• Member Since 22nd May, 2012
  • offline last seen Sep 15th, 2022

Quantum_Shift


Comments ( 44 )

Some spelling errors here and there and a few capitalization misses, but nothing major. And whats with the polygamist crap? Ugh! :facehoof: I really got turned off when I heard the mention of that! I mean I realize MLP in the past seasons has been predominantly female in population, but this doesn't mean they roll like that! Even in the show itself a couple is a COUPLE! Not a bunch of disgusting polygamists!

Sorry for the rambling, but I totally despise polygamy! The story is rather good. :twilightsmile: I will track and follow to see where you are going with it. For now...

Also, I liked the idea of having clothing as I too felt fur was not a substitute for proper clothing (I've got a thing for clothing so yeah.) I find it kinda funny that the female is kinda the "worker" type pony and the male is the "stay at home" type. Actually in our society nowadays its more even with male and females. Heck they are even allowing females to be in the armed forces as foot soldiers now! And I am ok with clop so long as its tasteful and written in as PART of the story and not just sex for the point of sex. Ya get me?

And where are you centering this story at? I see no mention of the mane 6 or anything from the Equestria I know of.

2040741
Have you not read the previous story? That one's still in the works, and is more focused on clop, but still. Same world, but it explains a bit more (and started as an RP to allow creative idea to take precedent, not story telling, so it starts as a weak story)

And chapter 3 of that explains: this isn't Equestria...

2042408 Sorry, no I didn't. I've been to tied up in my own story to really go looking around. I was kinda just on last night and had a little writers block so I glanced over the new stories list and saw yours.

2042452
ah, well, there's another story happening simultaneously-ish with this one, with a very similar name (just swap over to Z-Type instead of R-Type)

Oh, also, to answer your question about polygamy in this world, it's pretty simple: with most of the pony species in this world have anywhere from slightly to extremely disparate gender ratios, there's a minimum of around 3:1 females to males in best case scenario. As this is a pre-industrial world, that means population is more important than love and happiness in a lot of cases.
As such, small herds form as a base social structure, with larger herds forming the societal structure. The smaller ones are the families, and the larger ones are actual societies and the like.

And the worst case scenario? The Nightmares have a racial gender ratio of about 1000:1, female to male.


Oh, and one last thing: if you don't like the world, you don't have to read it. Polygamy is a central part of most of society in this story, so please be aware of this. But I hope you do, I'll be leaving some strong philosophical questions floating in the background for the readers to look for.

2042495 Eh I'll pass on that. Polygamy is disgusting and I don't see a single philosophical thing about it. It's pretty strait forward. Sorry, but I think I'll get off here thanks for the ride.

2042647
Can you explain why polygamy is disgusting?
And philosophical questions do not relate to polygamy. They relate to society as a whole and the results of visually different races of different social standings- something I think we're all familiar with, at least in theory.

2042670 Love is between two people! How can you honestly say you love each and every one of your herd mates equally? You can't! So what does that leave you? Jealousy, resentfulness, disrespect, ignoring some in favor of others, the list goes on. What happens when you're the only female in a group of males? Or vise versa? Some of them you actually have feeling for where as others you simply fuck them for the benefit of the population. How does it make you feel that you're simply around because you're needed to make babies? A machine called on when your services are required. That would make me feel simply like a tool that could at any time be tossed away in favor of a shiny new one.

Polygamy is for all its worth is socialistic nonsense.

2042745

Love is between two people!

So... you only love your mother, then? Or do you love your father, then? If love is only between two people, then there is no way families could work. Please try again.

How can you honestly say you love each and every one of your herd mates equally? You can't!

Why can't I? I love everyone in my family equally. They are my center and my anchors, and no building stands on a single pillar.

So what does that leave you? Jealousy, resentfulness, disrespect, ignoring some in favor of others, the list goes on.

If that's the sort of person you are, then you need to either work out your priorities or not engage in polygamy. I don't mind if you can't manage more than one person in your life at a time, but don't judge others just because they can.

What happens when you're the only female in a group of males? Or vise versa?

Obviously, you ended up there by choice. Why would you have joined into a group of loving partners as the only member of a given gender if you couldn't handle it? If it sort of crept up on you, and you're not comfortable, you should sit down and talk about it. Duh.

