuting my points.

You have a point about the not reading, but still. I'll fix that.

If you mention Forbidden Love one more time, this discussion is over. Because it's not about Forbidden Love, it's about this fic. And, last time I checked, they are different fics.

Defend your fic and get back on topic.

Also, two paragraphs in and it's just as bad as I predicted, mostly because of the exposition that anyone reading this fic knows already. And the grammar is incredibly clunky and bad. My hopes are low.

You know, I'm reading this, and it's every bit as bad as I said. I take nothing back. Except for the bit about the comedy tag; "swanky new duds" told me that this will be a comedy to rock the planets and shake the stars!

Actually, it just makes your fic look stupid.

7272572 I don't understand why you have to be so harsh. So what if he writes a Sonic fanfic? Just because you don't like it doesn't mean you have to act like a complete jerk. If you don't like it, then don't read it and go do something else instead of acting like a tool. Just randomly calling a story sh*t without having even read it was uncalled for. You started this anyway for no reason.

7272236

Thank you for liking the story also update, T.I.W.F and me are now friends and squashed da beef.

Login or register to comment