Some of them you actually have feeling for where as others you simply fuck them for the benefit of the population. How does it make you feel that you're simply around because you're needed to make babies?

Huh, you might have somethign here... it's almost... almost like what humanity did for nearly 8,000 years! Gasp, how could we do that? Oh right, because society said it was okay, so society thought it was alright.

A machine called on when your services are required. That would make me feel simply like a tool that could at any time be tossed away in favor of a shiny new one.

If you take a look at the story long enough, you'll see that that's the issue that comes up. In fact, it's kinda the central issue in this story. Except the being thrown away part. There aren't enough to go around. No more than you would throw away the Mona Lisa, a one-of-a-kind artwork, they wouldn't throw away a mate so hard earned.

Polygamy is for all its worth is socialistic nonsense.

I assume you meant "Polygamy is, for all it's worth, socialistic nonsense", to which I reply, "only if you can only love one person at a time."

Also, remember that these are not humans. You seem to have a really narrow view on this, which I'll allow to stand if only because you are, in fact, entitled to your opinion. And it's my opinion that you're wrong. Three cheers for the first amendment, which means you can say whatever you want. I only hope you try opening your mind, if only to look beyond preconceptions and understand that what may not work for you does work for others.

Look... I am not going to continue arguing with you on this subject as I feel its just going to end in rude comments being constantly thrown back at one another. :facehoof: And I will not engage in such immature nonsense. You have your opinion and I have mine. This is how it will end. Good day.

2043782
Alright, works for me.
Have a nice day!

It's very good and it deserves more views.

2077907
Why, thank you! I'm glad you think so. Free advertising is always lovely, but of course I wouldn't think of imposing you for it.
Though, ah, if you would advertise for me...

2077966
Will do! But both writers need to be in the mood for it, so I kinda need to find the right timing for me and for her. If you want something clop-filled, check out the other Wishing Star story, Z-Type. Lotsa clop there, if you haven't already stopped by for it.

For future reference:

Foal: Baby
Filly: Child female
Colt: Child male
Mare: Adult female
Stallion: Adult male

You seem to mix up a few of the terms in your fanfics.

2078625
Remember that all of these are from the viewpoints of humans who were not raised around the terminology.
Also, remember that the show refers to females as either mares or fillies. Or just girls.

As for Colts and Stallions, I've been fudging it a little for a combination of artistic licence and the fact that these are ponies coming up with this terminology, resulting in different uses for the terms due to memetic shift. Just as the term 'ass' has moved from specifically a type of wild onager, to donkeys in general, to the human posterior, is a good example of memetic shift in action. Just as, in the show and fandom, the term 'Flank' has been changed from the midst of the barrel to the hip or actual buttock of the ponies.

Languages evolve just as much as any living species.
(Now I have to bunker down and hope you aren't a rabid creationist)

Interesting concept very enthralled.:pinkiehappy:

2082598
Thank you very much!
Anything in particular that catches your eye?

This is very well written. I can hardly wait to see what happens next! :yay:

2111446
Thank you!
Receiving comments like this really makes my day.

I'm not sure if I've extended this offer to you or not, but if you come up with any interesting species to add to this world, please tell me. I can hook you up with a link to the species list doc, which includes around 20 pony-based species and a bunch of non-ponies.

2111697

I know this an alternate universe fanfic, but keep in mind that incorporating new species puts the author at a disadvantage in front of his audience because sometimes the author can use an excuse that the new character(s) use to ease their way into or out of conflict through ridiculous means or through rather quickly escalated means and sometimes the author won't notice that they did something like this. I am not saying that incorporating new creatures is a bad idea, I'm just saying try to keep the number of creatures to a steady amount. Also, giving creatures REALLY beneficial super powers or special capabilities like fyre could be capable of doing is not a good route to take either for the same reason mentioned above. Do not remove her, just don't make her too OP. (Overpowered)

2112351
Ah, well, not all Blaze-Ponies can do what she can. She's an actual, honest-to-goodness prodigy. Most Blaze-Ponies can't use any magic except their own racial magic, which is pretty much just manipulation of their 'servitors'.
The thing where she Awakened the fire was actually pretty much summoning a Fire Elemental, or maybe transforming a small fire into a Fire Elemental, but the whole thing is based on some pretty complicated spellwork that she can only use so well because she's what she is.

Also, she has a pretty severe range of disabilities. Snowballs? Fuckin' lethal to her. Water of the earth or sky? (rivers, ponds, lakes, rain, hail, snow) It'll harm her like throwing chunks of acid at her, to varying degrees based on source.. Ocean water? It's a contact poison, like getting mercury poisoning.
She can literally only bath in water that has been brought from a hot spring, or that has been tempered/corrupted from its origin by civilization.

No, the OP races are ones like Enderponies (natural teleporters or supreme ability, whose touch can dissolve organic materials into nothingness) and some others like Magma Slime Ponies. (living magma, naturally sitting at a couple thousand degrees kelvin)
Pyrelight is OP as a character, not as a member of her race.

Ooh, and just wait'll someone comes across a Thunderbird, or a Winterwing. Neither are pony races, but both of them are awe-inspiring.

2114317

Interesting... I'll keep this in mind.

2115219
If you'd like, we can move this conversation to PMS, and I can chat about how magics work in this world, and such.

If you're interested, just PM me with the tagline for it as Wishing Star Project Discussion

Anywho, I hope you enjoy more of this, there's still more ahead.

2160541
Smithing between sources of elemental force is an interesting process, especially when done in the right combinations. If/when this world industrializes, nearby nations are going to be screwed. Assuming there are any nearby nations, but those might be a world over or so.

After all, what can you do about an Earth Elemental that spews napalm, has a metal shell, flies with more maneuverability than a gnat, doesn't need to breath underwater, and can survive nuclear fallout, and the nuke itself as long as it's far enough from the point of impacts (around a mile or so away, to avoid the early shock wave)

Holy fucking shit. That's how to divorce someone

um.......... i'm going.......... unicorn.

2392544
[Query Not Recognized][Please Rephrase]
(Please explain further, as I have no idea what you mean)

2395044 i'm not totally sure what I meant myself.... maybe I should lay off the soda for a while.

2395457
Probably. What are you thinking of the stories so far?

2396356
Good to hear!
And remember, each Wishing Star story will update once every other week.

Heck, there's still one star that hasn't been wished upon yet. Be a good enough buddy to me and I might just give it to you! No guarantees, mind you, but hey, I'm still trying to find a sixth player who won't mind me being stressed all the time.

And who's available regularly.

And who has Skype.

Anyhow, I hope you enjoy the stories!

Aww.... and I was so looking forward to them having a four way... :fluttershysad:

2805952
That's not an impossibility. I just need internet to get time to write more.

2824975
I do have a couple small questions, one which involves spoilers, so I'll leave that one, but, I did notice that the two fics present so far happen to also be the names of games... was that intentional? Does that have other meaning?

Edit: Never mind, I figured it out... although that's an interesting coincidence, don't you think? Going to go read C-Type now...

2825086
:rainbowderp:
They are? Holy cow, I didn't know that... Thanks for pointing it out.
Anyhow, hope you enjoy the story. Feel free to ask potentially spoiler-y questions via the PMs, I'll respond as soon as I am able.

2826491
Super R-Type
Z-Type

As you can see, two very different games, but games none the less. I own R-Type, it's one of my favorite shooters for the SNES.

Edit: I did a google search, just because I was curious... There is a C-type, but unfortunately it's not a game. That woulda been freaky if it was, eh?
C-Type

2827273
No kidding...
But the letters refer to the protagonist's name, which is loosely based off of the name of the friend of mine who is helping write it.
Z-Type for Zach
R-Type for Rose
C-Type for Cole
A-Type isn't released yet
E-Type isn't either
and the last one hasn't been chosen yet, and I want to find another female writer who would want to join in. I have a couple of friends who are saying 'maybe', and a possible double for the last slot, if one of my friends and her boyfriend wants to do the RP.

Enderponies? Magma Slimes?2114317, You're mixing Minecraft with this, aren't you?

3104632
To a degree.
But the Slime Ponies were intro'd before, and they simply come in a variety of 'flavors'. Including Magma, Spelljelly, and the infamous Black Pudding, which is a hell of a lot worse than it sounds.

You wanna know what's really scary? Nightlings. They have no form of their own, so they take the forms of things that terrify you most so you'll leave them alone. They eat dust and lint. Not that dangerous unless you're scared of something with physically dangerous features, like a Blue Shell or something. Or pools of acid.

Login or register to comment